***************************************************************** 11/11/04 **** RADIATION BULLETIN(RADBULL) **** VOL 12.270 ***************************************************************** RADBULL IS PRODUCED BY THE ABALONE ALLIANCE CLEARINGHOUSE ***************************************************************** Send News Stories to news@energy-net.org with title on subject line and first line of body NUCLEAR POLICY 1 BBC: N Korea 'wary' on nuclear talks 2 BBC: S Korea chided for nuclear tests 3 INSIDE JoongAng Daily: North drags feet on 6-way nuclear talks 4 Korea Herald: Lawmakers focus on N.K. nuclear issue 5 US: FCNL :Say No to Funding for New Nuclear Weapons! 6 US: John Pilger: 9/11 Report "refuses to address" unanswered NORAD 7 US: EnergyPulse: The Energy Challenge 2004 - Solar 8 US: MoJo: Going Nuclear (Again)? 9 US: Fairfield County Weekly: Project Censored stories 10 Israel's Re-Arrest of Nuclear Whistleblower Vanunu 11 [NYTr] Fascist Israeli Regime Re-arrests Vanunu 12 VANUNU ARRESTED AND CHARGED AGAIN - MORE NEWS TO FOLLOW 13 [NukeNet] Vanunu arrested again 14 [du-list] Interviews Available on Israel's Re-Arrest of NUCLEAR REACTORS 15 Bellona: Russia not to pay penalty to China for delays at Tianwan NP 16 Floating NPPs and nuclear waste disposal to bring profit to 17 Bellona: An ‘ordinary emergency’ reactor shut down causes widespread NUCLEAR SAFETY 18 [DU-WATCH] Interesting Article at Ban Uranium Weapons 19 Bellona: Norway sponsored radiation monitoring at Polyarninsky shipy 20 US: KPVI: RADIATION EFFECT ON IDAHOANS NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE 21 US: THE ROY PROCESS IS STILL AVAILABLE 22 US: Lowell Sun: Tewksbury, Billerica to meet on water contamination 23 Bellona: TVEL Corporation to increase nuclear fuel production 24 Bellona: Truck with radioactive scrap metal stopped in Petropavlovsk 25 US: Las Vegas SUN: UNLV researchers tackle nuke waste 26 US: RGJ: Experts discuss recycling spent nuclear fuel 27 US: Tewksbury Advocate: Board creates new policy, perchlorate task f 28 Las Vegas Mercury: Backstory: Four more what? 29 Las Vegas RJ: Nuclear waste at center stage 30 US: Las Vegas RJ: Whistle-blower claims BLM firing over polluted min NUCLEAR WEAPONS 31 The Sunflower - November 2004 - No. 90 US DEPT. OF ENERGY OTHER NUCLEAR 32 [du-list] DU in the news - 11/11/04 ***************************************************************** ***************************************************************** FULL NEWS STORIES ***************************************************************** ***************************************************************** 1 BBC: N Korea 'wary' on nuclear talks Last Updated: Thursday, 11 November, 2004 [North Korean soldiers] North Korea has blamed the Bush administration for the stand-off North Korea has indicated it is not ready to resume stalled multinational talks on its nuclear weapons ambitions. Analysts believe Pyonygyang had been holding off in the hope that a new US president would be elected. But in their first comments since George W Bush's re-election, officials from the North reportedly said an early resumption of talks was not possible. Thursday's comments were made to Japanese officials in Pyongyang to discuss abducted Japanese nationals. There have been three rounds of six-party talks, aimed at pressuring Pyongyang to scrap its nuclear weapons ambitions. North Korea refused to attend a fourth in September. The communist state appeared to see no point in talking before the US presidential election on 2 November, analysts said. North Korea has consistently blamed the Bush administration's "hostile policy" for the nuclear stand-off. SIX PARTIES TO KOREA TALKS China Japa North Korea Russia South Korea United States But now Pyongyang knows the result, it still does not seem keen to restart discussions. "We understand North Korea is not positive (on restarting the talks soon)," Japan's Chief Cabinet Secretary Hiroyuki Hosoda told a news conference. Senior Vice Foreign Minister Shuzen Tanigawa also said North Korea was not ready to rejoin the talks, according to Kyodo news agency. "They (the North Koreans) said they were not in an environment where they could restart six-party talks in early stages," Mr Tanigawa told reporters. North Korea claims to have nuclear weapons and to be working on building up its arsenal. Experts believe the North has already extracted enough plutonium for six or seven atomic bombs, although this is difficult to verify as North Korea will not submit to inspections from the UN's nuclear agency. Missing Later on Thursday, Japanese and North Korea officials were expected to discuss the fate of Japanese nationals allegedly abducted by Pyongyang in the 1970s and 80s. Pyongyang allowed five abductees to return to Japan in 2002, but claims other missing Japanese are now dead. But Tokyo is sceptical, and wants proof the others have died. It also wants information on another two people whom North Korea says never entered the country. North Korean leader Kim Jong-il pledged in May to reinvestigate the cases. The abduction is a major stumbling block to the establishment of diplomatic ties, which would win Pyongyang substantial economic aid from Japan. The BBC's Tokyo correspondent, Jonathan Head, says there is strong public pressure on the Japanese government not to improve ties with North Korea until it gives a full account of what happened to all the Japanese abductees. ***************************************************************** 2 BBC: S Korea chided for nuclear tests Last Updated: Thursday, 11 November, 2004 [Students look at a diagram showing the theory of nuclear energy at the Seoul Science Museum] Seoul says the tests were only small-scale The UN nuclear watchdog has said South Korea has been illegally conducting secret nuclear tests on a larger scale than Seoul had previously declared. A report by the International Atomic Energy Agency said South Korea enriched a small amount of uranium in 2000 to a level almost useable in nuclear arms. IAEA boss Mohammad ElBaradei said uranium and plutonium tests by South Korea were a matter of serious concern. Seoul has repeatedly stressed it has no intention of building nuclear weapons. South Korea has admitted that its scientists conducted, without official authorisation, tests in 1982 to extract plutonium and in 2000 to enrich uranium - two separate routes to an atomic bomb. But the government has argued that the tests were on too small a scale to be significant and only 0.7g of plutonium and 200mg of uranium were produced. However, South Korea's concealment of its secret tests is seen by some experts as violation of Seoul's obligations under the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT). They say it could require the IAEA to refer South Korea to the UN Security Council. 77% enrichment The IAEA report obtained by the BBC said that South Korea had failed to inform the agency about the secret experiments, the BBC's Bethany Bell in Vienna reports. "Although the quantities of nuclear material involved have not been significant, the nature of the activities - uranium enrichment and plutonium separation - and the failures by [South Korea] to report these activities in a timely manner... is a matter of serious concern," said the report. "The agency is continuing the process of verifying the correctness and completeness of [Seoul's] declarations," it added. The report said that South Korean scientists had enriched a small amount of uranium to 77% uranium-235, which is close to weapons-grade. However, it said the average enrichment during the uranium experiments was about 10.2%. The report stated that the IAEA had found no indications that the experiments had gone beyond small-scale laboratory activities. Mr ElBaradei also praised Seoul's co-operation with the investigation into the matter. ***************************************************************** 3 INSIDE JoongAng Daily: North drags feet on 6-way nuclear talks November 12, 2004 KST 14:04 (GMT+9) November 12, 2004 ¤Ñ Comments from Chinese and Japanese officials suggest that North Korea was not yet ready to resume the stalled six-nation talks aimed at ending its nuclear program. China's Foreign Ministry spokeswoman, Zhang Qiyue, said in her daily press briefing that visiting North Korean officials have told their Chinese counterparts that it would make a decision on resuming of the talks after it studies the foreign affairs policy of the Bush administration in its second term. The North Korean position was laid out by North Korea's vice foreign minister, Kim Yong-il, during a meeting with Foreign Minister Li Zhaoxing and his deputy, Wu Dawei. At talks with Japanese officials in Pyeongyang on kidnapped Japanese citizens, North Korea said the same thing. Shuzen Tanigawa, a senior Japanese diplomat said he was told by the North Koreans that they were not ready to resume the talks soon. Copyright by Joins.com, Inc. Terms of Use | ***************************************************************** 4 Korea Herald: Lawmakers focus on N.K. nuclear issue 2003-11-12 Lawmakers of the ruling and opposition parties yesterday pressed the government to come up with early countermeasures to end the current stalemate in inter-Korean relations and the standoff over North Korea's nuclear weapons program. But the rival lawmakers put forth different views on how to achieve a breakthrough in the deadlocked inter-Korean relations and in the six-party talks on the North's nuclear issue. The lawmakers from the ruling Uri Party and the main opposition Grand National Party revealed their differences during a session for questioning the government. The session conducted yesterday marked normalization of Assembly activities after a two-week suspension. Uri lawmakers said there is little possibility that newly reelected U.S. President George Bush will change his hard-line stance toward the Pyongyang regime, and emphasized the need to immediately open talks between the two Koreas. "President Bush, who branded North Korea as part of an 'axis of evil,' could remain resolute in his position and try to solve the nuclear problem by a head-on attack on the North," said Uri Rep. Choi Sung. "Some worry that North Korea could become the next Iraq." Due to the uncompromising approach taken by Bush in the past, his re-election has raised concerns among some liberals in South Korea, the U.S.'s longtime ally. Resuming the six-party talks could be a solution, but a summit between the two Koreas should be held along with the talks, Rep. Choi added. Another ruling party lawmaker, Kim Sung-gon, said that if an immediate inter-Korean summit was problematic under the current circumstances, the government should review arranging a parliamentary meeting between the two Koreas first. (hayney@heraldm.com) By Shin Hae-in 2004.11.12 ***************************************************************** 5 FCNL :Say No to Funding for New Nuclear Weapons! Date: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 17:57:46 -0800 Friends Committee on National Legislation Legislative Action Message Print out this week's LAM and share it with a friend. November 10, 2004 The following action items from the Friends Committee on National Legislation (FCNL) focus on federal policy issues currently before Congress or the Administration. -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Say No to Funding for New Nuclear Weapons! Dear Friends, As soon as Wednesday, November 17, the full Senate Appropriations Committee may vote on whether to fund new nuclear weapons for fiscal year 2005. The committee is expected next week to take up an "omnibus" appropriations bill. An omnibus appropriations bill takes the place of the unfinished appropriations bills and is expected to include funding for the nuclear weapons program. The Bush administration has asked Congress for $27.6 million to continue a study on the Robust Nuclear Earth Penetrator (RNEP), or nuclear "bunker buster," and $9 million for the Advanced Concepts Initiative for new nuclear weapons. Sen. Dianne Feinstein (CA) intends to offer an amendment in committee to delete the funds for new nuclear weapons. The amendment is unlikely to pass. However, the bill will then quickly go to a House-Senate conference committee, which is expected to complete its work before Christmas. The House earlier zeroed out new nuclear weapons funding and may insist on doing so in conference committee. A partial or complete victory for nuclear restraint is possible in the final bill coming out of the conference committee. The result will depend in part on how much opposition Senate Appropriations Committee members hear from their constituents. Please contact your two senators today, especially if either is on the Senate Appropriations Committee. You can view the list of committee members on our Legislative Action Center. Just go to http://capwiz.com/fconl/dbq/officials/, click on "Congressional Directory," and then select the Senate Appropriations Committee from the drop-down list. Urge them to oppose funds for new nuclear weapons in the omnibus appropriations bill. Tell them that new nuclear weapons will not make the world more secure. Developing new nuclear weapons will send the wrong signal to the rest of the world that nuclear weapons are usable. In the long run, pursuing new nuclear weapons will undermine U.S. security. Contacting your congressperson is easy. You can reach his or her office in Washington, DC by calling the Capitol Switchboard at 202-224-3121. You can also fax or email him or her from FCNL's web site. Start with the sample letter posted on FCNL's Legislative Action Center, personalize the language, then send your message directly from our site. Here is the link: http://capwiz.com/fconl/issues/alert/?alertid=6631026&type=CO. Given the urgency of these issues, we ask that you forward this action alert to 10 or more of your local friends. Every fax, letter, and phone call is important. Thanks for your help! Background: Some civilian military planners and nuclear scientists are promoting the creation of a new class of earth-penetrating nuclear weapons. These weapons are sometimes referred to as "bunker busters" because they would be designed to burrow into the ground to destroy underground military facilities that are protected by 100 to 300 feet of reinforced concrete or rock. The Energy Department's fiscal year 2005 (FY05) budget includes $27.6 million for the Robust Nuclear Earth Penetrator (RNEP). The RNEP would use an existing nuclear weapon, redesigned for use against underground bunkers. It would have explosive power up to 70 times that of the bomb that destroyed Hiroshima. RNEP proponents claim that, because the weapon penetrates the earth before detonating, it would be a "clean" nuclear weapon. In reality, this would be an extremely deadly weapon. If detonated in an urban setting, tens of thousands of people could receive a fatal dose of radiation within the first 24 hours. More would be killed or injured by the extreme pressures of the blast and thermal injuries arising from the heat of the explosion. Still more casualties would result from the resulting fires and the collapse of buildings from the seismic shock that the explosion would produce. According to Sen. Jack Reed (RI), Robust Nuclear Earth Penetrators, "are really city breakers, not bunker busters." The Bush administration has repeatedly claimed that the RNEP program is a study and nothing more. However, the administration's intentions regarding RNEP go well beyond their initial claims. Energy Department budget documents show funding for RNEP increasing dramatically after this year. The initial three-year study was to cost $45 million, but the administration's proposed spending in the next five years would total nearly $500 million and move RNEP into early development and engineering stages. The U.S. has rightly criticized Iran and North Korea for their nuclear weapons programs. The U.S. has expressed concerns about the nuclear programs in India and Pakistan. There is also a growing fear that nuclear materials could fall into the hands of a violent extremist group, such as al Qaeda. Yet U.S. criticism rings hollow as the U.S. resumes its own nuclear weapons development programs. The Bush administration is leading the world down the wrong path. Instead of adhering to our obligations under the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) by reducing reliance on the most horrific weapons ever created and working for global disarmament, the administration is seeking new uses for nuclear weapons. Adopting such a nuclear posture is a step backward and a virtual invitation for other nations to opt out of their NPT obligations as well. -------------------------------------------------------------------------- FCNL's office will be closed from November 11-16 as the FCNL General Committee meets in Washington, DC for its annual meeting. At this meeting, the committee will set FCNL's legislative priorities for the 109th Congress. -------------------------------------------------------------------------- CONTACTING LEGISLATORS Capitol Switchboard: 202-224-3121 or 800-839-5276 CONTACTING THE ADMINISTRATION Sen. ________ U.S. Senate Washington, DC 20510 Rep. ________ U.S. House of Representatives Washington, DC 20515 President George W. Bush The White House Washington, DC 20500 White House Comment Desk: 202 456-1111 Fax: 202-456-2461 president@whitehouse.gov White House Web Page Return to regular view Information on your members is available at: FCNL's Congressional Directory Return to regular view Your contributions sustain our Quaker witness in Washington. We welcome your gifts to FCNL, or, if you need a tax deduction, to the FCNL Education Fund. You can use your credit card to donate money securely to FCNL through a special page on FCNL's web site. FCNL also accepts credit card donations over the phone. For more information about donating, please contact the Development Team directly at development@fcnl.org. Thank you. To follow these and related issues on a regular basis, we urge you to read the FCNL Washington Newsletter. Contact FCNL to receive the newsletter for free on a trial basis or click here to register to read it online. FCNL, 245 Second Street, NE, Washington, DC, 20002-5795 USA phone: (202) 547-6000 (In the U.S. 800-630-1330) fax: (202) 547-6019 email: fcnl@fcnl.org [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] ------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~--> Make a clean sweep of pop-up ads. Yahoo! Companion Toolbar. Now with Pop-Up Blocker. Get it for free! http://us.click.yahoo.com/L5YrjA/eSIIAA/yQLSAA/FGYolB/TM --------------------------------------------------------------------~-> To unsubscribe from this groups send a message to du-list-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com. In the body of the message type unsubscribe and send. Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/du-list/ <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: du-list-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/ ***************************************************************** 6 John Pilger: 9/11 Report "refuses to address" unanswered NORAD Date: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 18:00:06 -0800 QquestionsjohnXpilger9iiQreportX"refusesXtoQaddress"QunansweredXnoradXquestionsXhttpinnglobalZpress X-Temp-Subjectphrase2: YES rtX" X-Spam-Checker-Version: SpamAssassin 3.0.1 (2004-10-22) on darwin.ctyme.com X-Spam-Level: X-Spam-Status: No, score.0 required0 testsºYES_00,FORGED_RCVD_HELO, FROM_ORG,SUBJ_PHRASE2 autolearn version0.1 John Pilger: 9/11 Report "refuses to address" unanswered NORAD Questions http://inn.globalfreepress.com/modules/news/article.php?storyid=1016 NewStatesman -Issue November 15, 2004 John Pilger speaks out again. Last year, he revealed, that the WMD propaganda, "was part of a big lie invented in Washington within hours of the attacks of September 11 2001 and used to hoodwink the American public and distract the media from the real reason for attacking Iraq...It was 95 per cent charade", a former senior CIA analyst told him. Now Pilger wonders about yet unanswered questions regarding military procedures on 9/11: Iraq: the unthinkable becomes normal John Pilger "...Flying into Philadelphia recently, I spotted the Kean congressional report on 11 September from the 9/11 Commission on sale at the bookstalls. "How many do you sell?" I asked. "One or two," was the reply. "It'll disappear soon." Yet, this modest, blue-covered book is a revelation. Like the Butler report in the UK, which detailed all the incriminating evidence of Blair's massaging of intelligence before the invasion of Iraq, then pulled its punches and concluded nobody was responsible, so the Kean report makes excruciatingly clear what really happened, then fails to draw the conclusions that stare it in the face. It is a supreme act of normalising the unthinkable. This is not surprising, as the conclusions are volcanic. The most important evidence to the 9/11 Commission came from General Ralph Eberhart, commander of the North American Aerospace Defence Command (Norad). "Air force jet fighters could have intercepted hijacked airliners roaring towards the World Trade Center and Pentagon," he said, "if only air traffic controllers had asked for help 13 minutes sooner . . . We would have been able to shoot down all three . . . all four of them." Why did this not happen?..... -- NEU +++ DSL Komplett von GMX +++ http://www.gmx.net/de/go/dsl GMX DSL-Netzanschluss + Tarif zum supergünstigen Komplett-Preis! ***************************************************************** 7 EnergyPulse: The Energy Challenge 2004 - Solar Insight Analysis and Commentary on the Global Power Industry editor@energypulse.net. 11.11.04 Murray Duffin, Retired Solar energy is our most abundant renewable resource. An analysis of insolation in the USA southwest shows that using only the 1% of the land area considered, that has a slope of 7kWh/sq. m./day insolation, concentrated solar (CSP) can provide power of approximately 30 Gwe. With effective storage (as for solar towers) this potential could provide at least 3x the total productive energy of today’s economy. Solar energy generation can be considered in 3 categories, solar thermal, solar photovoltaic (PV), and solar thermophotovoltaic (TPV). As TPV is still a far future technology, only the first two will be considered here. 2004 may have been the watershed year for the development of solar renewable energy, although that may not become obvious for several more years. While there has been little progress in installations in some years, technology has continued to improve, and with rising costs of coal oil and natural gas, interest in solar energy is now growing rapidly. The new economic driver North American production of natural gas is reported to have declined by more than 3% in 2003 vs. 2002, and based on reports by the major producers in America, production in 2004 seems to have declined at least 3% in the first half, and as much as 10 to 12% in the third quarter y-o-y. Hurricane damage can account for less than 40% of Q3 decline, so it seems that decline of mature fields is accelerating. Against earlier forecasts of natural gas prices below $5.00/Mbtu for H2 2004, recent cash prices have been above $7.00, at a time when demand is low, and storage is at record levels. At the same time export demand for coal has caused prices to more than double, on average, for all but Powder River Basin coal; and we have seen oil prices rise 70% in a few months and are going into winter with heating oil stocks low and prices high. With possible brief respites, these trends appear irreversible. Solar Thermal Overview There are 2 major sets of solar thermal: Direct heating and cooling Electricity generation. Each can be split into flat plate and concentrating (CSP) subsets although for electricity generation CSP is the economic choice for all but small-scale applications. + Direct heating and cooling The mature technology is water heating for home hot water, space heating and swimming pool heating. Flat plate technology is common, inexpensive and effective and has been used successfully with gradual growth for at least 50 years. Efficiency can be in the 25 to 50% range, depending on design. More recent technology that is growing rapidly, and is the preferred choice for larger installations like hotels and public swimming pools is evacuated tube heating systems which provide much more heat per unit area, remain effective even during light overcasts, and can reach 60% conversion efficiency. Recently compound parabolic concentrators (CPC) have begun to be industrialized, proving very effective in evacuated tube systems. The advantage of CPC is that, by concentrating sunlight it can raise liquid temperature in pressurized systems to >300 degrees F, enabling economic absorption chillers for cooling systems. CPC is also effective over a very wide angle of illumination, eliminating the need for a tracker in a concentrator system. The California Energy Commission retrofitted and optimized a 20 ton conventional double effect (2E) LiBr/water absorption chiller to be solar hot water driven, and have estimated that such a system can be supplied commercially for Direct heating and cooling systems have the effect of displacing electricity, to use Amory Lovin’s term, providing “negawatts” instead of megawatts, and generally at lower cost than increased generating capacity. + Electricity generation (CSP) Thermal power generation is being addressed in several ways—and for different sizes of installation: + Solar dish concentrators driving Sterling engine generators. + Trough concentrators heating a liquid to gas system driving a turbine generator. + Solar towers using large reflector (heliostat) arrays to heat molten salts which, through a heat exchanger, drive steam turbines. + Solar chimneys using rising air from a large ground level greenhouse to drive turbines at the base of a km high chimney. CSP Details Dish/Sterling systems tend to be aimed at tens of kW applications for grid connected distributed power, and reach conversion efficiencies near 30%. Cost of electricity is still high, though there is a wide range of estimates. Widespread use seems likely to be well in the future. Trough concentrators get into the 100s of kW to tens of MW range, good for locally sighted factory power also at attractive efficiencies. The best-known examples are the SEGS series (now up to SEGS 9) in California. Recent projects have been commissioned in Nevada and Arizona. It has been estimated that a 100 mi. square in the Nevada desert could provide about 500 GWe, roughly equal to the USA installed electric power base. Up to now such applications have limited storage ability, so they are unsuitable to 24 hr. operation and dispatched power. CPC concentrators might overcome that drawback. These systems approach 14% efficiency today and are projected to get to 17% by about 2015. Solar towers (Power Towers) are MW sized for utility type supply and have the advantage of retaining heat for 24-hour operation. Solar 1 was operated near Barstow Ca. in the 1980s as proof of concept. Solar 2, a 10 MWe upgrade of Solar 1 operated from 1992 to 1999, demonstrating the feasibility of storing heat for dispatchable power and 24 hr. operation. Solar Tres (17 MWe) has been planned for Spain, originally to go into operation by late 2003, but now delayed to 2006, seemingly by bureaucracy. Towers in the 100 MW range are projected. Solar towers are about 23% efficient in conversion of incident energy to electricity, and can realize up to 70% capacity factor. Current experience indicates a space demand of 10 acres/MW, with promise of at least a 20% reduction. Solar chimneys4,5 are only theoretical so far, and seem to have captured most attention in Australia. They can be designed to heat water during the day to provide energy at night. Efficiency is estimated as 3%, but it seems likely that this can be at least doubled. Proposed designs have fresh air drawn into the heating area at ground level. Drawing in air near the tower top would augment generation with the sinking column of cooler air. In dry climates it should be possible to inject water vapor into intake air to further cool the descending air column. Current projected design is for 200 MW and requires about 23 acres/MW. Capital cost of $2.00/Wp is projected, but seems quite optimistic. For utility scale electricity generation, the best choices today are trough concentrator and solar tower systems. An excellent 2003 analysis for trough concentrators2 (based on 2002 data and projections) considers a necessary competitive target price for electricity of $4.50/MBtu, assuming a floor fixed at that level by LNG. We now can be sure that LNG will not be a major factor for at least a decade, and even then will set a floor above $6.00/Mbtu. This analysis showed trough systems becoming competitive at 10 Gwe installed capacity and 6 cents/kWh. It now seems more likely that 7-8 cents/kWh will be good which can be reached at 5-6 Gwe installed. Another late 2003 report3, using well reviewed data and analysis developed independently be Sunlab and Sargent &Lundy gives present electricity costs of 10 – 12.6 cents/kWh now, going to 3.5-5.5 cents/kWh before 2020 for trough and tower systems. Growing fossil fuel shortages seem certain to accelerate progress relative to these studies. Photovoltaic (PV) Historically PV has been seen as much too expensive for widespread use, having been represented as “the energy of the future and always will be”. 2003 saw a novel development that should change that conclusion. All of the pieces now seem to be in place for PV to breakthrough all the barriers of demand, cost and capacity that have been holding it back, but it seems that no one in the North American PV or electric utility industries has seen all the pieces yet, let alone put them together to make a picture Recent NG demand growth is largely for electricity generation. From 1993 through 2003 nearly 300 GW of electrical generating capacity was installed in the USA, about 90% of which is NG fired, both to meet Clean Air Act requirements, and to add flexible capability to meet peak loads. Base load demand is estimated to grow at least 1.5%/yr (6 GW/yr), but seems to have shot up by at least 5% in 2004 vs. 2003. Therefore NG fired supply, intended for peaking, is being converted to base load supply, leaving a growing shortage of peaking capacity. Now declining NG supply means that peaking demand growth can no longer be met by adding new NG fired capacity. However peak demand coincides with peak insolation making PV an attractive alternative. So, we have demand, at least if the cost is not too high. Can needed costs be met, and can there be adequate supply? In Renewable Energy World, Dec 2002, Auliche and Schulze (A) estimated worldwide polysilicon feedstock capacity for electronic grade (EG) silicon at 26,000 metric tons (MT)/yr, with production estimated at 14,000 MT/yr. With such a large excess capacity, poly suppliers have been happy to sell EG silicon for PV production at very attractive prices ($20.00-25.00/kg), enabling PV producers to lower their prices. As Maycock noted in Solar Today, Jan/Feb 2004, PV producers have sold cells and modules at cost, enabling very rapid industry growth in 2001-2003. System quotes as low as $4.00/Wp installed have been mentioned. Total world Si PV production in 2003 was about 0.7 GWp, having grown 32% worldwide while actually shrinking in the USA. A estimated that about 2000 MT each of “off spec” and “non-prime” EG Si were supplied to the PV industry in 2000. At 17 MT/MWp that was enough to produce 235 MWp in 2000. Maycock shows 2000 production at 288 MWp, which implies another 1000 MT from capacity dedicated specifically for PV. With perhaps 8000 MT excess capacity in 2000 suppliers have had no incentive to add capacity. However, production of >700MWp in 2003 has surely consumed the excess capacity, even if price may not yet have been attractive for the poly producers. In parallel, while technology is reducing the share of off spec and non-prime Si being produced, microelectronics demand for Si is growing rapidly. As a result, in the last 12 months the price of poly has gone from $20.00-25.00/kg to >$30./kg and is projected to go to $40.00-60.00/kg. These price increases push bottom prices for PV installations back to the range of $6.00-7.00/Wp. While there may still have been some stockpiles from prior years to work off in 2004, it is probably safe to say that PV growth will now be limited by poly capacity and price. To aggravate the situation, during the 2000-2003 period, poly producers experienced very low ROI, making it difficult now to attract the large increments of capital needed for conventional “Siemens process” poly production capacity. Unless there are dramatic technical advances, this condition is likely to persist for several years. John Schumacher has pointed out (Solar Today, Jan/Feb 2004), that breakthroughs are needed in both poly capacity capital and production costs, and in ways to get more collector surface per ton of poly. Fortunately, it seems that the technology now exists to meet both needs, and the only delay factor is time to recognition and industrialization. Schumacher7 has already operated a “proof of concept” facility for a new poly process that has a capital cost about 40% of that for the Siemens process and projected product price of In Dec. 2003, Origin Energy of Australia8, in conjunction with the Australian National University (ANU) announced a new “sliver cell”6 approach to making PV cells from Si wafers that is a classic example of “lateral thinking”. Origin claims a 12x increase in collector surface per ton of silicon, and a 30x potential increase in Wp/wafer. My calculations do not confirm these claims, but taking all yield factors into account, they can probably get to >6x increase in collector surface/ton, which is still a sufficient breakthrough. In 2004 ANU delivered a paper6 on sliver cells in concentrator applications, showing a 21% conversion efficiency at 20 suns. The Fraunhofer Institute has also worked with very thin silicon for PV and show 24% efficiency at 60 suns. Even at 20 suns and 6x yield/ton, poly scarcity ceases to be a restraint. In writing a National Energy Policy “primer” for the House and Senate Energy Committees in 2001 (which regrettably, but not surprisingly, they totally ignored), I estimated that we would need the output of 50 large factories for 20 years to install enough collector surface at 20 suns to produce 10 quads of PV solar energy per year. The sliver cell will enable 5 quads in 20 years with only 4 factories. What seemed quite impractical in 2001, now appears quite feasible. Sliver Cell Whole System Pluses . ANU notes that the cells can readily be connected in series, reducing the need for protective diodes and eliminating the transformer from the inverter. In addition to lowering system cost, these changes would also improve conversion efficiency to a-c significantly, thus reducing the needed collector area for a given Wp. Taking all of these factors into account (Schumacher’s poly + 6x surface increase/MT + elimination of diodes and transformer + light weight deriving from thin slivers + system efficiency) it seems likely that PV could get to an installed cost of $1.50/Wp before 2010. (ANU has estimated $1.80/Wp, but it’s not clear that they took all factors into account). In a concentrator system, when used for peaking power in conjunction with a CCGT, the concentrator could also preheat water for the steam turbine stage, potentially increasing CCGT output by at least 3%, at no additional cost. If a 500 MW CCGT installation needed 100 MW for peaking, the extra 15 MW of thermal energy would lower the total investment per effective Wp to about $1.30. With regulated utility type financing (cost of money 3% above inflation) the resulting peaking electricity could be provided at a cost near 13 cents/kWh. Historic PV electricity cost estimates have typically been quoted (see the Wall Street Journal Special Report Sept. 2001) as 22 to 40 cents per kWh. The average retail price of electricity in the USA in 2002 was 7 cents/kWh, and is surely higher now. Peak electricity price can be at least 3x, making conventional PV historically uncompetitive. (In some Calif. districts, base rates are 12 cents/kWh and conventional PV is marginally competitive for peak power now). At a base cost of 13 cents/kWh, even after markup for maintenance and OH, PV would be attractive for peaking supply across the southern tier. This base cost leaves room for attractive profit margins for everyone. I would expect NG fired power suppliers to start pushing very hard to have these technologies industrialized as rapidly as possible. Conclusions Solar thermal energy for hot water has long been attractive, and recent developments now make it attractive for air conditioning as well. Widespread use could reduce electricity demand in the USA by at least 10%, and this degree of reduction will probably become necessary as NG supply declines. CSP for electricity production begins to look attractive with rising cost of fossil fuels and very long permitting and construction times for nuclear. The technology is now well-understood and poised for rapid development with corresponding cost reductions. We now need an intelligent National Energy Policy (NEP), with relatively modest subsidies to kick-start the needed development. We can be very confident of successful exploitation. A major breakthrough in PV technology has now raised the potential of PV to the level of practicality. Production capacity is still a limiting factor. Lack of awareness is also a barrier. Again, an intelligent NEP is the key to further progress. Reliance on imported fossil fuel energy, with its attendant cost, security risk and negative payments balance could realistically be overcome in less than 20 years, with a government driven “Apollo Program” for energy, focused on efficiency, conservation, renewables and nuclear. Renewable solar energy is now positioned to make its contribution. References: 1) http://www.energylan.sandia.gov/sunlab 2) http://www.eere.energy.gov/solar/pdfs/3solar_henryprice.pdf 3) http://www.energylan.sandia.gov/sunlab/PDFs/Assessment.pdf 4) http://www.sbp.de/de/html/projects/solar/aufwind/pages_auf/princi pl.htm 5) http://www.visionengineer.com/env/solar_flue2.shtml 6) http://solar.anu.edu.au/pages/publications2004.html 7) http://jcschumacher.com/ 8) http://www.originenergy.com.au/news/news_detail.php?newsid=233=82 [Get Copyright Clearance] Copyright 2004 CyberTech, Inc. Want Contact The Author Email the author Phone: (843)849-6328 Copyright © 2002-2004, CyberTech, Inc. - All rights ***************************************************************** 8 MoJo: Going Nuclear (Again)? [MotherJones.com] [Mother Jones] [News] The atomic industry is poised for a comeback. But can it solve our energy problems? And at what cost? --> [Daily Mojo] November 11, 2004 On Tuesday, the Wall Street Journal that, with President Bush's re-election over and done with, the nuclear power industry was staging a comeback. Indeed, with the president's energy bill likely to pass in the upcoming months—it was defeated in 2003 by only a handful of Senate votes—the atomic industry will receive the subsidies and regulatory support it needs to start building reactors again, for the first time since demand petered out in the early 1980s. Opponents of nuclear power have argued that, because the industry cannot exist without heavy government funding, it should not exist at all. As Michael Scherer in Mother Jones last year, private investors won't touch atomic energy (the capital costs are too high), and the subsidies exist only because of the efforts of pork-minded Congressmen like Sen. Pete Domenici (R-NJ) and Sen. Larry Craig (R-ID). In the conservative National Review, Navin Nayak and Jeffrey Taylor this state of affairs, writing that nuclear power "simply does not make economic sense." Even so, some scientists and energy experts are taking another look at expanding nuclear power—which already generates one-fifth of the electricity in the United States—as a viable option for the future. At issue is the fact that, at the moment, there are very few other options for decreasing carbon dioxide emissions and increasing energy independence in the U.S. As Paul Roberts in Mother Jones, replacing our current hydrocarbon-based energy infrastructure with "clean" technologies and fuels will take many years, and will involve far more publicly-funded research and investment than has yet been proposed. In the meantime, nuclear energy cannot be ruled out categorically, according to the authors of a recent Belfer Center entitled The Future of Nuclear Power (PDF). The benefits of nuclear power are fairly straightforward. Nuclear plants, on the aggregate, are cleaner than hydrocarbon-based energy plants, producing less carbon dioxide and particulates than coal plants. A recent Brookings report noted that, owing to nuclear power plants, "carbon emissions by the OECD countries are about one-third lower than they otherwise would be." Increased reliance on atomic power would also no doubt reduce the United States' dependence on foreign oil. Yet even those who think nuclear power may be a realistic option point out that the current nuclear regime is inadequate. Matthew Bunn, a Senior Research Associate at the Belfer Center, that any expansion of atomic power will require improvements in three key areas: 1) avoiding accidents or theft of nuclear material; 2) "technologies that address complexity, cost, safety, waste management, and proliferation concerns"; and 3) "transparency in nuclear decision-making". The Belfer Center report notes that no existing nuclear technology can satisfy all of those concerns. The conventional "once-through" design, in which discharged fuel is sent directly to disposal, is the most effective in terms of cost, preventing proliferation, and safety. The main problem there is the considerable amount of nuclear waste generated. More recent reactor designs have tried to solve the waste problem by allowing for reprocessing and recycling of spent fuel—basically a scaled-down version of the reprocessing technology that the military uses to make weapons-grade plutonium. So which method is best? Science writer Michael Levi against the risks in using reprocessing. Such methods, claims Levi, does little to reduce the space required to store spent fuel. But more distressingly, rogue states such as Iran or North Korea could easily modify civilian reprocessing plants for military purposes. As such, many scientists recommend sticking with conventional designs. The Belfer Center reports that "waste management considerations" do not outweigh "the attendant safety, environmental, and security risks and economic costs" of newer, closed-fuel cycle plants. With public attention focused especially on proliferation threats and the possibility of nuclear terrorism, that argument could carry the day. Still, waste management remains a serious issue. Current nuclear power plants have produced over 40,000 metric tons of nuclear waste in the last 40 years, scattered in temporary, on-site storage facilities. The federal government has selected Nevada's Yucca Mountain as a permanent repository for the waste, which has become a matter of contention over the years. Environmentalists contend that Yucca is too unstable to hold all that material, and that transporting the waste by rail is unsafe. Recently in the New Republic Michael Crowley those concerns, noting that Yucca was "the closest thing to a permanent solution man can devise." Even if Yucca proves to be a viable option, however, it won't be nearly sufficient to manage all the waste of an expanded nuclear industry. For these reasons, the Belfer Center report recommends the creation of a "long-term waste management R program", as well as a "network of centralized facilities for storing spent fuel… in the U.S. and internationally." Safety is another concern. At the president's request, Congress recently renewed the , which caps liabilities on nuclear accidents, and limits the amount of insurance that plant owners need to carry. Consumer advocacy groups like Public Citizen that the support is unnecessary, and causes plant owners and insurers to worry less about nuclear safety than they otherwise would. Whatever the merits of the Bush administration's nuclear policy, it is clear that it will need to spend far more on research on safety and security issues. With all the necessary research that needs to be undertaken over the next few years, is it possible that nuclear power can ever be economically viable? Possibly. According to a Brookings Institution , entitled "The Political Economy of Nuclear Energy in the United States," the country has only turned away from nuclear power because gas-fired technology is comparatively quicker and easier to install, and because there is " little economic incentive to retire the nation's vast coal-burning infrastructure." If the current energy regime was ever upset—say, by carbon taxes or a "cap and trade" system for emissions—nuclear power would become more competitive. The upside is certainly high. But the country has not yet taken the hard steps needed to reduce all the downsides. - Bradford Plumer © 2003 The Foundation for National Progress ***************************************************************** 9 Fairfield County Weekly: Project Censored stories November 11, 2004 HERMA PHOTO OBJECT Project Censored is a media research group out of Sonoma State University which tracks the news published in independent journals and newsletters. From these, Project Censored compiles a list of news stories of social significance that have been overlooked, under-reported or self-censored by the country's major national news media. With the help of more than 200 Sonoma State University faculty, students and community members, Project Censored reviews some 700 stories that have been submitted for consideration, for coverage, content, reliability of sources and national significance. Here are Project Censored's 10 biggest examples of major stories this year that have been relegated to the most obscure corners of the media world. 1) Wealth inequality in 21st century threatens economy and democracy Wealth inequality in the United States has almost doubled over the past 30 years. In fact, the Federal Reserve Board's most recent "Survey of Consumer Finances" supplement on high-income families shows that in 1998, the richest 1 percent of households owned 38 percent of the nation's wealth. The top 5 percent owned almost 60 percent of the wealth. "We are much more unequal than any other advanced industrial country," New York University economics professor Edward Wolff told Third World Traveler . But that's just part of the problem. "Most Americans believe we take from people at the top to benefit those below," Pulitzer Prize-winning New York Times investigative reporter David Cay Johnston said in a interview. But our tax system is actually set up such that "people who make $30,000 to $500,000 ... give relief to those who make millions, or tens and hundreds of millions, of dollars a year." The United States isn't alone: Today, almost one-sixth of the world's population--940 million people--"already live in squalid, unhealthy areas, mostly without water, sanitation, public services, or legal security," John Vidal wrote in the U.K.'s Guardian . A recent United Nations report predicted that, absent drastic change to reverse "a form of colonialism that is probably more stringent than the original," one in every three people worldwide will live in slums within 30 years. Sources: "The Wealth Divide" (interview with Edward Wolff), Multinational Monitor , May 2003. "A BuzzFlash Interview, Parts I and II" (with David Cay Johnson), BuzzFlash staff, , March 26 and 29, 2004. "Every Third Person Will Be a Slum Dweller within 30 Years, UN Agency Warns," John Vidal, Guardian (U.K.), Oct. 4, 2003. "Grotesque Inequality," Robert Weissman, Multinational Monitor , July-August 2003. 2) Ashcroft versus human rights law that holds corporations accountable For decades the United States has trained right-wing insurgents and torturers, and toppled democratically elected governments--all in the interest of corporate profits. But rarely are the agents of repression ever held accountable. Indeed, many foreign tyrants go on to enjoy plush retirement right here in the United States. But recently lawyers have found a way to seek at least a modicum of justice for victims. The Alien Tort Claims Act, a 215-year-old law originally passed to prosecute pirates for crimes committed on the high seas, allows noncitizens to sue any individual or corporation present on U.S. soil. Human rights lawyers have pursued 100 cases under the ATCA since 1980. Defendants have included former high-ranking government officials from El Salvador, Guatemala, Bosnia, and the Philippines (including ex-president Ferdinand Marcos). The law has often resulted in victims being awarded millions of dollars--and in the perpetrators sometimes fleeing the country. But Attorney General John Ashcroft's Justice Department has set its sights on the Act, claiming in a brief last year that the law threatens "important foreign policy interests" associated with the war on terrorism. Yet hardly a word has been written in the mainstream media about the Bush administration's attack on the main legal recourse left in the United States for victims to seek redress for human rights violations carried out abroad. Source: "Ashcroft Goes after 200-Year-Old Human Rights Law," Jim Lobe, and Asheville Global Report, May 19, 2003. 3) Bush administration manipulates science and censors scientists Tampering with data that threatens corporate profits is much more widespread under Bush than we've been led to believe. One of the first White House moves--on the day Bush was inaugurated--was to fire engineer Tony Oppegard, the leader of a federal team investigating a 300-million-gallon slurry spill at a coal-mining site in Kentucky. "Black lava-like toxic sludge containing 60 poisonous chemicals choked and sterilized up to 100 miles of rivers and creeks," environmental lawyer Robert F. Kennedy Jr. wrote in the Nation . The EPA dubbed it, "The greatest environmental catastrophe in the history of the Eastern United States." Bush then appointed industry insiders to top EPA posts in charge of mine safety and health. In another case, a week after the EPA released a study to congressional staff about the toxic effects on groundwater of hydraulic fracturing--a process of injecting benzene into the ground to extract oil and gas, used by Halliburton, Vice President Dick Cheney's former company--the agency revised its findings in response to "industry feedback" to indicate that the practice posed no threat after all. In the days and months following the World Trade Center and Pentagon attacks, the EPA released more than a dozen statements claiming the air quality in the surrounding "control zone" was safe--despite evidence that asbestos dust was present in quantities well above the 1 percent safety benchmark. As a result, 88 percent of rescue workers suffered ear, nose, and throat ailments, and 78 percent suffered lung maladies, according to a Mt. Sinai School of Medicine study. Half suffered persistent respiratory problems up to a year later. In November the EPA arranged for Syngenta, the Swiss manufacturer of Atrazine, to take over federal research of its product, the most widely used weed killer in the United States. This occurred despite evidence that high concentrations of Atrazine in groundwater may be responsible for 50-percent-below-normal semen counts in men in U.S. farming communities. There have been dozens of scientists willing to blow the whistle--normally a reporter's dream come true. But news coverage hasn't come close to reflecting the gravity of the problem. Sources: "The Junk Science of George W. Bush," Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Nation , March 8, 2004. "Censoring Scientific Information," Censorship News: The National Coalition Against Censorship Newsletter , fall 2003. "Ranking Scientists Warn Bush Science Policy Lacks Integrity," Environmental News Service correspondents, , Feb. 20, 2004, and others. 4) High uranium levels found in troops and civilians Last year Project Censored included the United States' and Great Britain's continued use of depleted-uranium weapons--despite ample evidence of their acute health effects--among its top 10 underreported stories. Almost 10,000 U.S. troops died within 10 years of serving in the first Gulf War, researchers had found. And more than a third of those still alive had filed Gulf War Syndrome-related claims. In study after study, research pointed to the use of depleted uranium in U.S. and British weaponry as the culprit. But authorities concentrated their efforts into obfuscating the problem. More recently, the Uranium Medical Research Center, an independent group of U.S. and Canadian scientists that has conducted studies of Afghan civilians, found overwhelming evidence that the United States is also using nondepleted uranium in its weapons, which is far more radioactive than depleted uranium. Leuren Moret, president of Scientists for Indigenous People, has reported that a U.S. government study conducted on the babies of Gulf War veterans conceived after the soldiers returned home found that a full two-thirds suffered from serious birth defects or illnesses, including being born without eyes or ears, or with missing or malformed organs or limbs. In Iraq, Moret said, the defects are even worse. Sources: "UMRC's Preliminary Findings from Afghanistan and Operation Enduring Freedom" and "Afghan Field Trip #2 Report: Precision Destruction, Indiscriminate Effects," Tedd Weyman, UMRC Research Team, Uranium Medical Research Center, January 2003. "Scientists Uncover Radioactive Trail in Afghanistan," Stephanie Hiller, Awakened Woman , January 2004. "There Are No Words ... Radiation in Iraq Equals 250,000 Nagasaki Bombs," Bob Nichols, Dissident Voice , March 2004. "Poisoned?," Juan Gonzalez, New York Daily New s, April 2004, and others. 5) Wholesale giveaway of our natural resources Adam Werbach, former Sierra Club president, reviewed the Bush administration's environmental policy record and came to a disturbing conclusion: the record is not only bad--it's "akin to an affirmative action program for corporate polluters," he wrote in In These Times. For example, Congress has promised $3 billion in tax cuts to mining corporations to help them access natural gas embedded in underground coal deposits in Georgia's Powder River Basin. The Bureau of Land Management has calculated that miners will waste a full 700 million gallons of publicly owned water a year in the process. The Bush administration's Healthy Forests Initiative essentially entails granting logging companies access to old-growth trees--and then subsidizing them for brush clearing. And even the giant sequoias former president Bill Clinton sought to protect, by creating a 327,000-acre national monument in the southern Sierra Nevada just four years ago, are at risk for being logged at a rate of 10 million board-feet of lumber a year--a higher rate than allowed on surrounding national forest lands--in the name of "forest management." Sources: "Liquidation of the Commons," Adam Werbach, In These Times , Nov. 23, 2003. "Giant Sequoias Could Get the Ax," Matt Weiser, High Country News , June 9, 2003. 6) Sale of electoral politics The Help America Vote Act required that states submit their blueprints for switching over to electronic voting systems by Jan. 1, 2004, and implement those plans in time for the 2006 elections. Some regions are already using the machines. But those who've bothered to look into the new systems are sending up serious warning flares. A switch to electronic voting might seem innocent enough at first--until you look at who's implementing it, and how. Indeed, the transfer represents the privatization of the voting process in the hands of a select few fervent GOP supporters who've insisted on keeping their operating systems and codes a trade secret--meaning they enjoy absolute control over the entire voting process, including ballot-counting and oversight. There's no paper trail. One prime example is Diebold, one of the nation's top electronic voting machine manufacturers, whose equipment was responsible for the Florida debacle in 2000. Diebold already operates more than 40,000 machines in 37 states across the country. Many of these are in Georgia, which in November became the first state to conduct an election entirely with touch-screen machines. The other top two electronic voting machine manufacturers, Sequoia and Election Systems &Software, are equally suspect. Several of their executives have troubling track records of corruption and conflict of interest. All three companies are prominent Republican Party donors. Sources: "Voting Machines Gone Wild," Mark Lewellen-Biddle, In These Times , December 2003. "All the President's Votes?," Andrew Gumbel, Independent (U.K.), Oct. 13, 2003. "Will Bush Backers Manipulate Votes to Deliver G.W. Another Election?," Amy Goodman and the staff of Democracy Now!, Sept. 4, 2003. 7) Conservative organization drives judicial appointments Ever since the Reagan administration, the neoconservatives have pursued an aggressive campaign to stack the federal courts with right-wing judges. Their main vehicle: the Federalist Society of Law and Public Policy, an organization founded in 1982 by a small group of radically conservative law students at the University of Chicago. The effort has been a resounding success. With the help of Republicans in Congress, 85 extra federal judgeships were created under Presidents Ronald Reagan and George H.W. Bush; nine were created under Clinton. Now seven out of 12 circuit courts are anti-abortion. Seven of the nine Supreme Court justices are Republican appointees--and it's been 11 years since a post has opened up, meaning another right-winger or two could be appointed sometime soon. During Bush Sr.'s tenure, one White House insider boasted that no one who wasn't a Federalist ever received a judicial appointment from the president. The Federalist Society now counts Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah), Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, and prominent members of the conservative American Enterprise Institute among its leadership. John Ashcroft, Interior Secretary Gale Norton, Solicitor General Theodore Olson, and White House Counsel Alberto Gonzalez--charged with approving judicial nominations before passing them on to Congress--are all members. As one might expect, the Federalists have consistently acted in favor of business deregulation, creationist teachings, property rights over the rights of individuals, and much of the rest of the right-wing agenda. Sources: "A Hostile Takeover: How the Federalist Society Is Capturing the Federal Courts," Martin Garbus, American Prospect , March 1, 2003. "Courts vs. Citizens," Jamin Raskin, American Prospect , March 1, 2003. 8) Secrets of Cheney's energy task force come to light As the Bush administration continues to protect the iron wall of secrecy it's erected around Cheney's energy task force, at least two documents confirm long-standing suspicions that the administration's foreign policy is being driven by the dictates of the energy industry. When Bush took office in January 2001, he said tackling the country's energy crisis would be a top priority. The president established the National Energy Policy Development Group and appointed former Halliburton CEO Cheney as its head. One of the big issues on the table was oil, which accounted for 40 percent of the nation's energy supply. But rather than lay the groundwork for converting the economy to alternative, renewable sources, the task force's report promoted a central goal of "mak[ing] energy security a priority of our trade and foreign policy." In other words, Cheney's group wanted to find additional sources of oil overseas and ensure U.S. access to that oil--whatever it took. Documents recently obtained from the task force as the result of a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit filed by public interest group Judicial Watch indicate Cheney and his colleagues had their sights on the black gold under the Iraqi desert well before the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. In July 2003 the Commerce Department finally turned over records that included "a map of Iraqi oilfields, pipelines, refineries, and terminals, as well as two charts detailing Iraqi oil and gas projects, and 'Foreign Suitors for Iraqi Oilfield Contracts,'" according to Judicial Watch's subsequent press release. There were also similar maps and charts for Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. The documents were dated March 2001. Sources: "Cheney Energy Task Force Documents Feature Map of Iraqi Oilfields," Judicial Watch staff, Judicial Watch, July 17, 2003. "Bush-Cheney Energy Strategy: Procuring the Rest of the World's Oil," Michael Klare, Foreign Policy in Focus, January 2004. 9) Widow brings RICO case against U.S. government for 9/11 As the 9/11 Commission completed its first year, Ellen Mariani and her attorney held a press conference on the steps of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania to announce her own startling conclusions. Mariani, wife of Louis Neil Mariani, who died when terrorists flew United Airlines Flight 175 into the World Trade Center's south tower, had come to believe top American officials had foreknowledge of the attacks, purposefully failed to prevent them, and had since taken pains to cover up the truth. The administration, she argues in a federal lawsuit, allowed 9/11 to happen so Bush and company could launch their seemingly endless, global "war on terror" for their own personal and financial gain. Her lawyer, Philip J. Berg, a former deputy attorney general of Pennsylvania, filed a 62-page complaint that included 40 pages of evidence. "Compelling evidence ... will be presented in this case through discovery, subpoena power by this Court, and testimony at trial," he wrote in a press release. But only Fox News showed up to the press conference, and it never ran anything on the topic. Sources: "911 Victim's Wife Files RICO Case Against GW Bush," Philip Berg, Scoop (), Nov. 26, 2003. "Widow's Bush Treason Suit Vanishes," W. David Kubiak, Scoop, Dec. 3, 2003. 10) New nuke plants: taxpayers support, industry profits If you thought nuclear energy was dead, think again: the Bush administration's energy bill provides taxpayer cash for companies that build new nukes. A secretly crafted provision of the bill, released late on a Saturday night in November, offers energy companies as much as $7.5 billion in tax credits to build six nuclear reactors. This is in addition to almost $4 billion set aside for other nuclear energy programs. While the bill has yet to pass into law, it is still being pursued by supporters in Congress. Estimates on the amount of tax credits being considered have since risen to "as much as $15 or even $19 billion." Sources: "Nuclear Energy Would Get $7.5 Billion in Tax Subsidies, US Taxpayers Would Fund Nuclear Monitor Relapse If Energy Bill Passes," Cindy Folkers and Michael Mariotte, Nuclear Information and Resource Service, Nov. 17, 2003. "US Senate Passes Pro-Nuclear Energy Bill," Cindy Folkers and Michael Mariotte, WISE/NIRS Nuclear Monitor, Aug. 22, 2003. Copyright © 1995-2004 New Mass Media. All rights reserved. ***************************************************************** 10 Israel's Re-Arrest of Nuclear Whistleblower Vanunu Date: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 14:28:06 -0600 (CST) Institute for Public Accuracy 915 National Press Building, Washington, D.C. 20045 (202) 347-0020 * http://www.accuracy.org * ipa@accuracy.org ___________________________________________________ PM Thursday, November 11, 2004 Israel's Re-Arrest of Nuclear Whistleblower Vanunu "Heavily armed police commandos stormed a Jerusalem church compound Thursday and arrested nuclear whistle blower Mordechai Vanunu," the Associate Press reports. Vanunu had been restricted from speaking to non-Israelis or media and had openly violated such prohibitions, including appearing on a news release of the Institute for Public Accuracy on Sept. 17: . The following are available for interviews: FELICE COHEN-JOPPA, ART LAFFIN, freevanunu@mindspring.com, http://www.vanunu.com Cohen-Joppa is the coordinator of the U.S. Campaign to Free Mordechai Vanunu; Laffin is associate coordinator of the group. Cohen-Joppa said today: "It is an outrage that Israel has re-arrested nuclear whistleblower Mordechai Vanunu only six months after his release from prison. The unjust and severe restrictions that have forced Mordechai Vanunu to remain in Israel following his release last April, and intend to muzzle his voice for nuclear disarmament, are grave violations of his human and civil rights. These violations are now magnified as Israel has hidden behind news of the death of Yassir Arafat to increase its punishment of Mordechai Vanunu. After 18 years in prison, he has no secrets to reveal. Israel must stop punishing this man who has already suffered so much for letting the world know about Israel's nuclear arsenal." DANIEL ELLSBERG, ellsbergD@cs.com, http://www.truthtellingproject.org, http://www.ellsberg.net Author of the book "Secrets: A Memoir of Vietnam and the Pentagon Papers," Ellsberg said today: "The only secret Mordechai Vanunu has left to tell the world is the one he revealed on the day of his release from 18 years in prison, April 21, 2004: 'I am a symbol of the will of freedom, that the human spirit is free. You cannot destroy the human spirit.' That is indeed the most dangerous secret in the eyes not only of Israel but of every state that withholds vital information from its own citizens, including the U.S. and U.K. Israel should let the foremost prophet of the nuclear age go forth to be honored throughout the world -- and we call on them to do so -- but even if it returns him instead to his 6-by-9 foot cell, Mordechai Vanunu will remain the most free man on earth." MARY and NICK EOLOFF, Nick.Eoloff-1@tc.umn.edu Mordechai Vanunu's adoptive parents, the Eoloffs live in St. Paul, Minn. They said today: "We are horrified that today armed Israeli special police forces entered St. George's Cathedral compound in order to kidnap Mordechai Vanunu for the second time. It is further proof that the security forces have no respect for an individual's human rights and dignity nor respect for a religious site which is a sacred place of sanctuary. Mordechai has always acted from a moral belief that nuclear weapons are immoral and illegal and that all nations should begin the process of their disarmament." MARK GAFFNEY, MHGaffney@aol.com, http://www.counterpunch.org/gaffney01312003.html Gaffney is author of a book about Israel's nuclear program, "Dimona -- The Third Temple: The Story Behind the Vanunu Revelation." He also wrote the recent article "The Case of Mordechai Vanunu: Preeminent Hero of the Nuclear Age." He said today: "Israel has been pressing for attacking Iran while it is suppressing the truth about its own nuclear weapons program -- the only program which has come out of the Mideast and has actually developed nuclear weapons and is driving other countries to acquire weapons of mass destruction." Background on Israel's nuclear capacity: A letter from the Anglican Bishop in Jerusalem on Vanunu's re-arrest today: For more information, contact at the Institute for Public Accuracy: Sam Husseini, (202) 347-0020; or David Zupan, (541) 484-9167 _________________________________________________________________ You received this message as a subscriber on the list: public@lists.accuracy.org To be removed from the list, send any message to: public-unsubscribe@lists.accuracy.org For all list information and functions, including changing your subscription mode and options, visit the Web page: http://lists.accuracy.org/lists/info/public ***************************************************************** 11 [NYTr] Fascist Israeli Regime Re-arrests Vanunu Date: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 15:49:50 -0600 (CST) Via NY Transfer News Collective * All the News that Doesn't Fit In Israel the former political prisoner and kidnap victim is under house arrest for "leaking classified information." Reuters - Nov 11, 2004 http://www.reuters.com/newsArticle.jhtml?type=worldNews&storyID=6789772 Israel Arrests Nuke Whistleblower Vanunu for 'Leak' By Dan Williams JERUSALEM (Reuters) - Israeli police put nuclear whistleblower Mordechai Vanunu under house arrest on Thursday on suspicion of spilling more state secrets, seven months after he completed an 18-year prison term for treason. Vanunu was bundled into an unmarked car at the Jerusalem church where he has lived since he left jail in April, witnesses said. Barred from going abroad or meeting foreign media for a probationary period, he had been under constant surveillance. "He (Vanunu) is suspected of passing classified information to unauthorized parties," police spokesman Gil Kleiman said. "He is also suspected of violating the terms of his release." Vanunu, 50, denied the allegations when brought to court later on Thursday. Flashing the V for victory sign with both his hands, he said: "The atomic secrets (he revealed) have already been told around the world." He was later released and put under house arrest for a week in a hostel attached to the church, police said, adding that they had confiscated documents and three laptop computers from his room in the church and would examine them for classified information. Barred from going abroad or meeting foreign media for a probationary period, Vanunu had been under constant surveillance. Despite the restrictions, he gave interviews to reporters which he said were the sole grounds for his arrest. "I cannot shut up, I have to have freedom of speech," he told reporters at the court. The re-arrest of a man widely reviled in Israel but admired by anti-nuclear activists worldwide and repeatedly nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize was overshadowed by the death of Palestinian President Yasser Arafat in Paris. Vanunu was abducted in Rome by Mossad agents and jailed in 1986 for discussing his work at Israel's main atomic reactor in Dimona with a British newspaper. His revelations to the Sunday Times led experts to conclude that the Jewish state had amassed between 100 and 200 nuclear weapons, all but blowing away the country's policy of "strategic ambiguity" over its assumed non-conventional arsenal. In July, the Supreme Court rejected an appeal by Vanunu to be allowed to leave Israel before the year-long ban expires, citing Defense Ministry charges that he intended to reveal more secrets. Vanunu made a failed bid to win political asylum in Sweden last month, saying he felt his life was threatened. In an interview conducted by an Israeli intermediary and broadcast by the BBC in early June, Vanunu said he had exposed Dimona because he wanted to save Israel from a "new holocaust." But he also questioned the Jewish state's right to exist. (c) Copyright Reuters 2004. All rights reserved. * Search the NYTr Archives at: http://olm.blythe-systems.com/pipermail/nytr/ To subscribe or unsubscribe or change your settings via the web, visit: http://olm.blythe-systems.com/mailman/listinfo/nytr ================================================================= NY Transfer News Collective * A Service of Blythe Systems Since 1985 - Information for the Rest of Us 339 Lafayette St., New York, NY 10012 http://www.blythe.org e-mail: nyt@blythe.org ================================================================= ***************************************************************** 12 VANUNU ARRESTED AND CHARGED AGAIN - MORE NEWS TO FOLLOW Date: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 17:54:40 -0800 Free Mordechai Vanunu - Info & Action Alert #38 **NEWS ALERT ON ARREST OF MORDECHAI VANUNU** Contact Israeli Embassy to demand his release! phone: 202-364-5500 email: ambassador_sec@israelemb.org fax: 202-364-5607 Public & Interreligious Affairs v.(202) 364-5542 Political Department (202)364-5581/2 Press Office (202) 364-5538 or contact Israeli ambassador in your country - http://www.embassyworld.com/embassy/israel1.html FOLLOWED BY: - Letter from the Bishop in Jerusalem on the arrest of Mordechai Vanunu - Article from Ma'ariv, English language website, Nov. 11, 2004 ================ News Alert From Rayna Moss: Mordechai Vanunu was arrested this morning in his room at St. George's Cathedral in East Jerusalem, by a huge police force (about 30 armed officers). The pretext for his arrest: Vanunu violated the Draconian restrictions that were imposed on him when he was released from prison in April, by giving interviews to foreign media. The attempt to silence Mordechai Vanunu on this of all days, is an attempt to bury Israel's secret nuclear arsenal together with Yasser Arafat. While the world media and attention are focused on the burial of the Palestinian leader, the Israeli government is attempting to disappear the nuclear whistleblower, whose only crime is revealing the terrible truth that Israel is trying to hide: weapons of mass destruction that are concealed from Israeli citizens and from the world. Mordechai Vanunu is expected to be brought to court on Friday morning, November 12. His supporters will demonstrate outside the courthouse. Details will be sent out later today. For more information: Rayna Moss: 0507-368236 legalese@netvision.net.il www.vanunu.com www.vanunu.co,uk ---------------------------- Letter from the Bishop in Jerusalem on the arrest of Mordechai Vanunu from St George's Cathedral Close this morning The Episcopal Church in Jerusalem & The Middle East The Diocese of Jerusalem The Rt Revd Riah H Abu El-Assal 11 November 2004 To: a.. The Most Revd Rowan Williams Archbishop of Canterbury b.. The Most Revd Frank Tracy Griswold Presiding Bishop of ECUSA c.. The Most Revd Andrew Hutchinson Primate of the Anglican Church of Canada d.. The Most Revd Peter Carnley Primate of the Anglican Church of Australia e.. The Australian Board of Mission f.. The Revd Canon John L. Peterson Secretary General of the Anglican Consultative Council g.. The Revd Samuel Kobia General Secretary of the World Council of Churches h.. Mr Jeries Saleh Middle East Council of Churches i.. The Heads of Churches in Jerusalem It is with tremendous grief and sadness that I inform you that the Israeli special police force entered St George's Cathedral Close today without permission and took Mordechai Vanunu into custody. Approximately thirty officers, many with guns, entered the cathedral gardens and interrupted breakfast in the Pilgrim Guest House. It was a traumatic event that terrorized many of our tourists, pilgrims, and staff. In the 100 years of the cathedral's history, such an event has never taken place. Immediately I related how they have come into a sacred place, and that their guns were not welcome. The officers with guns withdrew to outside of the Cathedral Close; however, it came to my attention later, that at least one of the officers still carried a concealed weapon. This was after I had been reassured that all weapons had been removed from the church grounds. It is inconceivable why such force is mandated for procedures like today's. Mordechai was calm during the search, questioning the need for the interrogation, and they searched his room in his and my presence. They took his papers, laptop, and other possessions into custody. I called his lawyer, and he will meet Mordechai in Petah Tiqva. This type of entry into a sacred space must not be tolerated by the churches throughout the world, and it must not be accepted by those who respect the rights and dignity of every person. We ask the government of Israel to stop such actions as these, and we call for the respect of sacred places in the Land of the Holy One. It is with extreme sadness and disappointment that I must write this letter, and please continue to pray for us in these difficult times. Peace of God to all of you, The Rt Revd Riah Abu El-Assal Bishop in Jerusalem cc: His Excellency, President Moshe Katsav Prime Minister Ariel Sharon ------------- Ma'ariv, English language website, Nov. 11, 2004 Vanunu detained on suspicion of revealing confidential information Nuclear spy also suspected of violating restrictions imposed on him during his April release from prison. Tal Yamin-Wolfowitz Mordechai Vanunu was detained this (Thursday) morning by police on suspicion of revealing confidential information and of failing to abide by the restrictions that were imposed on him upon his release from prison. The nuclear spy was arrested after a search was carried out in his room, which is located in an East Jerusalem hostel not far from the Saint George Church. During the search, documents and a laptop were uncovered and taken to the offices of the International Crimes Unit in Petah Tikva for examination. Vanunu was under surveillance for months as defense officials estimated it was only a matter of time until he would be detained. Since his April release, the nuclear whistleblower has stretched the boundaries of his restrictions when he spoke with foreign media organizations. When Vanunu was released, a long list of restrictions was imposed on him. Among other things, he was not allowed to leave the country, contact foreign nationals without consent or hold chats on the internet. He was also instructed to notify officials when he did not sleep at his known residence. Three months ago, Attorney General Meni Mazuz instructed police to launch a criminal investigation against Vanunu following the interviews he had given to foreign media. (2004-11-11 00:29:45.0) ======== end - more to follow Felice Cohen-Joppa Coordinator U.S. Campaign to Free Mordechai Vanunu POB 43384 Tucson, AZ 85733 Phone/Fax 520-323-8697 freevanunu@mindspring.com www.nonviolence.org/vanunu ***************************************************************** 13 [NukeNet] Vanunu arrested again Date: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 17:54:49 -0800 Nuclear Whistle-Blower Is Arrested in Jerusalem Associated Press November 11, 2004 10:29 a.m. JERUSALEM -- Heavily armed police commandos stormed a Jerusalem church compound and arrested nuclear whistle-blower Mordechai Vanunu on Thursday, seven months after he completed an 18-year prison sentence for treason, witnesses and police said. Police spokesman Gil Kleiman said Mr. Vanunu had allegedly revealed classified information, but declined to discuss the nature of his alleged disclosures or to whom he made them. Mr. Vanunu, 49 years old, was released from prison in April after 18 years -- much of it in solitary confinement -- for disclosing secrets he learned as a technician at the Israeli nuclear reactor in the southern town of Dimona in the 1980s. On Thursday morning, about 20 police commandos wearing bullet-proof vests and wielding machine guns burst into the walled compound of St. George's Anglican Church where Mr. Vanunu has taken sanctuary in a guesthouse since his release, arresting him as he ate breakfast. Mr. Vanunu was arrested at the hostel. "We were sitting ... having breakfast at nine o clock, then all these military stormed in, running everywhere with heavy arms," said Ninni Rydsjo, a Swedish aid worker who was staying at the hostel attached to the church. "They were looking outside, everywhere. We were very frightened," she said. Ms. Rydsjo said that while Mr. Vanunu appeared calm as he was led away, the bishop, Riah Abu El-Assal, accused the police of violating the sanctity of the church. Police said they had removed papers and a computer from Mr. Vanunu's room. Mr. Vanunu has acknowledged violating his release arrangement, which barred him from meeting foreigners or discussing his work at Dimona, but said he had no more classified information to reveal. Mr. Vanunu was convicted in 1988 for divulging information and pictures of the Dimona reactor. The details, published in London's Sunday Times, led experts to conclude that Israel has the world's sixth-largest stockpile of nuclear weapons, including hundreds of warheads. Israel has followed a policy of nuclear ambiguity, neither confirming nor denying it has nuclear weapons. Mr. Vanunu, a convert to Christianity, became a hero to peace activists for his role in unveiling Israel's nuclear program. Peter Hounam, the Sunday Times journalist who published Mr. Vanunu's nuclear revelations, said he was "horrified" by the arrest, and accused the Israeli authorities of using Thursday's death of Palestinian Leader Yasser Arafat to try to divert attention from it. "I think they deliberately waited until Arafat died," he told the Associated Press from England. "But I don't think they will succeed because people all over the world will ask why Israel is being so vindictive." In an AP interview in September, Mr. Vanunu said he wanted to replace his Israeli citizenship with a foreign one, perhaps Palestinian. "In Israel, I am regarded as a traitor ... and since my release they are not respecting my human rights, my freedom of speech my freedom of movement," he said at the time. He said he planned to continue his anti-nuclear campaign, but he had no more secrets to reveal. "All I knew was published 18 years ago," he said. -- Subscribe to our free weekly list serve by visiting:http://www.prwatch.org/cmd/subscribe_sotd.html Diane Farsetta Senior Researcher, Center for Media & Democracy 520 University Avenue, Suite 227 Madison, WI 53703 phone: 608-260-9713 fax: 608-260-9714 email: diane@prwatch.org http://www.prwatch.org/ _______________________________________________________________________ Subscribe/Unsubscribe Here: http://www.energyjustice.net/nukenet/ Change your settings at: http://energyjustice.net/mailman/listinfo/nukenet_energyjustice.net ***************************************************************** 14 [du-list] Interviews Available on Israel's Re-Arrest of Date: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 18:00:01 -0800 Institute for Public Accuracy 915 National Press Building, Washington, D.C. 20045 (202) 347-0020 * http://www.accuracy.org * ipa@accuracy.org ___________________________________________________ PM Thursday, November 11, 2004 Interviews Available on Israel's Re-Arrest of Nuclear Whistleblower Vanunu "Heavily armed police commandos stormed a Jerusalem church compound Thursday and arrested nuclear whistle blower Mordechai Vanunu," the Associate Press reports. Vanunu had been restricted from speaking to non-Israelis or media and had openly violated such prohibitions, including appearing on a news release of the Institute for Public Accuracy on Sept. 17: . The following are available for interviews: FELICE COHEN-JOPPA, (520) 323-8697, ART LAFFIN, (202) 882-9649, (202) 829-7625, freevanunu@mindspring.com, http://www.vanunu.com Cohen-Joppa is the coordinator of the U.S. Campaign to Free Mordechai Vanunu; Laffin is associate coordinator of the group. Cohen-Joppa said today: "It is an outrage that Israel has re-arrested nuclear whistleblower Mordechai Vanunu only six months after his release from prison. The unjust and severe restrictions that have forced Mordechai Vanunu to remain in Israel following his release last April, and intend to muzzle his voice for nuclear disarmament, are grave violations of his human and civil rights. These violations are now magnified as Israel has hidden behind news of the death of Yassir Arafat to increase its punishment of Mordechai Vanunu. After 18 years in prison, he has no secrets to reveal. Israel must stop punishing this man who has already suffered so much for letting the world know about Israel's nuclear arsenal." DANIEL ELLSBERG, (510) 526-2605, ellsbergD@cs.com, http://www.truthtellingproject.org, http://www.ellsberg.net Author of the book "Secrets: A Memoir of Vietnam and the Pentagon Papers," Ellsberg said today: "The only secret Mordechai Vanunu has left to tell the world is the one he revealed on the day of his release from 18 years in prison, April 21, 2004: 'I am a symbol of the will of freedom, that the human spirit is free. You cannot destroy the human spirit.' That is indeed the most dangerous secret in the eyes not only of Israel but of every state that withholds vital information from its own citizens, including the U.S. and U.K. Israel should let the foremost prophet of the nuclear age go forth to be honored throughout the world -- and we call on them to do so -- but even if it returns him instead to his 6-by-9 foot cell, Mordechai Vanunu will remain the most free man on earth." MARY and NICK EOLOFF, (651) 698-1493, Nick.Eoloff-1@tc.umn.edu Mordechai Vanunu's adoptive parents, the Eoloffs live in St. Paul, Minn. They said today: "We are horrified that today armed Israeli special police forces entered St. George's Cathedral compound in order to kidnap Mordechai Vanunu for the second time. It is further proof that the security forces have no respect for an individual's human rights and dignity nor respect for a religious site which is a sacred place of sanctuary. Mordechai has always acted from a moral belief that nuclear weapons are immoral and illegal and that all nations should begin the process of their disarmament." MARK GAFFNEY, (541) 783-2309, MHGaffney@aol.com, http://www.counterpunch.org/gaffney01312003.html Gaffney is author of a book about Israel's nuclear program, "Dimona -- The Third Temple: The Story Behind the Vanunu Revelation." He also wrote the recent article "The Case of Mordechai Vanunu: Preeminent Hero of the Nuclear Age." He said today: "Israel has been pressing for attacking Iran while it is suppressing the truth about its own nuclear weapons program -- the only program which has come out of the Mideast and has actually developed nuclear weapons and is driving other countries to acquire weapons of mass destruction." Background on Israel's nuclear capacity: A letter from the Anglican Bishop in Jerusalem on Vanunu's re-arrest today: For more information, contact at the Institute for Public Accuracy: Sam Husseini, (202) 347-0020, (202) 421-6858; or David Zupan, (541) 484-9167 For all list information and functions, including changing your subscription mode and options, visit the Web page: http://lists.accuracy.org/lists/info/mediagen [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] ------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~--> Make a clean sweep of pop-up ads. Yahoo! Companion Toolbar. Now with Pop-Up Blocker. Get it for free! http://us.click.yahoo.com/L5YrjA/eSIIAA/yQLSAA/FGYolB/TM --------------------------------------------------------------------~-> To unsubscribe from this groups send a message to du-list-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com. In the body of the message type unsubscribe and send. Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/du-list/ <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: du-list-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/ ***************************************************************** 15 Bellona: Russia not to pay penalty to China for delays at Tianwan NPP On October 19, the acting chief of the Russian Nuclear Regulatory Andrey Malyshev visited Tianwan NPP’s construction site in China. 2004-11-10 19:57 The first reactor was scheduled for launch back in April and Russia might face the penalty reaching $200m, Kommersant daily reported. The contract for the construction of Tianwan nuclear power plant was signed in 1997. It stipulates that Russia will build two power units with total power output of 2,000 megawatts. According to Mr. Malyshev, in the nearest future the Chinese part must announce a tender on the construction of two more nuclear power units. The Russian part is studying the conditions of the tender and soon will make the decision concerning its participation. The first power unit of Tianwan nuclear power plant is likely to be put into operation in two months, Mr. Malyshev said. The earlier tests revealed 3300 serious defects or “nonconformances”. However, this is not the record. For example, while testing the units built by the Electricite de France, 50,000 nonconformances were found and the start-up was delayed for two years. Regarding the quality of the Russian equipment, Malyshev said it was controlled not only by the Atomstroyexport, but also by the Rostekhnadzor inspection organisation. He believes the quality control could be lost during inappropriate storage conditions or installation. The Rostekhnadzor agreed with Chinese partners and sent its specialists to the site for the whole period of the construction. The Atomstroyexport is already late for several months with the reactor unit launch. Some experts estimate China could demand from $40m to $200m penalty. Mr. Malyshev, however, hopes to avoid the penalty by setting a new start-up date together with the Chinese partners, Kommersant reported. Publisher: Bellona Foundation, President: Frederic Hauge Information: info@bellona.no, Technical contact: webmaster@bellona.no Telephone: +47 23 23 46 00 Telefax: +47 22 38 38 62 * P.O.Box 2141 Grunerlokka, 0505 Oslo, Norway ***************************************************************** 16 Floating NPPs and nuclear waste disposal to bring profit to Severodvinsk + + [Home page in Russian] Rus Eng [Homepage in Norwegian] Nor Russian NPPs Russia has 10 nuclear power plants (NPPs) in operation. The safety standards of the Soviet designed reactors have been highly questioned by international experts. During the last decade, the social is Jump to section [Hydrogen report]     About Bellona    Energy and climate change        Russia            EnviroRights       EcoPravo magazine  You are here: www.bellona.no : Russia : Russian NPPs : News story | [This page is also available in Russian] [Currently version is English] Sections Energy and climate > Sellafield > Energy Nuclear Russia > Russian NPPs > Nuclear Powered Icebreakers > The Russian Navy > Nuclear Weapons > Nuclear Waste Management > Nuclear Industry Environmental rights > The Nikitin case > The Pasko Case > Access to enviroinformation Floating NPPs and nuclear waste disposal to bring profit to Severodvinsk The deputies from Severodvinsk stated this at the meeting with Arkhangelsk region governor in October. 2004-11-08 18:16 The participants of the meeting discussed also the perspectives of the floating nuclear plant construction in Severodvinsk, Regnum.ru reported. The Federal Special-Purpose Program stipulates construction of the atomic heating plant in Severodvinsk covered by off-budget sources. The design works are completed and the estimated cost of the project is about $175m. The Federal Atomic Agency on Atomic Energy examines several possible ways to finance construction of the floating NPP including credits from China and India on the security of the Russian Government. The Severodvinsk deputies also believe that the local budget could profit not only from floating NPP construction, but also from nuclear waste disposal in Severodvinsk, Regnum.ru reported. [ Bellona Home ] > [ About Bellona ] [ Energy and climate change ] [ Russia ] [ EnviroRights ] [ EcoPravo magazine ] >> [ The Russian Navy ] [ Nuclear Industry ] [ Nuclear Powered Icebreakers ] [ Accidents and Incidents ] [ Waste Management ] [ Nuclear Weapons ] [ Russian NPPs ] >>> [ Balakovo NPP ] [ Beloyarsk NPP ] [ Bilibino NPP ] [ Kalinin NPP ] [ Kola NPP ] [ Kursk NPP ] [ Leningrad NPP ] [ Novovoronezh NPP ] [ Rostov (Volgodonsk) NPP ] [ Smolensk NPP ] [ Research reactors ] [ International cooperation ] You are here: www.bellona.no : Russia : Russian NPPs : News story | Top of page Publisher: Bellona Foundation, President: Frederic Hauge Information: info@bellona.no, Technical contact: webmaster@bellona.no Telephone: +47 23 23 46 00 Telefax: +47 22 38 38 62 * P.O.Box 2141 Grunerlokka, 0505 Oslo, Norway Menu system java script courtesy of dhtml central. [ (c) BELLONA -- Reuse and reprint recommended provided source is stated ] ***************************************************************** 17 Bellona: An ‘ordinary emergency’ reactor shut down causes widespread panic ST. PETERSRSBURG—Reports about a supposedly common reactor shut down at the Balakovo Nuclear Power Plant in Russia’s southwestern Saratov region led to wide-spread panic resulting in overdoses of iodine taken by the fearful against possible radiation poisoning, and showing up the lack of coordination within the country’s emergency notification system. The Balakovo Nuclear Power Plant in Russia's Saratov Region. balaes.ru Rashid Alimov, Charles Digges, 2004-11-10 12:50 Last Friday’s rush on iodine in Saratov drug stores was triggered by the announcement of an emergency shut down of reactor bloc No. 2 at the Balakovo NPP in the early morning hours of November 4th. Spokesmen for the plant said the situation, though termed “emergency” was normal and that the shut down had occurred when the reactor’s safety system s detected a coolant leak. The malfunction was repaired and the reactor was re-launched. “Emergency shut-down of a reactor—it’s only a technical term. There is no emergency. On the contrary, it’s very good, that disaster protection has done its job,” a spokesman for the plant told Bellona Web. But that was cold comfort for residents of Saratov, some 700 kilometres southwest of Moscow, who dashed to drugstores and bought out stocks of iodine, which, if taken during a radiation emergency, prevents the digestion of radioactive iodine isotopes released into the atmosphere. Eventually the panic spread briefly throughout the rest of the country—which maintains vivid memories of the Kursk sinking in 2001 and the 1986 explosion at Chernobyl and the official disinformation campaign downplaying the scale of the disasters—because nuclear industry officials were sluggish and vague in responding to reports about the Balakovo incident. Many therefore decided to take protective measures into their own hands, and found themselves hospitalized or sitting in emergency rooms to be treated for iodine overdoses. Bellona demands that it be included in an independent environmental investigation now underway to determine the reasons behind the shut down of Balakovo’s second reactor bloc. Bellona also demands that a complete report on the incident be made available to the public. The shut down that triggered the panic The emergency shut down occurred late on the night of November 4th and was caused by a leakage of coolant-water in the reactors secondary circuit, which automatically triggered the reactors disaster protection system, plant officials told Bellona Web. “Disaster protection has worked normally, in four seconds the reactor was halted,” said the plant spokesman of the emergency shutdown. According to Bellona’s Alexander Nikitin, “emergency shut-down is an extraordinary measure.” It’s permitted to be used only when all the other ways to control the reactor fail, he said. Rosatom spokesman Nikolai Shingaryov explained what happened to Gazeta.ru, saying that a tube from a steam generator in the second reactor cracked, causing water to leak onto the clamps of a water pump in the coolant system. The pump then shorted out and water pressure in the steam generator dropped. When this occurred, the disaster protection system immediately shut down the reactor. The pump was changed and the reactor was re-launched. “It was an ordinary incident—such things happen on average once every two weeks,” Shingaryov said. Nuclear whistleblower Sergei Kharitonov, a former employee of the Leningrad NPP until he was fired for his fight against plant authorities in his efforts to upgrade safety there, told Bellona Web that “such statements from Rosatom’s press service testify to the evidently complete chaos in the nuclear industry”. According to the Balakovo NPP representatives, “this event is not significant for safety and is categorized according to International Nuclear Events Scale [INES] at level zero.” The INES scale runs from zero to five, five being the most serious measure. Information meltdown News of the event, often contradictory and incomplete, spread quickly through Russian newswires and eventually national television. Morning reports on state-run Channel One from Balakovo, addressing the rumors of an incident at the nuclear power plant, said that the event was a training exercise. This made little sense to those who had already heard wire reports about the emergency shut down of Balakovo’s second reactor bloc, begging the question among the population as to why what was reported as minor fault was now being explained as a training exercise. In an interview after the shut down, the Balakovo spokesman said that the television station had “broadcast information without a full understanding of the situation. This could cause panic.” The plant’s chief engineer told Bellona Web that there actually had been an emergency training session on November 3rd. The Emergency Situations Department of Balakovo and the administrations of the nearby villages of Natalino and Matveyevka had been informed about the training executrices, which involved a test of the emergency notification system and drill evacuation of plant personnel. The real training exercise could very well have contributed to the rumors of a more serious accident. Public information officials at Balakovo managed to cast further suspicions on the credibility of their own statements by being uninformed about a planned visit by Sergei Kireyenko, the Kremlin-appointed presidential emissary to the Privolzhye district, where Saratov is situated. When asked to confirm whether Kireynko would indeed visit the plant following the incident, Balakovo representatives called the visit “more fantasies.” But within two hours, the Balakovo NPP released a statement on its website saying Kireyenko had not only “visited the plant and personally made sure it was safe,” but that he had “himself touched the repaired tube, which [earlier] had a leakage of pure desalinated non-radioactive water.” A spoon full of sugar would have helped the iodine go down The conflicting news reports causes panic from Balakovo to Nizhny Novgorod, some 700 kilometres north of the plant. Residents of surrounding cities like Penza, Volgograd, Voronezh and Tambov regarded the official information with disbelief and waited, according to several local accounts, for radioactive fallout to come drifting over their cities. Emergency authorities, meanwhile, were uncoordinated, uniformed and sloppy in their reaction to the panic, offering few precautions that residents should be taking, or even if they should be taking precautions at all. According to the anti-nuclear Ecodefence! Group, inhabitants of several small villages surrounding the Balakovo, like Matveyevka, located 5 kilometres from the plant, were instructed to take iodine tablets—though without dosage information—and were told not to come outdoors, and not to tend cattle. In nearby Saratov, a rush of panicked and confused residents bought out most of the cities supply of iodine in an onslaught on local drug stores. According to the Kommersant newspaper, all students Nayanova University in Samara, 150 km from Balakovo, were given glasses of milk with iodine. Kindergartens in the Samara Regions were ordered not to let children outdoors and to give each child an iodine-soaked gauze strip to be worn around their throats. At several regional plants, employees were instructed not to open windows. Drug stores in Samara saw the same winding lines of frightened customers queuing up to buy iodine. Soon seven people came to Samara hospitals with iodine poisoning. A 52-year-old woman bought iodine salvation for external use and drank it dissolved in water. She got minor larynx burns, vomiting and increase of temperature. Balakovo also reported two iodine over-dosages, said local Emergency Situations Department deputy head Valery Sarayev, according to the RIA Novosti Russian newswire. There was also panic in Penza region. Local news agencies there reported on patients crowding hospitals with symptoms of iodine poisoning. Residents of the closed nuclear city of Penza-19 also gave way to panic. By 11 am on November 5th, all local drugstores sold out all the iodine. Local phone stations and mobile works could not cope with the increased loads. Emergency Situation Department phone lines were consistently busy. According to local journalists, it was impossible to get any information by phones from local officials. Was radiation released? Whether any radiation was released into the atmosphere remains unclear. “To answer this question, one needs special research, but we cannot affirm, in principle, that no release occurred,” an Ecodefence! representative told Bellona Web. “When an emergency shut-down happens, overheated radioactive steam has to be released from the steam generators. Its tubes always have micro cracks, which is why radiation may get into the steam, and then into the atmosphere.” Losses Losses caused by the panic, as well as stress loads on the Privolzhye are difficult to measure. But the emergency shut-down, which itself is an extraordinary event, evidently led to a loss of energy production. But plant representatives of the plant told Bellona Web that such shut downs for repairs are foreseen expenses and have little impact on projected energy profits. Last Friday, November 5th, Saratov Regional Governor Dmitry Ayatskov issued a statement saying that the Balakovo NPP’s director, Pavel Ipatov, had said the reactor would be up and running by 10 pm that evening. Vladimir Ingatov, the plant’s chief engineer, said the same at a press conference that day. It was not until the following evening, however, that the reactor was restarted. On Monday the Saratov regional prosecutors office declared it would begin a search for people who had disseminated rumors about a supposed catastrophe at the Balakovo NPP, though such a seemingly fruitless pursuit could well have been avoided had authorities been forthright about the incident from the beginning. Balakovo NPP on the international scene The Balakovo plant, which currently operates four VVER-1000 pressure water reactors, has been slated as a possible site for the burning of mixed uranium and weapons-grade plutonium, or MOX, fuel as part of the US-Russia Plutonium Disposition agreement of 2000. Under this agreement, both the United States and Russia have agreed to destroy 34 tonnes each of surplus weapons-grade plutonium in parallel progress. But Russian progress is lagging because of funding problems, and the US State Department has further hindered matters by insisting that Russia assume full liability for any accidents that may occur during the building of MOX fabricating and burning facilities. Russia has stated on several occasions that it will not agree to such onerous liability terms, thus grinding the MOX plutonium disposition plan to a halt. At Balakovo, the reactors would have to be retrofitted at a cost of several million dollars to make them fit to burn the volatile MOX fuel. The plant had planned to build two more VVER-1000 reactor blocs, but this was halted by a local referendum in 1993. Authorities, however, later nixed the referendum, saying that the two extra reactors would push the MOX programme forward. Even though it is highly uncertain as to whether the MOX programme will ever come to fruition, nuclear officials say they still intend to proceed with the two new reactors at Balakovo. Rashid Alimov reported from St. Petersburg, and Charles Digges reported from Oslo. Publisher: Bellona Foundation, President: Frederic Hauge Information: info@bellona.no, Technical contact: webmaster@bellona.no Telephone: +47 23 23 46 00 Telefax: +47 22 38 38 62 * P.O.Box 2141 Grunerlokka, 0505 Oslo, Norway ***************************************************************** 18 [DU-WATCH] Interesting Article at Ban Uranium Weapons Date: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 23:33:18 -0600 (CST) Hello Du-Watch: Your Friend Tara Thornton considered the following article interesting and wanted to send it to you. Draft Convention: Executive Summary (Date: 2004-10-31 13:06:30) Topic: ICBUW URL: http://www.bandepleteduranium.org/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=160 You can read interesting articles at Ban Uranium Weapons http://www.bandepleteduranium.org ------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~--> Make a clean sweep of pop-up ads. Yahoo! Companion Toolbar. Now with Pop-Up Blocker. Get it for free! http://us.click.yahoo.com/L5YrjA/eSIIAA/yQLSAA/Sj.0lB/TM --------------------------------------------------------------------~-> [Brought to you by HTTP://WWW.STOPNATO.ORG.UK] Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/du-watch/ <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: du-watch-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/ ***************************************************************** 19 Bellona: Norway sponsored radiation monitoring at Polyarninsky shipyard The shipyard signed the contract on installation of the Picasso radiation monitoring system. 2004-11-10 20:21 The Polyarninsky Shipyard no.1 is situated in Polyarny, a town of ca 30 000 inhabitants, north of Murmansk in the Kola Bay. The shipyard has been designated as the recipient of an integrated radioactive waste management complex as a combination of several AMEC projects. The aim of the AMEC project PICASSO is to provide an automated radiation monitoring system to give information in real time on the actual radiation situation. It is based on the Norwegian software PICASSO, adapted for Russian use, and combined with Russian manufactured radiation sensors. Installation of automated radiation monitoring at this site ensures safe operation, early warning in case of accidents and helps protect workers, population and the environment against radiation. The automated radiation monitoring system PICASSO-AMEC at Atomflot has been put into operation in 2003. The following elements are included in the radioactive waste management complex: - The Picasso system for radiation monitoring - The mobile pre-treatment facility for solid radioactive waste - Light weight storage buildings and containers for transport and storage of solid waste - The mobile treatment facility for liquid radioactive waste Eight gross gamma air detectors and one submersible detector are planned, including one gross gamma detector in the city of Polyarny. Gamma radiation detectors will be placed at the following locations: - Integrated radioactive waste management complex - The open pad for interim storage of solid radioactive waste - The piers where submarines are laid up awaiting dismantlement - The floating docks where submarines are dismantled - The entrance gate and the radiation safety department building The submersible sensor for water radioactivity is planned in the sewage discharge pipe from the waste management complex. This position is beneficial for the integral assessment of the shipyard's impact on the water environment, Mil.no reported. Publisher: Bellona Foundation, President: Frederic Hauge Information: info@bellona.no, Technical contact: webmaster@bellona.no Telephone: +47 23 23 46 00 Telefax: +47 22 38 38 62 * P.O.Box 2141 Grunerlokka, 0505 Oslo, Norway ***************************************************************** 20 KPVI: RADIATION EFFECT ON IDAHOANS [NBC Newschannel 6 Nov 10, 2004 Forty years ago, scientists with the United States Government conducted tests of nuclear bombs. Nine hundred and eleven of those occurred at the Nevada test site just 90 miles north of Las Vegas. In 1990, Congress approved the 'Radiation Exposure Compensation' Act because they realized the health of anyone in the area could have been affected. While Utah, Nevada, and Arizona have been approved for compensation by the U.S. Government, Idaho has not been approved. Aaron Kunz spoke with a couple of people right here in Eastern Idaho who say it's time that changed. According to several studies by the National Cancer Institute, the prevailing winds blew radioactivity from the Nevada test site north into Idaho and Montana. Don McBride and Lana Stoddard have both been told they have thyroid cancer. "We were interested because it's kind of unusual for both of us to have it." "Have thyroid cancer?" "Thyroid cancer - and yet there is no history of cancer in our family." After a little research, they discovered it may be caused by government testing of nuclear bombs in the Nevada desert over 40 years ago. The deadly cause, exposure to Iodine 131. What McBride and Stoddard found through hours of research was a little shocking. "They deliberately made sure the winds were blowing this way instead of towards Los Angeles. So they knew something was going to happen. Once I read that, I thought, 'Well, it's time we said something, then.'" According to a report by the National Cancer Institute, winds blew Iodine 131 into Idaho and Montana. Lana Stoddard was diagnosed this year and she's upset that it will affect her for the rest of her life. "We've been healthy all our lives; we don't drink, we don't smoke, we haven't indulged in any of these things that might put our health at risk, and yet we show up with thyroid cancer." "I know eventually it's going to get me." Idaho has until March 1st to make a case. For more information, you can log onto cancer.gov/i131. The website has a calculator to get a rough idea of the risk to children born before 1971. Then you're asked to tell your story. Address it to: Isaf al-Nabulsi, PhD Senior Program Officer 500 Fifth Street NW Washington, D.C. 20001. Email address is ialnabul@nas.edu. Explorer ©Copyright 2004 Oregon Trail Broadcasting KPVI ***************************************************************** 21 THE ROY PROCESS IS STILL AVAILABLE Date: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 17:59:49 -0800 Concerned Citizens, The Roy Process for denaturing high level nuclear waste, plutonium and "dirty bomb" elements is still available to a company capable of realization. This unique photon transmutation method can be done with existing infrastructure, commercially available machinery and current supporting technology. A treatment facility can transmute spent fuel (nuclear waste) at each nuclear power plant where it is stored in cooling ponds. The heat produced can make steam to drive the existing electric generators. Safe and secure burial of high level nuclear waste at Yucca Mountain is a scientific impossibility. Here is the original 1979 article: THE ARIZONA REPUBLIC Sunday, November 4, 1979 Process may kill radiation threat By CLARENCE W. BAILEY Copyright, 1979. The Arizona Republic TEMPE -- An internationally recognized Arizona State University physicist disclosed Saturday that he has discovered a method for treating nuclear reac­tor and other highly dangerous radioactive wastes so they will be harmless. The procedure was conceived by Dr. Radha R. Roy professor of nuclear physics who is the designer and former director of nuclear-physics research fa­cilities at the University of Brussels In Belgium. and at Pennsylvania State Uni­versity. Roy said the process “very roughly can be described in part as a reversal of phenomena that occur during a nuclear fission chain reactions. The scientist said the process is the culmination of many years research “Theoretical analysis and mathematical calculations confirm the process is highly effective and that any level of radio activity, from weak to strong. Can be reduced to harmless state in a short period of time,” Roy said. The thing that is so encouraging is that the method can cancel radioactivity rapidly enough for it to be of r real practical value in disposing of dangerous wastes in storage and as they are being produced, Roy said. One treatment-plant design which Roy has devised could reduce the radioac­tivity of even the most dangerous wastes with half-lives or 15,000 to 40,000 years to a level where they would be essentially harmless in about 20 days. A half-life is the time required for a quantity of radioactive material to lose one half of its radioactive strength. Roy, who left his native Calcutta, India. to do advanced nuclear- physics re­search at the University of London during World War II, said all the necessary theoretical and quantum electrodynamical work on the process has been completed. “There remains perhaps as much as a years work in calculating parameters and preparing data that will he needed for the engineering design of a pilot radio­active waste-treatment plant’ he said. Roy is known internationally among scientists for his many advanced research contributions in the field of nuclear fission fragments and as the author of de­finitive graduate and post-doctoral textbooks used in universities all over the world. “During the 37 years since the first fission chain reaction there has been no progress whatever toward the development of a method of deactivating radioactive waste or even for storing it safely,” he said. “The collections of dangerous nuclear wastes in this country alone have now reached a total of at least 75 million gallons, and it is growing daily.” He estimated an operational nuclear waste-treatment plant could cost $40 mil­lion or more. By contrast, he noted, Congress last summer appropriated $80 million just to build more concrete storage bunkers to hold only a part of the growing accumulation of nuclear wastes. “Since it is so very dangerous to ship strongly radioactive materials it would certainly be sensible to build a treatment plant for each reactor so radioactivity could be killed out before the waste is transported anywhere" the scientist said. Roy said that the national danger from nuclear waste is "extremely serious" and urged the federal government to build treatment plants near established nuclear waste storage areas. Other treatment plants should be constructed to kill out the radioactivity in the wastes from the nation's weapons programs and from its educational, industrial, medical and experimental research facilities he said. Roy warned that waste containing plutonium 239 is "critically dangerous" because of its extremely high radioactivity and also because it is the essential ingredient in an atomic bomb. The treatment process not only will render plutonium 239 harmless in a remarkably short time, he said, but also will keep deactivated plutonium from ever being reprocessed to make an illegal atomic weapon. Roy further warned that the United States not only is exporting nuclear energy when it sells reactor technology to foreign nations, but also is sending overseas the potential for making illegal bombs out of plutonium from reprocessed nuclear wastes. The treatment method will guarantee to foreign countries that use nuclear fission energy that they can maintain an environment free from radioactivity, and it also could guarantee to the world that there will be no reuse of plutonium in an unauthorized weapon, he said. Careful theoretical and mathematical analysis have assured him that the nuclear waste- treatment process will function reliably and with rapidity and high efficiency, he said. "But the existence of this promising nuclear waste-treatment procedure should not be construed in any sense to mean that nuclear fission power reactors are safe" Roy said. The contractor who built Three Mile Island's reactor-like those who built the other 71 reactors now operational in the United States -- expected that plant to function normally for 30 years in total safety without event .But the fact is that it went out of control and nearly created a meltdown which could have destroyed a large part of the human habitat of east-central Pennsylvania,'' Roy said. ---------------------------------------- Neutralize & Eliminate Nuclear Waste For Good The Roy Process Brief Description from the web site: http://members.cox.net/theroyprocess Is there a safe process to get rid of nuclear waste? One possible solution is a process invented by Dr. Radha R. Roy, former professor of Physics at Arizona State University, and designer and former director of the nuclear physics research facilities at the University of Brussels in Belgium and at Pennsylvania State University. Dr. Roy is an internationally known nuclear physicist, consultant, and the author of over 60 articles and several books. He is also a contributing author of many invited articles in a prestigious encyclopedia. He is cited in American Men and Women of Science, Who`s Who in America, Who`s Who in the World and the International Biographical Centre, England. He has spent 52 years in European and American universities researching and writing recognized books on nuclear physics. He has supervised many doctoral students. Roy invented a process for transmuting radioactive nuclear isotopes to harmless, stable isotopes. This process is viable not only for nuclear waste from reactors but also for low-level radioactive waste products. In 1979, Roy announced his transmutation process and received international attention. The Roy process does not require storage of radioactive materials. No new equipment is required. In fact, all of the equipment and the chemical separation processes needed are well known. What`s the basis for the Roy Process? If you examine radioactive elements such as strontium 90, cesium 137 and plutonium 239, you will see that they all have too many neutrons. To put it very simply, the Roy process transmutes these unstable isotopes to stable ones by knocking out the extra neutrons. When a neutron is removed, the resulting isotope has a considerably shorter half-life which then decays to a stable form in a reasonable amount of time. How do we knock out neutrons? By bombarding them with photons (produced as x-rays) in a high- powered electron linear accelerator. Before this process, the isotopes must be separated by a well-known chemical process. It is feasible that portable units could be built and transported to hazardous sites for on-site transmutation of nuclear wastes and radioactive wastes. To give an example, cesium 137 with a half-life of 30.17 years is transformed into cesium 136 with a half-life of 13 days. Plutonium 239 with a half-life of 24,300 years is transformed into plutonium 237 with a half-life of 45.6 days. Subsequent radioactive elements which will be produced from the decay of plutonium 237 can be treated in the same way as above until the stable element is formed. From the Patent application claim: http://members.cox.net/theroyprocess/additional-uses-royprocess.html Dr. Roy was right. There IS only one way to totally eliminate high level nuclear waste and that is to transmute and denature it for good. Dennis F. Nester Phoenix, Arizona (602) 494-9361 Atomic Age Timeline Animation: http://www.animatedsoftware.com/poifu/poifu.swf ***************************************************************** 22 Lowell Sun: Tewksbury, Billerica to meet on water contamination www.lowellsun.com/ November 11, 2004 Lowell, MA By JENNIFER AMY MYERS, Sun Correspondent TEWKSBURY Determined to get to the bottom of the town's drinking-water woes, Selectman Jerry Selissen said he will a meet with the Billerica Board of Selectmen on Nov. 15 in hopes of creating a joint task force between the two towns. "In speaking with Billerica Board of Selectman Chairman Francis Fraine, I've realized that their board is not totally familiar with the issue," Selissen said. "I'd like to familiarize them with this and get people working together. "I want to move forward and see if we can find the ultimate source of the perchlorate and put this to bed once and for all" Selissen added. "We need to communicate between the communities about this situation." In August, perchlorate, a chemical used to produce explosives and rocket fuel, was discovered in Tewksbury's drinking water, prompting a public health advisory. The chemical has been found in samples taken from both the Merrimack and Concord rivers, but only Tewksbury's drinking-water supply has been impacted. Officials have discovered perchlorate levels in water exiting the Lowell and Billerica wastewater treatment plants to be higher than that of water entering the plants. They are investigating whether perchlorate is a byproduct of bleach used to treat wastewater. Town Manager David Cressman told selectmen last night that perchlorate levels in samples of town drinking water taken in October ranged from 1.2 to 1.385 parts per billion. In order to lift the public health advisory, the water must maintain a level of less than 1 ppb for eight straight weeks. "Billerica plans to do 24-hour composite sampling at six sewer pump stations to determine where perchlorate exists in the sewer collection system," Cressman said. Cressman added that Lewis Zediana, chief operator of the Tewksbury water-treatment plant, the DEP and Billerica officials, believe tests now show perchlorate entering the sewer plant. Although the general public is not at risk and there are no federal or state drinking-water standards for perchlorate, the state Department of Environmental Protection advises that women who are pregnant or nursing, children under 12, and those with untreated thyroid disorders not drink the water. In other business last night, Cressman reported that four town-owned buildings and six schools are not equipped with defibrillators. According to an inventory prepared by Fire Chief Richard Mackey, the Fire Department has seven defibrillators, the Police Department has 10 and the library, Recreation Department, senior center and high school currently house one each. Town buildings that are not equipped include Town Hall and its annex, the water-treatment plant and the Department of Public Works. "These should almost be standard features in all buildings, like fire extinguishers," selectmen Chairman Joe Gill said. A defibrillator provides an electrical pulse through the heart, restoring a normal rhythm, in the event of a sudden cardiac arrest. Cressman said he would like to purchase the four machines needed to equip the town buildings by the end of this fiscal year, pending savings in some accounts. If the money cannot be found in this year's budget, he said he will budget them for next year. Each defibrillator costs $1497.50, at a total cost of $5,990 to fully equip town buildings and $8,985 for the schools. "We should take steps to make sure these things are on site," Selectman John Ryan said, reacting to news that the high school is the only school building that has a defibrillator. "This is a subject we need to revisit during budget talks." ] © 1999-2004 MediaNews Group, Inc. ***************************************************************** 23 Bellona: TVEL Corporation to increase nuclear fuel production The production of the uranium powder would increase in four times after the launch of new line at the Novosibirsk Plant for Chemical Concentrates. 2004-11-10 17:15 The state Russian Corporation TVEL intends to increase export of the nuclear fuel by intensifying production of the uranium powder. The Novosibirsk Plant for Chemical Concentrates, which is a part of the TVEL, will start construction of the new line, which should increase the plant’s capacity in four times, daily Vedomosti reported. The TVEL is a state corporation where 100% of its shares belong to the Russian Ministry of Property Relations. TVEL manages the federal shares of the major Russian companies engaged in uranium mining and nuclear fuel reprocessing. The TVEL consists of 11 companies specialising in uranium mining, nuclear fuel production for nuclear plants, navy and research reactors. The Novosibirsk Plant for Chemical Concentrates produces fuel elements, uranium for research reactors and lithium and it is the biggest produces of the fuel for the NPPs. The TVEL controls 89% of the voting shares of the Novosibirsk plant. In 2003 the plant showed $166m sales result and $20m net profit. The Novosibirsk plant used to produce the fuel elements packed with uranium dioxide pellets from Ust-Kamenogorsk, Kazakhstan. The full dependence on one supplier forced the Novosibirsk plant to establish its own production of uranium dioxide pellets and powder. In 2003 the plant launched the production line with 200 tonne powder and pellets capacity per year what corresponded to 30-40% of the plant’s needs. The TVEL’s president Alexander Nyago said at the opening ceremony of the new production line that the Novosibirsk plant would be more stable by producing all the components independently. The TVEL Corporation is considering the proposal of the Novosibirsk plant for the construction of the second production line with 600 tonnes annual capacity. Its construction would require about $35m, but could allow increasing profit by $10-11m per year. However, the plant would continue to buy uranium dioxide pellets in Kazakhstan as the TVEL’s plants increase production. The complete production at one place could allow controlling quality better and taking part in the European tenders for nuclear fuel deliveries, Vedomosti reported. Publisher: Bellona Foundation, President: Frederic Hauge Information: info@bellona.no, Technical contact: webmaster@bellona.no Telephone: +47 23 23 46 00 Telefax: +47 22 38 38 62 * P.O.Box 2141 Grunerlokka, 0505 Oslo, Norway ***************************************************************** 24 Bellona: Truck with radioactive scrap metal stopped in Petropavlovsk-Kamchatsk The security guards stopped the truck with radioactive scrap metal at the entry to the commercial port of Petropavlovsk-Kamchatsk, the Russian Far East. 2004-11-10 18:10 On October 19, RIA-Novosti reported that radiation alarm was triggered when a truck was passing the port’s checkpoint. The truck was loaded with scrap metal from the military unit in closed town Viluchinsk. The detected radiation levels were not dangerous. The radioactive cargo was sent back to the military unit for the thorough check of the container content. The Russian most eastern nuclear submarine base is situated near Viluchinsk. Publisher: Bellona Foundation, President: Frederic Hauge Information: info@bellona.no, Technical contact: webmaster@bellona.no Telephone: +47 23 23 46 00 Telefax: +47 22 38 38 62 * P.O.Box 2141 Grunerlokka, 0505 Oslo, Norway ***************************************************************** 25 Las Vegas SUN: UNLV researchers tackle nuke waste November 10, 2004 School takes lead in study of transmutation By Christina Littlefield LAS VEGAS SUN Some UNLV researchers are trying to be the modern equivalent of alchemists, but instead of seeking a cost effective way to turn lead into gold they are searching for an efficient way to change high-level radioactive waste into low-level waste so that it is less dangerous. The technology could eliminate the nation's need to bury nuclear waste in deep geological repositories such as the Yucca Mountain site, researchers said. The problem is that it will take a lot of gold -- billions of dollars -- to "transmute" nuclear waste on a large scale, said Anthony Hechanova, director of UNLV's Transmutation Research Program. The federal government currently funds transmutation research at about $60 million a year, Hechanova said, and at the current rate, large-scale facilities to try to transform the waste will not be online until 2030. Yucca Mountain is scheduled to begin accepting waste by 2010. "Right now, the Department of Energy's interest in the (research) program is to avoid building a second repository," Hechanova said. "If we stay at the current level (of producing nuclear waste), every 20 years we would need to build a new Yucca Mountain." As researchers at the lead university in the national transmutation research program, Hechanova and other UNLV researchers are meeting with scientists from around the world this week to discuss advances in nuclear partitioning and transmutation that may make the process easier. This week's international conference, one of a handful the university hosts on the topic each year, has brought experts on nuclear fuel and transmutation from 22 countries to UNLV's Harry Reid Center for Environmental Studies. Hosting the conference greatly increases UNLV's prestige as a scientific research university while allowing professors to discuss their ideas on transmutation with some of the best in the field, Gary Cerefice, deputy director of UNLV's Transmutation Research Group, said. UNLV has been at the forefront of the nation's efforts to find ways to change nuclear waste since Congress first funded the research in 2001, Hechanova said. Spurred by the possibility of playing host to the nation's nuclear waste at Yucca Mountain, Nevada's congressional delegation helped fight for both the national funding and UNLV's initial $3 million allocation to research transmutation and radiochemistry. To date, the university has received about $15 million in federal money in the past four years to pay for student and faculty research projects, equipment and infrastructure support and international collaborations that advance transmutation research. That's more money than all of the other participating universities have received combined, Hechanova said, and allows UNLV to train both undergraduate and graduate students to be the future experts on an issue that has uniquely impacted Nevadans with the proposed Yucca Mountain site. It's also allowed UNLV to bring on five new professors from such top universities as the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. "What does that say about UNLV that people are coming here from MIT for our academic program," Hechanova said. "I predict that in about five years UNLV will have the No. 1 actinide program in the nation, if not the world. "It makes sense for UNLV to lead this research because if they do move forward with Yucca Mountain, we want to have experts here ... who are independent from federal government." UNLV researchers are studying 27 different issues related to nuclear partitioning and transmutation, including actinide chemistry, which includes the study of how radioactive metals react with other materials over time. A new actinide laboratory being finished this week will allow students and faculty to work with plutonium. Nuclear partitioning is the separation of the nuclear waste into its individual elements. It allows scientists to significantly reduce the amount of waste that has to be classified as high-level waste, Hechanova said. Only about two percent of used nuclear fuel is extremely radioactive and the rest of the waste can, if separated out, be classified as low-level or non-radioactive waste. Some of the elements, such as plutonium, can also be recycled to produce more nuclear fuel, Hechanova said. In the future, other elements of nuclear waste may be recycled for use in other industries, such as medicine. Once spent nuclear fuel is reduced to its individual elements, highly radioactive particles can then be changed into low-level waste, Hechanova said. The transmutation rate can reduce the waste's radioactive life down to 100 to 300 years as opposed to the 100,000 years scientists predict the waste will be toxic if left untreated, Hechanova said. In predicting the safety of Yucca Mountain, "scientists have a lot of confidence in how geology materials act over 100 years but we don't over 100,000 years," Hechnova said. With the continued advancement of the technology, Hechanova said it's possible to completely eliminate the need for geological repositories as all nuclear waste will be able to be recycled or reduced to such a low-level toxicity that certified landfills could accept it. The Nevada Test Site and several other landfills throughout the country already accept low-level waste, Hechanova said. The UNLV research program works involves students and faculty in six departments across three different colleges, including students studying mechanical and electrical engineering, chemistry, geoscience, physics and health physics, Hechanova said. Students and faculty also benefit from partnerships with leading nuclear research institutions such as Los Alamos in New Mexico, and through international collaborations with Russia, the Republic of Georgia, France, Israel and Canada, as well as the European community at large, Cerefice said. The research program has also allowed the university to build eight new laboratories and bring in equipment such as a transmission electron microscope that students in several scientific disciplines can use. With the capacity to magnify an image up to 1.3 million times, the transmission electron microscope is a $1.3 million investment the university could never have made on its own, Hechanova and Cerefice said. "We're picking up infrastructure that would take us years to develop," Cerefice said. The research program supported more than 35 researchers and more than 70 students in its first three years, producing 23 master's degree graduates and one Ph.D graduate, Cerefice said. "We're training people who will be the decision makers for the next 50 years." Questions or problems? Click here. ***************************************************************** 26 RGJ: Experts discuss recycling spent nuclear fuel ASSOCIATED PRESS 11/10/2004 11:33 pm LAS VEGAS — Scientists from around the world were meeting this week to consider ways to recycle spent nuclear fuel, saying the process could relieve pressure to bury the highly radioactive waste at sites such as Yucca Mountain in Nevada. One expert attending a conference at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas compared reprocessing and transmutation to “the alchemist’s dream of turning lead into gold.” “What hasn’t been shown is the feasibility at the engineering level,” said scientist Gary Cerefice, among the hosts of the gathering of about 120 scientists from countries including France, Japan and Russia. Although developing the techniques could take decades, the pursuit continues abroad to reprocess or recycle spent nuclear fuel pellets. “We’re doing the research. The implementation is many, many years away,” said Carter “Buzz” Savage, who directs the U.S. effort at the federal Energy Department. Reprocessing and transmutation won’t change the need for a repository the Energy Department wants to open in 2010 at Yucca Mountain, 90 miles northwest of Las Vegas. But it might reduce or eliminate the need for future repositories, Savage said. Reprocessing spent fuel in the United States has been prohibited since the mid-1970s, although the Bush administration allows research into extracting usable plutonium and uranium. The other technique, transmutation, would transform long-lived radionuclides such as americium and neptunium into smaller amounts of shorter-lived radioactive materials to be buried in a repository. Savage said the government is spending $68 million on the Advanced Fuel Cycle Initiative Program, with the same amount expected next year. Making transmutation viable would entail licensing a new generation of reprocessing plants, fuel fabrication plants and reactors. Some scientists envision regional facilities handling waste from commercial power reactors. One scenario would be to put a facility at Yucca Mountain. The Department of Energy plans to ask the Nuclear Regulatory Commission in December for a license for the Yucca Mountain repository. Commission review is expected to take several years. Copyright Reno Gazette-Journal, a Gannett Co. Inc.Newspaper. Use ***************************************************************** 27 Tewksbury Advocate: Board creates new policy, perchlorate task force TownOnline.com - By Bethan L. Jones/ Staff Writer Wednesday, November 10, 2004 The Board of Selectmen had a quiet meeting Tuesday night, yet still created a stir when it created a new policy of abutter notification, and addressed the Fiscal Year 2005 to 2009 capital improvement plan. Selectmen John Ryan took advantage of the light schedule to raise concerns about the boards current policy on notifying abutters in regard to hearings. The current policy requires the applicant notify abutters of the initial hearing but not subsequent hearings. Ryan said he was concerned it becomes difficult for neighbors to keep track of hearing dates, especially when hearings are continued from one meeting to another. "I just feel if we're going to put something off for a month, we should notify," said Ryan. Chairman Joseph Gill agreed with Ryan, saying the current policy maintains a level of informality. He added the second notification could be sent first class mail rather than sent certified. Town Counsel Charles Zaroulis said it would be appropriate to require the applicant to send the second notices if they are the party requesting the continuance. If the town needs additional time, it will pick up the tab. Selectmen Douglas Sears said the applicant should be required to submit an affidavit to the town documenting the notification, just as they are required for the initial notice. The selectmen unanimously adopted the new policy and will notify the other boards in town, urging them to reevaluate their notification policies. Town Manager David Cressman presented the board with both a four year capital improvement and his goals for 2005. Within both plans, Cressman cited the continued construction and work centering around the sewer project, with phase nine design work set to begin within the next few months. The recently approved senior center project and the continued feasibility study at Rocco's Landfill are also items which will receive attention and funds in the upcoming year. Other projects which have been in the works for some time such as the town hall improvements and central fire station have been put on the back burner until FY2007. Cressman also noted the needed funds for the Tewksbury Memorial High School reaccredidation and the maintenance on several elementary schools which are over thirty years old. He added, however, the plans are both conservative and reasonably attainable. "[The plans are] something we should be proud of in these tough economic times," said Ryan. Selectmen Jerome Selissen informed the board he will be appearing before Billerica's Board of Selectmen on Monday with the goal of creating a task force and opening the lines of communication between the towns in regard to the perchlorate problem. The Billerica Waste Water Treatment Plant is currently considered the main source of Tewksbury's perchlorate in the drinking water. "We're going to go forward and see if we can't find the source," said Selissen. Town tests for the month of October show Tewksbury's drinking water moving between 1.2 and 1.38 parts per billion, still above the 1 ppb needed to lift the water ban on those within the sensitive populations. The Selectmen and the Board of Health will be interviewing the four candidates for the open health seat on Tuesday, Nov. 23 at 6:30 p.m. prior to the Selectmen's regularly scheduled meeting. The Selectmen will then interview candidates for the Board of Appeals at 7:15 p.m. All interviews are open to the public but will not be televised. © Copyright of CNC and Herald Interactive Advertising Systems, ***************************************************************** 28 Las Vegas Mercury: Backstory: Four more what? Thursday, Nov 11, 2004, 09:07:11 PM Copyright © Las Vegas Mercury By Michael Green By small majorities, Americans support terrorism and Nevadans want a nuclear waste dump. It's not just that those who voted for The Rug want the continued murder of American soldiers in Iraq and persecution of minorities and the unreligious at home because they mistakenly think he's moral. Think about it. The Bush campaign used an ad--a brilliant one, by the way--blasting John Kerry for his comment that terrorism should be a "nuisance." No, obviously we want it to be a major threat, controlling our lives forever. Bush's campaign brilliantly capitalized on public fears and lack of thought to use it to attack Kerry. As for Nevada, in 2000, candidate Bush lied about nuclear waste at Yucca Mountain. Kerry vowed not to put it here. But a majority, including the R-J editorial page and its discredited pollster (what happened to Bush's 10- and six-point leads in Nevada?), chose nuclear waste. Logically, it should be buried under 1111 W. Bonanza Road or GOP headquarters, where the theory is that a three-point margin is a mandate only if a Republican wins. Meanwhile... • Nevada voters are smarter than South Dakota voters. A small state is unwise to unload a powerful senior senator, yet South Dakotans did that to Tom Daschle, a poor minority leader but a major player. Nevadans overwhelmingly returned their powerful senior senator, Harry Reid. But six years ago, with Nevadans knowing he would become assistant minority leader, he won by only 428 votes. So, we're not much smarter. • If Reid's night was bittersweet, state Senate Minority Leader Dina Titus' night was more sweet than bitter. Ridding the state Senate of Ray Shaffer dropped the GOP majority to 12-9, giving Democrats three seats out of seven on committees and Titus a spot on the Finance Committee--a fine place for her to exert influence, especially with a gubernatorial campaign on the horizon and Republicans staying with Bill Raggio and his pro-Reno budgeting. Meanwhile, Steven Horsford figures to be more of a team player and more effective in representing his district than Joe Neal, who often pecked at Titus, and helping Sen. Mike Schneider win probably improved relations with the incumbent. Her Democratic caucus figures to be a bit more united this time. • If you thought the presidential election was ugly, try the County Commission. The drunk, the crooked engineer and the strip club and casino toady beat the mudslinger, the slanderer and the drunken sexual harasser. But seriously, folks, there may have been a message. Despite a smaller bankroll, David Goldwater ran well against Lynette Boggs McDonald on a slower growth platform. Tom Collins talked about better planning in defeating Shari Buck, and similar noises came from Jerry Tao, whose loss to incumbent Chip Maxfield wasn't that large. Could this mean smarter growth policies? • Again, women judges. Sandra Pomrenze and Stefany Miley unseated Family Court judges Bob Lueck and Bob Gaston; Cynthia Dianne Steel gave better-funded Supreme Court candidate Jim Hardesty a run for his money; and women either won or garnered significant percentages in District and Justice Court battles. By the way, none of them was named Bonaventure. • Why did I get a mailer from Lori Lipman Brown, once a leading state Senate liberal, endorsing John Mason, who led the Nevada Republican Party during one of its sharp right turns in the 1990s? • Glad that Independent American Joel Hansen lost his bid for Nevada Supreme Court? Newly elected Justice Michael Douglas was known for intelligent and gutsy decisions locally, and his new colleagues Hardesty and Ron Parraguirre are among the state's most respected District Court judges. But it would be nice to know who made the racist phone calls opposing Douglas. • Nevadans are conservative, so they defeated a measure to increase education spending to fund schools at the national average, but liberal for supporting a minimum wage hike. They are conservative because they gave Bush a majority, but liberal because anti-gay activist Richard Ziser could muster only 35 percent against moderate Sen. Harry Reid. You want election analysis? Psychoanalysis might work better. • How important were the 2003 tax votes in the Legislature? The only Assembly Republican losers, Don Gustavson and Ron Knecht, were among the 15 obstructionists who blocked the tax hike through the regular session and two special sessions (and Knecht really impressed voters by introducing a bill to change Nevada's name to East California--and he probably opposes "frivolous" lawsuits). Assembly District 16 gave John Oceguera 58 percent despite a last-minute mailer from anti-tax blaster George Harris, who not only has no impact, but added to his sterling record by misspelling Oceguera's name. • Some doctors are perturbed. Yes, Questions 3, 4 and 5 went as they wished. But some residents received pro-Question 3 fliers accompanied by literature for Bush and other Republicans, and the doctors made clear they wanted to keep their campaign nonpartisan. Was it an accident or did it have something to do with the Republican operatives they hired? • Finally, here's to Dubya, a terrific politician. A once-drunken, unthinking liar convinced voters he's more moral and security-conscious than a man still carrying around shrapnel from defending his country and willing to sacrifice his wealth to help the poor. Either that, or 51 percent of American voters are stupid. That thought is even more frightening than four more years. Copyright © Las Vegas Mercury, 2001 - 2004 ***************************************************************** 29 Las Vegas RJ: Nuclear waste at center stage Wednesday, November 10, 2004 Scientists discuss reprocessing and recycling By KEITH ROGERS REVIEW-JOURNAL Scientists from around the world traveled to Las Vegas on Tuesday to talk about a common problem: How to reduce the amount of nuclear waste destined for yet-to-be-built repositories like the one planned for Yucca Mountain. The solution, they said, is to continue to develop and explore a couple techniques known in scientific circles as reprocessing and transmutation. As one put it, it's like "the alchemist's dream of turning lead into gold." "What hasn't been shown is the feasibility at the engineering level. We can do it one atom at a time," said scientist Gary Cerefice, among the hosts of the three-day conference at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas. About 120 scientists from countries including France, Japan and Russia are attending. Although progress in developing the techniques is measured in decades, the pursuit continues abroad to reprocess or recycle materials in spent nuclear fuel pellets. Reprocessing spent fuel in the United States has been prohibited since the mid-1970s. The Bush administration allows research into what it takes to extract usable plutonium and uranium. The other technique, transmutation, is aimed at taking long-lived radionuclides such as americium and neptunium and transforming them into smaller amounts of shorter-lived radioactive materials to be buried in a repository. "We're doing the research. The implementation is many, many years away," said Carter "Buzz" Savage, who directs the U.S. effort at the Department of Energy. Reprocessing and transmutation won't change the need for a Yucca Mountain repository but may reduce or eliminate the need for future repositories, he said. The task of making transmutation viable would entail licensing a new generation of reprocessing plants, fuel fabrication plants and reactors. Some scientists envision regional facilities to cater to commercial power reactors. One scenario would be to locate them at Yucca Mountain. The Department of Energy hopes to begin a licensing review in December for the proposed repository at Yucca Mountain, with first deliveries of spent fuel from U.S. power reactors in 2010. Savage said the government is spending $68 million on the Advanced Fuel Cycle Initiative Program, with the same amount expected next year. Copyright Las Vegas Review-Journal ***************************************************************** 30 Las Vegas RJ: Whistle-blower claims BLM firing over polluted mine Thursday, November 11, 2004 Federal complaint seeks damages of more than $1 million By SCOTT SONNER THE ASSOCIATED PRESS The Anaconda mine's pit in Yerington is shown in this July file photo. Photo by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS RENO -- The Bureau of Land Management's former project manager for a contaminated mine site in Nevada said Wednesday he was fired because he refused to stop speaking out about dangers posed there by radioactive and other toxic wastes. In a federal whistle-blower complaint seeking more than $1 million in damages, Earle Dixon of Carson City said BLM state Director Bob Abbey fired him in October in retaliation for his aggressive research and public comment on the health and safety risks to workers and the community near the former Anaconda copper mine on the edge of Yerington. A copy of the administrative complaint obtained by The Associated Press said Dixon refused to go along with repeated attempts by BLM management and the Nevada Division of Environmental Protection to downplay dangers at the 3,600-acre site and "sweep the issue under a political rug." BLM spokeswoman Jo Simpson said Wednesday the agency was not surprised the complaint had been filed but had no direct response to the charges. "We welcome the investigation and we believe the investigation will bear out that our actions were appropriate," she said. Environmental Protection Division spokeswoman Cindy Petterson said the state agency has made no attempt to downplay the seriousness of the mine's pollution. She said personnel changes BLM made in the management of the project a month ago "has led to an improvement in the process." The complaint says cleanup costs at the abandoned mine owned by Atlantic Richfield Co. have risen dramatically, from an estimated $10 million or $20 million to potentially more than $200 million, as a result of research Dixon conducted or directed on dangers from uranium and other toxins. Tests this summer found unusually high levels of radiation in soil samples at the mine. Earlier groundwater tests showed high concentrations of uranium in wells on site, up to 200 times the U.S. drinking water standard. "The site is an environmental compliance mess. There is nothing in compliance: not groundwater, not air, not soil," Dixon said. "It needs to be addressed. I was trying to move forward and get it addressed and that's not what the BLM or NDEP wanted." "Every time I would try to put real technical comments in there and cite things relative to Superfund guidelines, they would take out those parts and water it down," he said in an interview Wednesday. Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility, a Washington D.C.-based watchdog group, filed the formal whistle-blower complaint with the Labor Department in San Francisco last week on behalf of Dixon, an environmental protection specialist who earlier taught at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas and spent eight years doing research for the U.S. Energy Department at the Nevada Test Site. The complaint said Dixon was at least partly responsible for documenting radiation readings, contamination of soil and water, and Arco and BLM noncompliance with federal pollution standards, including possible public exposure to radioactive and toxic metals in airborne dust. Jeff Ruch, PEER's executive director, said federal law makes it clear "you cannot be discriminated against for implementing the Clean Air Act or the Safe Drinking Water Act. "You can't be fired for doing your job, and Earle Dixon was fired for doing his job," Ruch said from Washington. The 34-page complaint includes 23 pages of summaries of notes Dixon took of meetings and telephone conversations with his superiors, EPA, state regulators and others over the course of at least 87 days between the time he was hired in November 2003 and fired on Oct. 5. Among other things, Dixon insisted on personally observing sampling, collecting worker safety-related data, and developing a formal site health and safety plan "that would draw attention to the problem by forcing workers to wear respirators, a visible red flag to the community," the complaint said. The complaint said BLM responded by criticizing him for his disclosures, ordering him not to speak to the media, and censoring and editing his technical communications and memos. The complaint said BLM's public affairs director in Reno told Dixon's immediate supervisor on July 23 that Dixon was "not to talk to press at all" following a telephone interview with AP the day before in which Dixon said, "Nobody is used to having this sort of radiation at an old abandoned copper mine." Copyright Las Vegas Review-Journal ***************************************************************** 31 The Sunflower - November 2004 - No. 90 Date: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 23:22:45 -0600 (CST) The Sunflower is a monthly e-newsletter providing educational information on nuclear weapons abolition and other issues relating to global security. Help us spread the word and forward this to a friend. Click here to help sustain this valuable resource by making a donation. To receive our free monthly e-newsletter subscribe at http://www.wagingpeace.org/subscribe/ Download the complete PDF Version * Perspectives * First Presidential Mandate: Protect Us from Nuclear Terrorism and Proliferation * A New Bridge to Nuclear Disarmament by Douglas Roche * Take Action * Election Behind Us, Work Before Us * Abolition Now and Mayors for Peace Emergency Campaign * Energy Communities Alliance Annual Conference - Save the Date * Proliferation * Tentative Deal Reached with Iran * Taiwan Denies Plutonium Experiments * US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Closes Online Library * Switzerland Opens Nuclear Investigation, Pakistani Scientist Remains in Custody * Russian Scientist Surrenders Weapons-Grade Nuclear Material * Nuclear Legacy * Nuclear Radiation in the Arctic * US Navy Closes Project ELF * Sweden Denies Vanunu Asylum * Nuclear Laboratories * Work Still Halted at Los Alamos * Iraq * Update on the Iraq Debacle * Missiles, Defense and Missile Defense * US Defense Companies Reap "Healthy" Profits * October: International Missile Test Month? * Nuclear Energy and Waste * Congress Reclassifies High-Level Radioactive Waste * Japan Moves Towards Reprocessing Spent Nuclear Fuel * Yucca Mountain Exacerbates Nuclear Waste Storage Crisis * Washington State Initiative Blocks Nuclear Waste Dumping for Now * US Nuclear Regulatory Commission to Join Search for Missing Nuclear Fuel Rods * Switzerland Increases Distribution of Tablets to Guard Against Nuclear Radiation * Nuclear Insanity * Indian Nuclear Option Helped Remove Potentially Dangerous Strategic Ambiguities in the Region * Nuclear Reactor Shut-Down in Russia Causes Frenzy * French Anti-Nuclear Protester Run Over by Train * Foundation Activities * Broadcasting Peace: A Conversation with Walter Cronkite * Resources * United Nations Disarmament Stamp * As Time Goes By: Making the Case for Love in a Time of Fear * Committee Examining Radiation Risks of Internal Emitters Report Published * Uranium in the Wind by Ross Wilcock * Missile Defense All Over Again * BASIC October Report * Quotable * Walter Cronkite * Mohamed ElBaradei * Pope John Paul II * Arundhati Roy * Senior Aide to President Bush * Chris Hedges * The Economist * Henry Kissinger * Martin Luther King, Jr. * Stephen Hawking * Editorial Team * Luke Brothers * David Krieger * Carah Ong * Forrest Wilder Perspectives First Presidential Mandate: Protect Us from Nuclear Terrorism and Proliferation | Top The primary mandate of President George W. Bush is to protect US citizens. In fact, Republicans and Democrats alike agree that nuclear proliferation and terrorism are THE greatest threats facing the US . In his second term, President Bush has the opportunity to make Americans - and people all over the world - safer and more secure by implementing responsible nuclear policies that will prevent the spread of nuclear weapons and prevent terrorists from obtaining and using nuclear weapons, technology and materials. To accomplish these goals, the Nuclear Age Peace Foundation recommends that President Bush's first order of business in his second term should be providing global leadership to create and maintain a worldwide inventory of nuclear weapons and nuclear weapons materials and to place these weapons and materials under strict international safeguards. The US should also immediately increase its efforts and devote more resources to securing loose nuclear weapons and materials in Russia . Preventing nuclear proliferation and nuclear terrorism cannot be based on double-standards. A US nuclear policy that relies on these weapons for the foreseeable future, combined with the doctrine of preemptive warfare, encourages other nations to acquire nuclear weapons in pursuit of their own security needs. President Bush should immediately cease all efforts to create a dangerous new generation of nuclear weapons, including the Robust Nuclear Earth Penetrator ("bunker-busters") and low-yield nuclear weapons ("mini-nukes"). Researching and developing new generations of nuclear weapons undermines US credibility in persuading other nations not to pursue their own nuclear arsenals. President Bush has said that the US must shoulder the responsibility of leading global efforts to halt proliferation of nuclear weapons. To do this, the US must lead all nuclear weapons states in fulfilling their existing obligations under international law to pursue the phased elimination of nuclear weapons. There is no other way to assure that these weapons will not be obtained or used by terrorists or states hostile to the US . "President Bush's number one mandate this term is to fulfill his campaign promise to protect US citizens from the greatest threats facing us today - nuclear proliferation and terrorism," stated David Krieger, President of the Nuclear Age Peace Foundation. "President Bush must restore US credibility around the world by implementing responsible nuclear policies." A New Bridge to Nuclear Disarmament | Top by Douglas Roche A bridge on the long road to nuclear disarmament was built when eight NATO States supported a New Agenda Coalition resolution at the United Nations calling for more speed in implementing commitments to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. The bridge gained extra strength when Japan and South Korea joined with the NATO 8 - Belgium , Canada , Germany , Lithuania , Luxembourg , The Netherlands, Norway and Turkey . These States, along with the New Agenda countries - Brazil , Egypt , Ireland , Mexico , New Zealand , South Africa and Sweden - now form an impressive and perhaps formidable center in the nuclear weapons debate and can play a determining role in the outcome of the 2005 NPT Review Conference. The bridge they have formed links the nuclear weapons States , which are entrenching nuclear weapons in their military doctrines, and the Non-Aligned Movement, which wants immediate negotiations on a time-bound program for nuclear disarmament. It is hard to know what to call this new collection of important States in the center. It is certainly not an entity. To be called a working partnership, it will at least have to pursue a common goal. And it is by no means certain that the tensions within the center can be contained. Nonetheless, the strategy adopted by the New Agenda Coalition to make its annual resolution at the U.N. First Committee more attractive particularly to the NATO and like-minded States - and thus shore up the moderate middle in the nuclear weapons debate - is working. Although the bridge needs strengthening, it is firm enough for the centrist States to exert leverage on the nuclear weapons States to take minimum steps to save the NPT in 2005. Click here to read the full article. To view the entire Sunflower, visit: http://www.wagingpeace.org/menu/resrources/sunflower or Download the complete PDF Version To receive our free monthly e-newsletter subscribe at http://www.wagingpeace.org/menu/resources/subscribe/ ***************************************************************** 32 [du-list] DU in the news - 11/11/04 Date: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 17:59:55 -0800 Thursday, November 11, 2004 11:26 AM PST Your Keyword News Alert for [depleted uranium] matched the following stories: Asia Times, Thu, 11 Nov 2004 4:07 AM PST Middle East http://atimes.com/atimes/Middle_East/FK12Ak04.html "The bombs being dropped on Fallujah don't contain explosives, depleted uranium or anything harmful - they contain laughing gas - that would, of course, explain [Pentagon chief Donald] Rumsfeld's misplaced optimism about not killing civilians in Fallujah. Guardian Unlimited, Wed, 10 Nov 2004 4:07 PM PST Tumbleweed collection http://www.guardian.co.uk/life/dispatch/story/0,12978,1347782,00.html Tumbleweed, sometimes called Russian thistle, is that cartwheel-shaped shrub seen blowing across the screen just before the showdown in dozens of Westerns. It could have a new role in cleaning up battlefields and weapons testing grounds, because it has a knack of soaking up depleted uranium, or DU. Corvallis Gazette Times, Wed, 10 Nov 2004 9:05 PM PST OSU to host Global Action' series http://www.gazettetimes.com/articles/2004/11/11/news/community/wedloc03.txt "From Global Awareness to Global Action," a seven-hour experience focusing on world issues, will run from 1 to 8 p.m. today at Oregon State University's Memorial Union. Fairfield County Weekly, Thu, 11 Nov 2004 1:18 AM PST The News that Didn't Make The News Make the News http://fairfieldweekly.com/gbase/News/content?oid=oid:89269 Project Censored is a media research group out of Sonoma State University which tracks the news published in independent journals and newsletters. Seattle Weekly, Wed, 10 Nov 2004 5:05 PM PST Veterans Day Address to the Nation http://www.seattleweekly.com/features/0446/041110_news_veteransday.php A suggested speech for the president. In honor of Veterans Day this week, George Bush is likely to say a few words about those who served. [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] ------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~--> Make a clean sweep of pop-up ads. Yahoo! Companion Toolbar. Now with Pop-Up Blocker. Get it for free! http://us.click.yahoo.com/L5YrjA/eSIIAA/yQLSAA/FGYolB/TM --------------------------------------------------------------------~-> To unsubscribe from this groups send a message to du-list-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com. In the body of the message type unsubscribe and send. Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/du-list/ <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: du-list-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/ ***************************************************************** NOTE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107 this material is distributed without profit or payment to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving this information for non-profit research and educational purposes only. For more information go to: *****************************************************************