*****************************************************************
04/19/04 **** RADIATION BULLETIN(RADBULL) **** VOL 12.94
*****************************************************************
RADBULL IS PRODUCED BY THE ABALONE ALLIANCE CLEARINGHOUSE
*****************************************************************
Send News Stories to news@energy-net.org with title on subject
line and first line of body
NUCLEAR POLICY
1 Subject: ANNOUNCEMENT - PROTEST IN MOSCOW ON APRIL 22 (CHERNOBYL
2 BBC: Denmark reveals Iraq arms secrets
3 BBC: Kim 'in China for secret talks'
4 Korea: Digital Chosunilbo: Kim Jong-il Must Learn His ¡°Chinese Less
5 UPI: Analysis: Nuke-for-energy deal for Kim?
6 VANUNU -- EVEN CONTACT WITH PARENTS WILL BE FORBIDDEN
7 Vanunu Prison Video Broadcast Irks Supporters
8 Amnesty Int'l - Vanunu must be free
9 [southnews] Vanunu ordered to stay in Israel
10 Vanunu restrictions eased a little
11 AFP: I'm not a traitor, says Israeli nuclear whistleblower on eve of
12 Reuters: Nuke Whistleblower Wants Israel's Reactor Destroyed
13 Haaretz: Limits on Vanunu eased slightly ahead of release
14 Haaretz: Ignore Vanunu; don't restrict him
15 SFC: Vanunu's release refocuses attention on Israel's `bomb in the b
16 Reuters: What Nuke Whistleblower Doesn't Know Scares Israel
17 Arutz Sheva: Ministers Instructed to Remain Silent on Vanunu Affair
18 BostonHerald: Vanunu: Israel's nuclear reactor should be destroyed
19 Straits Times: Beijing pulls no punches with Cheney -
NUCLEAR REACTORS
20 US: NRC: NRC Renews License for H.B. Robinson Steam Electric Plant,
21 US: NRC: Report on the Independent Verification of the Mitigating Sy
22 Herald: Call to expand nuclear power use attacked by greens
23 Pravda.RU: Vietnam modernizes its nuclear reactor
24 US: AP Wire: NRC approves license renewal for Pee Dee nuclear plant
25 US: PRN: Robinson Nuclear Plant's License Renewed by NRC Through Jul
26 US: NRC: NRC to Hold Predecisional Enforcement Conference to Discuss
27 US: NRC: NRC to Meet with Duke Energy Officials to Discuss Safety Pe
NUCLEAR SAFETY
28 [DU-WATCH] connecting dots in Iraq
29 US: [DU-WATCH] Thom Hartmann Radio Interview with Leuren Moret on
30 US: [DU-WATCH] why we didn't check before - chelation therapy (or
31 Records on DU Exposures Never Saw the Light of Day
32 US: [RADFOOD] good news and action item
33 DU contaminated vets return from Iraq
34 US: Gallup Independent: Ex-workers have health problems
35 US: New York Daily News: G.I.s press Army for uranium test
36 BBC: Nuclear sub surfaces in Arctic
37 ITAR-TASS: Security at Moscow’s nuclear facilities raises concerns
NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE
38 US: Salt Lake Tribune: No more nuclear waste
39 US: Zwire: EPA to revise Foote Mineral cleanup plan
40 KLAS: State Advises Yucca Workers to be Tested
41 US: NEWS.com.au: ERA apologises for contamination
42 NRC: NRC Approves Restart of Final Stage in Uranium Hexafluoride Pro
NUCLEAR WEAPONS
US DEPT. OF ENERGY
43 Lenawee Online News GUEST EDITORIAL: A wasteful compensation program
44 Rocky Mountain News: Proposed land use near butte criticized
OTHER NUCLEAR
45 Google News Alert - nuclear
46 Scotsman.com: Wind power 'will cost taxpayer millions'
*****************************************************************
*****************************************************************
FULL NEWS STORIES
*****************************************************************
*****************************************************************
1 Subject: ANNOUNCEMENT - PROTEST IN MOSCOW ON APRIL 22 (CHERNOBYL
Date: Tue, 20 Apr 2004 05:11:06 +0400 Ecodefense Moscow,
April 20, 2004
ANNOUNCEMENT
On Thursday, April 22, Ecodefense will stage non-violent
anti-nuclear protest in Moscow (Russia). Action will take place
at 1 pm (13-00), near the Ministry of industry and energy.
(Address: Kitaigorodsky pr. 7)
Activists from 6 Russian cities will come down to Moscow to
express its protest over plans of Russian government to build new
nuclear reactors and import foreign nuclear waste.
After governmental reform occured earlier in 2004, Ministry of
industry and energy became responsible for the strategy and
policy of energy industries, including nuclear. Activists will
call on minister Viktor Khristenko to stop construction of new
nuclear reactors, and the import of nuclear waste (spent nuclear
fuel) to Russia.
For more info in Moscow call 7766281, 2784642 (Vladimir Slivyak)
e-mail: ecodefense@online.ru www.antiatom.ru
*****************************************************************
2 BBC: Denmark reveals Iraq arms secrets
Last Updated: Monday, 19 April, 2004
[Prime Minister Anders Fogh Rasmussen]
Mr Rasmussen says the reports vinidcate him
Denmark has declassified intelligence reports compiled before the
Iraq war which show officials thought Iraq had weapons of mass
destruction.
In one report, Iraq was thought to have both chemical and
biological weapons, as well as an active nuclear programme.
The extracts appear to contradict claims leaked to a newspaper
that there was no evidence to back up the theory.
Former intelligence officer Major Frank Soeholm Grevil has been
charged with breaching the official information act.
The major told reporters at the Berlingske Tidende newspaper he
had sent 10 reports to the prime minister which concluded that
the coalition was unlikely to find weapons of mass destruction.
Pressure
The two journalists who published the leaks, Jesper Larsen and
Michael Bjerre, have been charged with exploiting information
emerging from a crime.
Before the war, Danish Prime Minister Anders Fogh Rasmussen
supported the US-led invasion and told parliament that he was
convinced Iraq was in possession of such weapons.
I don't think we get complete picture of what the government knew
Jeppe Kofod, Social Democrats spokesman
Denmark sent a submarine and a warship to participate in the
campaign.
Since the leaks - and the failure to find any weapons of mass
destruction - the prime minister has come under increasing
pressure from opposition parties to declassify the reports.
But Danish Defence Intelligence Service (DDIS) chief Rear Admiral
Joern Olesen said: "These reports that have been made public
document that Iraq, according to the entire DDIS's evaluation,
probably had biological and chemical weapons just before the
war."
Mr Olesen said the documents were based on information gathered
by the United Nations and Nato but the reports warned that "any
evaluation is subject to uncertainties".
Mr Fogh Rasmussen said the documents were proof that neither he
nor anyone else in government had tried to mislead parliament.
"The released documents remove any insistence of claims that the
government could have misused, twisted or suppressed information
received from the DDIS," he told reporters.
Investigation
But AP news agency says a Danish intelligence report dated 7
March, 2003, concluded that there was no "certain information
that Iraq has operative weapons of mass destruction".
Spokesman for the opposition Social Democrats Jeppe Kofod said
that in March the prime minister still insisted he "knew" Iraq
had the weapons.
"I don't think we get a complete picture of what the government
knew," he said.
He called for more details following the release of the documents
and for an independent investigation into whether Mr Fogh
Rasmussen deliberately misled MPs.
*****************************************************************
3 BBC: Kim 'in China for secret talks'
Last Updated: Monday, 19 April, 2004
[North Korean spent nuclear fuel rods in Yongbyon]
China has hosted six-nation talks on the continuing nuclear
stand-off
North Korean leader Kim Jong-il is reported to have met Chinese
President Hu Jintao for talks in Beijing.
South Korean media reports said a special train took the
reclusive Mr Kim and his entourage to the Chinese capital for a
summit on Monday.
China is a key mediator in the row over North Korea's nuclear
programme.
Talks have made little progress on how the programme could be
dismantled, or how North Korea's energy and security concerns
would be addressed.
If confirmed, the North Korean leader's four-day visit to
Pyongyang's old communist ally would be his first since May 2001.
No mention of the visit was made on North Korea's official KCNA
news agency or on China's official Xinhua news agency, but it was
reported extensively in the South Korean media.
Witnesses reported seeing a motorcade leaving the train station
in Beijing.
South Korea's Yonhap news agency said talks between Mr Kim and Mr
Hu focused on North Korea's nuclear ambitions and Beijing's
economic assistance to the North.
Mr Kim was also expected to meet other Chinese leaders, including
former President Jiang Zemin and Prime Minister Wen Jiabao,
Yonhap said.
[Kim's armoured train] Mr Kim, who is scared of flying, likes to
travel by special train
Mr Kim's special train crossed into China late on Sunday and
travelled overnight to Beijing, South Korea's YTN cable
television news said. The North Korean leader is scared of
flying.
"At the moment all parties are working together to find a way to
set up a working group to address issues," Chinese Foreign
Minister Li Zhaoxing told a news conference without confirming Mr
Kim's visit.
"China's objective is clear. The legitimate security concerns of
[North Korea] should be properly addressed and the whole
peninsula should be free of nuclear arms," he said.
Mr Kim's two previous known trips to China since 2000 were
confirmed by the two governments only after he returned home.
Talks pressure
Analysts say Pyongyang may be seeking economic and energy aid
from its old communist ally.
But Beijing is under pressure from Washington to step up the pace
of diplomacy over North Korea's nuclear weapons programme.
During his visit to Asia last week, US Vice-President Dick Cheney
told Chinese leaders that time was running out to resolve this
issue.
He reportedly presented Beijing with new evidence regarding North
Korea's nuclear capability.
A North Korean foreign ministry spokesman responded on Sunday by
describing Mr Cheney as "mentally deranged".
He said North Korea was "seriously contemplating a measure" to
counter the US' demand that Pyongyang irreversibly dismantles its
nuclear programme before it will grant the North any concessions.
China's role
China has proved a crucial player in dialogue with Pyongyang,
having hosted two rounds of six-nation talks in Beijing.
In February, China said North Korea had agreed to push towards a
third round of international talks on the region's nuclear
crisis.
The nuclear crisis was sparked in October 2002 when US officials
said North Korea had admitted to having a secret uranium-based
nuclear programme, in violation of a 1994 agreement.
It has since restarted a mothballed nuclear power station, thrown
out United Nations nuclear inspectors and pulled out of the
Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty.
North Korea says it has reprocessed thousands of spent nuclear
fuel rods at the Yongbyon nuclear facility, from which extracted
plutonium can be used to manufacture nuclear bombs.
The US insists that Pyongyang must dismantle its nuclear
facilities. But Pyongyang says it will only do so in return for
economic and energy aid, and security guarantees from Washington.
*****************************************************************
4 Korea: Digital Chosunilbo: Kim Jong-il Must Learn His ¡°Chinese Lesson¡± This Time
Around
Updated Apr.19,2004 23:40 KST
North Korea leader Kim Jong-il is in China, and while everything
about his trip - including his schedule - is shrouded in secrecy,
it can be surmised that its major goals are discussions of the
North Korean nuclear issue and Chinese economic aid.
Not more than a few days ago, U.S. Vice President Dick Cheney was
in China and discussed the North Korean nuclear issue. With
Kim¡¯s visit following close behind, it¡¯s enough to make some
wonder whether we¡¯re on the verge of some turning point in the
discussions between the United States, China and North Korea over
the nuclear issue. One suspects this even more when you see how
China has recently been moving quite actively toward finding a
solution to the nuclear crisis. This is a critical moment in
which our government must pay close attention.
North Korea is in such a situation that it would find it
difficult to survive day to day without Chinese petroleum and
food aid. In this situation, the Chinese leadership¡¯s opinion of
North Korea has grown increasingly negative and critical, and it
seems to have grown even more so recently. In particular, this
fourth-generation of Chinese leaders, led by President Hu Jintao,
has been accelerating China¡¯s market reforms and has attached
considerable importance to the nation¡¯s relationship with the
United States. North Korea, which is tarnishing China¡¯s
international image through the defector issue and causing
confrontation with the U.S. through its nuclear weapons
development, can be nothing but a burden to China.
During this visit, Kim must understand what it is that China¡¯s
leaders and citizens think of North Korea and what it is that
they want of it. From this standpoint, it is quite significant
that this is Kim¡¯s first meeting with President Hu. If this is
simply another incomprehensible example of North Korea¡¯s
internal and foreign strategy, then even this China trip will
have very little chance of success.
Concerning North Korea¡¯s internal economic problems, too, Kim
must listen to China¡¯s advice on reform and deepen its ¡°Chinese
lessons.¡± It has become clear that the North¡¯s ¡°7.1 Economic
Management Reform Measures¡± from two years ago have ended in
almost complete failure. The biggest reason is that those reforms
were emergency measures that totally avoided basic reform
measures like the permission of private farming, and what¡¯s
more, the North was unable to secure outside aid. Rather than
simply being envious of China¡¯s vibrant economic growth and
shallowly trying to imitate it like he did with the ¡°Shinuiju
Special Economic Zone,¡± he must deeply examine the substantive
meanings behind the path of reform China has walked and gather
lessons from that.
*****************************************************************
5 UPI: Analysis: Nuke-for-energy deal for Kim?
United Press International:
By Jong-Heon Lee UPI Correspondent Published 4/19/2004 11:40 AM
SEOUL, South Korea, April 19 (UPI) -- Will North Korean leader
Kim Jong Il bring a breakthrough on the nuclear impasse?
Kim's surprise visit to Bejing this week for a summit with
Chinese President Hu Jintao raised hopes of progress in the
long-stalled nuclear issue.
China is considered one of few nations that have leverage over
Kim's defiant regime, which has been heavily dependent on
Beijing's food and energy aid. Beijing's economic assistance is
vital for the North's tattered economy. China also needs North
Korea to ease the nuclear standoff to boost its leverage in
pressing for a more accommodating U.S. stance toward Taiwan.
"The two nations need each other's help. The Beijing summit was
arranged for mutual benefit," said Moon Heung-ho, a China expert
at Hanyang University in Seoul. "We hope to see progress in the
nuclear stalemate in the North Korea-China summit," Seoul's
Foreign Ministry official said.
Kim held talks with Chinese President Hu on Monday in Beijing
after arriving in the Chinese capital by train earlier in the day
for an informal visit, according to South Korea's media reports
and diplomatic sources in Seoul.
Neither the South Korean nor the Chinese government would
confirm Kim's visit, which was cloaked in secrecy. But both sides
are widely expected to announce his visit after Kim returns to
Pyongyang, as they have done in the past.
When Kim visited China in 2000 and 2001, neither side announced
the visits in advance or commented on the trips until after he
returned home. "North Korea has requested that Kim's schedule be
kept secret due to security concerns," a diplomatic source in
Seoul said.
Kim crossed the border city of Sinuiju into China around 9 p.m.
Sunday after leaving his office in Pyongyang at 1 p.m. that day
by special train. Kim was greeted at the Chinese border city of
Dandong by Wang Jiarui, the Communist Party's director of
international relations, South Korea's official Yonhap News
Agency said in a report from the Chinese capital that quoted
"informed diplomatic sources."
Kim's train, carrying an entourage of some 40 high-level ruling
party, state and military officials, drew into Beijing's main
railway station around 6 a.m. Monday amid tight security.
Beijing's railway station was guarded by military police and a
station official said it was closed for the arrival of a "special
visitor."
A convoy of unmarked cars, including a black Mercedes limousine,
pulled out of the railway station and headed west towards the
state guesthouse, where Kim has stayed on previous trips, said
Yonhap and Seoul's state-run television, KBS.
Kim reportedly met Hu over lunch at Zhongnanhai, the leadership
compound in Beijing. It was the first summit between the two
communist allies since the new Chinese leaders took office last
year.
No details of the summit were available, but media reports
quoted sources as saying it was focused on how to end the
standoff over Pyongyang's nuclear arms ambitions, Beijing's food
and energy assistance, and North Korea's economic reforms.
At the summit, Kim said his country was ready to give up its
nuclear development program if the United States dropped its
hostile policy towards Pyongyang. He also asked for economic and
energy aid from China.
In return, Hu reportedly called for Pyongyang to move to ease
the nuclear crisis, saying U.S. Vice President Dick Cheney on a
visit to Beijing last week warned that time was running out for a
resolution on the issue.
Analysts in Seoul said Beijing wanted to hear Kim's position on
North Korea's nuclear program and use the summit to make progress
toward six-party talks to end the nuclear crisis. "China invited
the North Korean leader to visit Beijing to offer economic aid
and persuade Pyongyang to make concessions to break the nuclear
impasse," said Paek Seung-joo, an analyst at the Korea Institute
for Defense Analysis in Seoul.
China has been mediating between North Korea and the United
States at the six-way talks, which also involve South Korea,
Japan and Russia, aimed at seeking a peaceful resolution to the
crisis. China hosted two rounds of six-party talks, the latest
one in February, but no agreement has been reached.
"North Korea is not in a position to dismiss Chinese pressure,"
said Lee Tae-hwan, a China specialist at the Sejong Institute, a
private think tank in Seoul, "because China provides between 70
percent and 90 percent of North Korea's oil and more than
one-third of its imports and food aid."
"Beijing wants to use its role in defusing the nuclear crisis as
leverage in dealing with Washington over the Taiwan issue," a
Western diplomat said, requesting anonymity. "With the North
Korea card in hand, China would call for the United States to
discourage Taiwan from adopting a confrontational stance with the
mainland following Chen Shui-bian's re-election as the island's
president.
Kim Jong Il's China trip came after Cheney came to China last
week armed with fresh evidence of North Korea's nuclear weapons
capabilities and pressing Beijing to take a tougher line with its
communist neighbor.
After the summit, Kim visited Zhongguancun technology park,
China's leading high-tech development zone. He is scheduled to
have a series of meetings with Chinese leaders, including former
President Jiang Zemin, Prime Minister Wen Jiabao, parliamentary
leader Wu Bangguo and Vice President Zeng Qinghong.
On his way back to North Korea on Wednesday, he is expected to
visit Shenyang or Dalian in China's northeast to study government
efforts to boost the economy with outside investment.
Copyright © 2001-2004 United Press International
*****************************************************************
6 VANUNU -- EVEN CONTACT WITH PARENTS WILL BE FORBIDDEN
Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2004 07:45:06 -0500 (CDT)
What kind of vindictive retribution is this ?
What kind of example do the terms of Vanunu's release set for what is
claimed to be a democratic State?
Why bother with allowing him to appeal the conditions of his release ?
Wouldn't Israel's purpose be better served by assasination ? Perhaps a few
other perpetual dissident rabble-rousers can be simultaneously offed !!
Michael
======================
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/ArticleNews/TPStory/LAC/20040419/VANUNU19/TPInternational/Africa
Israeli who spilled nuclear secrets to be kept on tight leash after
release
EVEN CONTACT WITH PARENTS IS FORBIDDEN
Glove and Mail (Toronto) Monday, April 19, 2004
By DOUG SAUNDERS
When Mordechai Vanunu ends his 18 years of mostly solitary confinement
Wednesday morning, he will likely be greeted with complete silence from
all four of his parents.
Mr. Vanunu, 50, became an international cause clbre in 1986, when he was
kidnapped by Israel's Mossad intelligence agency and imprisoned for
treason after telling the world about Israel's secret nuclear-weapons
program. Israeli officials believe Mr. Vanunu is one of the most dangerous
men in the country, and have ordered him not to leave his town in Israel,
to speak to foreigners, to use a cellphone or the Internet, or to come
within 100 metres of any embassy or border.
Those restrictions, which are indefinite in duration, are being appealed
in Israeli court this morning. But even if they are overturned, Mr. Vanunu
will step out of prison into an awkward political environment and a truly
bizarre family situation.
Standing outside the Jerusalem prison upon his release will be Nick and
Mary Eoloff of St. Paul, Minn., who adopted him as their son in 1997. But
the Eoloffs will have to remain silent and remote, because they are
forbidden to contact him by any means.
Mr. Vanunu's biological parents will also be silent. Patriotic Israelis,
they were against their son's decision to expose Israel's secret nuclear
labs, and even more offended when he converted to Christianity.
The Eoloffs, lifelong anti-nuclear protesters who want to bring Mr. Vanunu
to their home in Minnesota, visited him in prison yesterday and said he is
angry and depressed by the situation.
"More than anything, I think he believes he has a right to the life of a
normal citizen -- he wants just a quiet normal life, and he wants to live
in the United States," Mrs. Eoloff said in a telephone interview from
Jerusalem last night. "They took 18 years of his life, and I don't think
they have the right to take any more."
That sympathy is not widely shared in Israel. "The majority of people here
still see him as a traitor," Mrs. Eoloff said. " . . . His life is in
certain danger here."
Yesterday, when they announced the restrictions on Mr. Vanunu, Israeli
officials said they were worried he will try to provide more secret
information to the news media, or draw further attention to Israel's
nuclear program, which the country does not officially admit to having.
"The main consideration should be his intent to go on causing damage to
Israel," said Shabtai Shavit, a former Mossad chief who helped draft the
unusual set of restrictions. "Who will guarantee that he will only speak
the truth? Who is to stop him imagining things?" Mr. Shavit told the
Reuters news agency.
Mr. Vanunu's sudden re-emergence could prove awkward at a moment when
Israel has just won full co-operation from the United States in its war
against Palestinian militants and its ban on the return of Palestinian
refugees to Israel. The United States cannot legally provide aid to
countries that produce weapons of mass destruction; Israel has managed to
get around this restriction using a don't-ask-don't-tell policy that
became much more difficult after Mr. Vanunu released photos of desert
atomic-bomb labs to The Times of London.
Indeed, Mr. Vanunu, who worked from 1976 to 1985 at the Dimona
nuclear-power facility while it was secretly producing more than 200
nuclear warheads, has pledged to continue speaking out against the
weapons. His outspokenness led him to spend most of his sentence in
solitary confinement, which ended in 1998. Due to be released a year ago,
he spent another year in prison because he refused to agree not to talk
about nuclear weapons.
"He's very willing to join the opposition to nuclear development once he's
living in the United States," Mrs. Eoloff said.
The Eoloffs adopted the dissident after spending years organizing petition
campaigns to have him released. They believed adoption would give him U.S.
citizenship, but learned a year later that the United States does not
grant citizenship to adopted children over age 16. Mrs. Eoloff said
yesterday she hopes Mr. Vanunu will be granted political asylum in the
United States.
Mr. Vanunu's brother Meir said the dissident remains angry and depressed,
but that he does not have any information beyond what he revealed to The
Times.
"Mordechai is not crazy, but he is very angry and sometimes suffers from
notions that there is a vast Israeli conspiracy against him, all around,"
his brother said on Friday.
Some senior Israelis expressed fear that restrictions on Mr. Vanunu might
backfire. "I think it is a mistake to gag him," said David Kimche, a
former director-general of the Israeli Foreign Ministry. "It only bolsters
Vanunu's supposed credibility and, in turn, pretty much anything he may
choose to concoct about Israel."
=========================
INTERNATIONAL NEWS ARTICLE
http://www.reuters.com/newsArticle.jhtml?type=worldNews&storyID=4863226
Swiss Radio International. April 19, 2004 1:45 PM
By Allyn Fisher-Ilan JERUSALEM (Reuters)
Nuke whistleblower wants Israel's reactor destroyed
- Mordechai Vanunu, about to complete an 18-year jail term for spilling
Israeli nuclear secrets, has called for the destruction of Israel's
secretive Dimona reactor, newspapers have reported.
"Just like the Iraqi reactor was destroyed, I want the Israeli reactor
destroyed," Vanunu, referring to Israel's 1981 bombing near Baghdad, was
quoted as saying in a videotaped meeting recently with security officers.
"I am defending the Arab world," he said in the interview, according to a
transcript carried by newspapers on Monday. The tape was to be broadcast
later in the day.
Vanunu, a former technician at the Dimona reactor, was jailed in 1986 as a
traitor after disclosing information to Britain's Sunday Times which led
analysts to conclude Israel had produced as many as 200 nuclear bombs at
the facility.
Israel maintains a strategic ambiguity over its nuclear programme in an
attempt to ward off its foes while avoiding a regional arms race. It has
kept the Dimona facility, in southern Israel, closed to international
inspection.
Vanunu, 49, is expected to be placed under restrictions as soon as he is
released on Wednesday, the government having decided to bar him from
leaving the country, tap his phone and bar his access to the press for a
probationary period.
Release of the videotape appeared aimed at bolstering the government's
case in a court challenge Israel's civil liberties union is mounting on
Vanunu's behalf against the edicts.
Challenging Israel's right to exist, he declared: "There is no need for a
Jewish state. There should be a Palestinian state. Whoever wants to be
Jewish can live anywhere."
Vanunu said he hoped to fight the restrictions and move overseas. He
denied having anything sensitive left to divulge and threatened to defy
some restrictions using the Internet.
"I've been inside for 20 years, everything has changed. Science has
advanced...so what I saw seems very outdated to me," Vanunu said.
Vanunu also maintained he was neither a spy nor a traitor.
"I wanted to inform the world about what happened. It's not treason," --
outside Israel "five or six billion people (see me)...as a positive
figure."
Asked why he had chosen to convert to Christianity back in the 1980s,
Vanunu replied: "I think Islam and Judaism are both the same backward
religion...Christianity is progressive."
===============
*****************************************************************
7 Vanunu Prison Video Broadcast Irks Supporters
Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2004 14:27:39 -0700
PRESS RELEASE
April 19, 2004 For immediate release
Contact: Rayna Moss, +972 051 368 236
Israeli Free Vanunu Campaign
For more information, see www.vanunu.co.uk, www.vanunu.com, www.vanunu.org
Vanunu Prison Video Broadcast Irks Supporters
The International Delegation currently in Israel to welcome Mordechai
Vanunu after his release is appalled by the news that an interview
videotaped last month with Vanunu at Ashkelon Prison will be broadcast on
Israeli television this evening. Without his knowledge or consent, this is
the first public media communication to Israel and the world from a man who
has been silenced for the past 18 years, the first 11 _ of which were in
solitary confinement.
At a visit this afternoon with Mordechai Vanunu, American adoptive parents
Nick and Mary Eoloff said he told them he did not give his permission for
the tape to be used for broadcast, and was not told that was the
intent. He was told it was a routine procedure for prisoners nearing release.
The International Campaign to Free Vanunu continues to stand with Mordechai
Vanunu in condemnation of nuclear weapons and all weapons of mass
destruction in the Middle East and around the world. We continue to look
for a free and open debate on the more than 200 Israeli thermonuclear
weapons his revelations exposed 18 years ago.
An international delegation, comprised of over 80 individuals from a dozen
countries, will join together with Israelis at Ashkelon Prison when
Mordechai Vanunu walks out of the prison gate on April 21, 2004.
The delegation will begin a vigil at Ashkelon Prison in anticipation of
Vanunu's release at 1 p.m. on Tuesday, April 20, and will be joined by
others at 3 p.m. A press conference will be held across the street from
the prison at 5 p.m. The delegates who will be speaking at the press
conference are marked below with an asterisk. (*) In addition, Gideon
Spiro of the Israeli Committee for Mordechai Vanunu and for a Middle East
Free of Atomic, Biological and Chemical Weapons and Issam Makhoul, Member
of Knesset will speak.
Restrictions to be faced by Mordechai Vanunu on release:
Mordechai Vanunu will face many restrictions on his release from Ashkelon
Prison, so many that his new freedom will be seriously compromised.
" It is absolutely disgraceful that these restrictions are being imposed on
a man who has finished his 18 year sentence, has no charges to face, and
has suffered so much already" said Rayna Moss of the Israeli Free Vanunu
Campaign.
These draconian restrictions have been imposed under the emergency
regulations passed by the British mandate of 1945.
1. Vanunu will have to register to live in an Israeli city of his choice.
2. He will have to give notice to the authorities if he wishes to travel to
another city.
3. He will not be allowed to leave Israel for 6 months. This restriction
will be reviewed at the end of 6 months and could be renewed.
4. He will not be allowed to contact foreigners either by phone or in person.
5. It is unclear whether his American adoptive parents, who have been
allowed to visit him while in custody, will be allowed to speak to him when
free.
6. He will not be allowed to go within 100 meters of any embassy, visit any
port of entry, come within 300 meters of any international boundary and he
may not be allowed to worship in a church of his choice.
International Noteworthy Delegates
Nick and Mary Eoloff: Mordechai Vanunu's adoptive parents since 1997, from
St. Paul, Minnesota, USA
* Mairaed Maguire: Irish Nobel Peace Prize Laureate in 1976 for her work
towards building peace in Northern Ireland and founder member of the Peace
People. Present in Israel with a delegation from Belfast and Dublin.
Reverend Ed Browning: Retired Bishop Episcopal Church,
USA
Felice Cohen-Joppa: Coordinator, U.S. Campaign to Free Mordechai Vanunu.
Tucson, Arizona, USA
* Jeremy Corbyn: Labour Party Member of Parliament. Vice chair of House of
Commons Human Rights Committee. Active in supporting many civil liberty and
international peace causes. Longtime supporter of the Campaign to Free
Vanunu. G.B.
Bruce Kent: Past chairman of the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament, present
vice chairman. Member of the International Peace Bureau, tireless peace
campaigner. Trustee of Campaign to Free Vanunu. G.B.
* Susannah York: International actor, well known from Hollywood films,
theatre, radio and T.V., supporter of human rights causes and Trustee of
Campaign to Free Vanunu. G.B.
Art Laffin: Associate coordinator, U.S. Campaign to Free Mordechai Vanunu,
Washington, D.C., USA. Member of the Catholic Worker Movement.
Barry Roth: Psychiatrist, peace and anti-nuclear activist, Boston,
Massachusetts, USA
* Colin Breed : Liberal Democrat Member of Parliament. Active supporter of
peace campaigns and long time supporter of Mordechai Vanunu in the House of
Commons. G.B.
Ben Birnberg: Internationally known Civil Liberties and Human Rights
Lawyer. Trustee of Campaign to Free Vanunu. G.B.
Ernest Rodker: Coordinator, British Campaign to Free Vanunu
Fredrik S. Heffermehl: lawyer, writer, translator and political organizer,
Honorary President of the Norwegian Peace Alliance, Vice President of
the International Peace Bureau, Vice President of the International
Association of Lawyers against Nuclear Arms, and other organizations, Norway
Pat Arrowsmith: Active in Campaign Against Nuclear Weapons since 1950's.
One of the organizers of the first Aldermaston march and involved in many
demonstrations against military bases involving arrest and imprisonment.
Active in the Campaign to Free Vanunu. G.B.
Ole Kopreitan: executive director, Nei til atomvaapen (No to Nuclear Arms),
longtime Vanunu campaigner, Norway.
-end-
*****************************************************************
8 Amnesty Int'l - Vanunu must be free
Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2004 17:45:12 -0700
NEWS RELEASE
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
April 19, 2004
Contact:
Jack Cohen-Joppa, U.S. Campaign to Free Mordechai Vanunu
voice: 520-323-8697 e-mail: freevanunu@mindspring.com
Amnesty International's press office, London
Voice: +44 20 7413 5566
AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL JOINS CALL FOR MORDECHAI VANUNU'S UNCONDITIONAL RELEASE
Amnesty International today joined the global call for the
unconditional release of Israeli nuclear whistleblower Mordechai
Vanunu. In a statement from their London office, the international human
rights organization said it "urges the Israeli authorities not to impose
any restrictions or conditions on former nuclear technician Mordechai
Vanunu upon his release on Wednesday after 18 years in jail."
"Mordechai Vanunu should be allowed to exercise his rights to
freedom of movement, association and expression in Israel and should be
allowed to leave the country if he wishes," said Amnesty International.
"His release is long overdue and Israel must not continue to violate his
fundamental human rights once he is released from prison."
Their statement continues:
"...In recent months Israeli officials have publicly supported and
called for Vanunu to be detained beyond expiry of his sentence, or for his
freedom to be restricted upon his release. Available information indicates
that the Israeli authorities intend to impose heavy restrictions on
Vanunu's freedom upon his release, including banning him from leaving the
country, confining him to assigned residence, and denying him the right to
be in contact with journalists and foreigners.
"Israel is bound by international law not to impose arbitrary
restrictions on Mordechai Vanunu, including on his right to travel within
the country or abroad, his right to peaceful association with others and
his right to express his opinions," said Amnesty International.
Background
Article 12 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
(ICCPR), which Israel has ratified and is obliged to uphold, stipulates that:
"everyone lawfully within the territory of a State shall, within that
territory, have the right to liberty of movement and freedom to choose his
residence" and that "everyone shall be free to leave any country, including
his own".
The rights to freedom of expression and association are guaranteed by
Articles 19 and 21 of the same Covenant.
-end-
Felice Cohen-Joppa
Coordinator
U.S. Campaign to Free Mordechai Vanunu
POB 43384
Tucson, AZ 85733
Phone/Fax 520-323-8697
freevanunu@mindspring.com
www.nonviolence.org/vanunu
*****************************************************************
9 [southnews] Vanunu ordered to stay in Israel
Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2004 18:31:42 -0500 (CDT)
------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor ---------------------~-->
Buy Ink Cartridges or Refill Kits for your HP, Epson, Canon or Lexmark
Printer at MyInks.com. Free s/h on orders $50 or more to the US & Canada.
http://www.c1tracking.com/l.asp?cid=5511
http://us.click.yahoo.com/mOAaAA/3exGAA/qnsNAA/7gSolB/TM
---------------------------------------------------------------------~->
The Israeli Government has banned nuclear whistleblower Mordechai Vanunu
from leaving the country for a year.
Mr Vanunu is due to be released from prison tomorrow after serving 18
years for revealing details about Israel's secret nuclear program.
Much of Mr Vanunu's sentence has been served in solitary confinement and
the convicted traitor has told friends he wants to leave Israel when he
is freed from jail.
But Israel's Interior Minister Avraham Poraz has signed an injunction
banning the nuclear whistleblower from leaving the country for one year.
The government fears that if Mr Vanunu moved overseas he could reveal
more secrets about Israel's nuclear program.
Israel refuses to confirm or deny that it even has atomic weaponsbut
foreign analysts believe the country could have more than 150 nuclear
warheads.
_____________________________
I'm not a traitor, says Israeli nuclear whistleblower on eve of release
Mon Apr 19, 3:50 PM ET
JERUSALEM (AFP) - Mordechai Vanunu, who is to be freed Wednesday after
18 years in prison for blowing the whistle on Israel's nuclear
programme, remains unrepentant and does not regard himself as a traitor,
according to new footage.
"I am neither a traitor nor a spy. I only wanted the world to know what
was happening" at the Dimona nuclear plant in southern Israel, Vanunu
said during an interrogation by security service agents which was
broadcast on Israeli television Monday night.
Vanunu said that he had been motivated by a desire "to destroy the
reactor", saying that he had acted "for the (good of the) world".
"Why did the world perceive me as a hero or appreciate what I did --
except for Israel?" he asked during the broadcast interrogation which
was the first opportunity ordinary Israelis had had to see him
throughout his long captivity.
"Just like they destroyed the Iraqi reactor, I want them to destroy the
Israeli reactor," he said in reference to Iraq (news - web sites)'s
Osirak nuclear plant which was the target of a 1981 Israeli air raid.
Vanunu, a former technician at Dimona, was sentenced in 1986 after
leaking details of Israel's secret nuclear arsenal to Britain's Sunday
Times newspaper. He spent 11 years of his incarceration in solitary
confinement.
Israeli agents lured Vanunu from London to Italy where he was kidnapped
and brought to Israel. He was tried in secret and found guilty of espionage.
He will be subjected to a series of unprecedented restrictions after his
release, including a ban on leaving the country.
Interior Minister Avraham Poraz ruled the travel ban was essential to
prevent him from "damaging state security", his ministry said in a
statement.
But proposals to bar Vanunu from speaking to foreigners, including his
American-born adoptive parents, or approaching any foreign embassy were
dropped by Poraz, public television reported.
Vanunu's lawyers had appealed to the Israeli government to abandon the
restrictions in their entirety.
The senior attorney for the Association for Human Rights in Israel
(ACRI), Oded Feller, "submitted its reservations yesterday regarding the
severe restrictions that state agencies are seeking to impose on Vanunu
after his release", ACRI said in a statement.
Feller said in the appeal to the interior minister and the head of the
Home Front Command, Major General Yaior Naveh, "that the prohibitions
and restrictions ... are unreasonable, and constitute a severe and
unjustified infringement of the freedom of the released prisoner."
Amnesty International also urged the Israeli government Monday not to
impose any restrictions or conditions on Vanunu.
"His release is long overdue and Israel must not continue to violate his
fundamental human rights once he is released from prison," it said.
Vanunu himself denied that he remained any threat to national security
and said he had no more nuclear secrets to reveal.
"First of all, I've been on the inside for 20 years -- everything has
changed already," he told his interrogators.
"Second, what I went through is a process the entire world knows about
.. it's clear that everything has been published. Science has progressed.
"Technology has taken giant steps forward, so what I saw appears to me
to be very old. I don't think the Americans are interested, or the
Europeans."
Israel has firmly adhered to a policy of "nuclear ambiguity", never
confirming or denying it possesses nuclear weapons. But foreign experts
believe the Jewish state holds at least 200 atomic warheads.
Vanunu's brother Meir said it was "scandalous" that the security
services had allowed the tape of the interrogation to be broadcast.
"This reminds one of the methods of a totalitarian country," he told AFP.
Despite the ban on talking to foreigners, many international supporters
of Vanunu are expected to attend his release on Wednesday from Shikma
prison in the southern port city of Ashkelon.
Israel keeps nuclear smokescreen
From correspondents in Jerusalem
Agence France-Presse April 18, 2004
FOR the past 40 years, Israel has sought to maintain a veil of secrecy
over its nuclear capacity even if Mordechai Vanunu's revelations erased
any shred of doubt about its possession of an atomic arsenal.
Ever since the 1965 inauguration of the Dimona plant in the southern
Negev desert, the one-time workplace of the whistleblower Vanunu, Israel
has consistently refused to deny or confirm that it possesses nuclear arms.
But even before Vanunu, who is to be released on Wednesday after 18
years in prison, leaked details of the program to Britain's Sunday Times
newspaper in 1986, the official policy of ambiguity had left few people
fooled.
Israel currently has two nuclear facilities, the reactor at Dimona in
the Negev desert built with French aid and capable of producing
weapons-grade plutonium and a smaller research reactor at Nahal Sorek,
south of Tel Aviv.
Under an understanding with the United States dating back to 1969,
Israel has committed itself to abstain from any comment on its nuclear
potential and not to carry out nuclear tests.
In return, the United States does not pressure Israel to adhere to the
nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), which would oblige the Jewish
state to submit its nuclear facilities to international supervision by
the UN's atomic watchdog, the International Atomic Energy Agency.
The agency's Director General Mohamed ElBaradei recently urged Israel to
give up its nuclear arsenal, claiming it spurred a regional arms race.
I am not happy with the status quo, because I see a lot of frustration
in the Middle East due to Israel's sitting on nuclear weapons or nuclear
weapons capability, while others in the Middle East are committed to the
NPT, he told the Israeli daily Haaretz.
As an extra precaution, the whole program is also covered by military
censorship, which the Israeli media regularly bypasses by quoting
foreign publications.
According to these foreign experts, Israel has used its reactor at
Dimona to produce around 200 nuclear warheads.
Peter Hounam, the journalist who first broke the Vanunu story for the
Sunday Times, criticised Israel's gall for still failing to come clean
about its capabilities but said it was determined not to upset its
allies in Washington.
But its decision to try to gag Vanunu at all costs even after his
release was likely to backfire and serve to increase demands for
clarity, he added.
I think that the international reaction to the way he is being treated
will add to the impetus for the UN being given access to the Dimona
plant, he told AFP.
Everything about this stinks of hypocrisy, he added.
No Israeli leader has ever broken the long-standing taboo by
unequivocally recognising the existence of a nuclear arsenal, but
allusions have become less and less oblique.
The former premier Shimon Peres, considered the father of Israel's
nuclear program after reaching agreement with France back in 1956 for
the provision of a nuclear reactor and uranium, effectively confirmed
its existence in an interview with French television in 2001.
The suspicion and the fog which surround this project are constructive,
for it increases our power of deterrence, said Peres in a documentary
on Dimona.
Peres, who was director at Israel's defence ministry in the 1950s, has
no sympathy for Vanunu's decision to turn the spotlight on the nuclear
issue.
The archives of South News can be found at
http://southmovement.alphalink.com.au/southnews/
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/southnews/
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
southnews-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
*****************************************************************
10 Vanunu restrictions eased a little
Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2004 19:57:37 -0500 (CDT)
http://www.haaretzdaily.com/hasen/spages/417201.html
Ha'aretz (Israel ) Monday
By Yossi Melman and Relly Sa'ar, Haaretz Correspondents
Limits on Vanunu eased slightly ahead of release [0.gif]
The defense establishment on Monday decided to ease some of the
restrictions on nuclear whistleblower Mordechai Vanunu, who goes free on
Wednesday after serving an 18-year sentence.
The move came after defense officials realized that some of the
restrictions were legally untenable. Thus, the ban on discussing his
abduction was lifted. The ban on going near embassies was also altered;
Vanunu was told that he could go near them, but not enter them.
Interior Minister Avraham Poraz signed an injunction on Monday prohibiting
Vanunu from leaving Israel for one year. Other restrictions imposed on him
by the defense establishment will remain in effect for six months. Defense
sources said the main reason for preventing Vanunu from leaving the
country and not issuing him a passport was that he still knows state
secrets that may jeopardize state security.
The Association for Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI), which represents
Vanunu, intends to petition the High Court of Justice against the
restrictions, after Vanunu's request to revoke them were rejected.
Vanunu, who was convicted for revealing details of Israel's previously
covert nuclearfacility in Dimona to Britain's Sunday Times newspaper in
October 1986, will take up residence in Jaffa's luxurious Andromeda Hill
apartment complex, security sources said Monday.
While some restrictions were eased, Vanunu was warned not to give
interviews to the media about his work and to report to the police if
anyone approaches him for this purpose.
Vanunu may not give anyone any classified information obtained while he
was working in the Dimona nuclear facility or discuss issues related to
his former workplace, even if he has released that information before (to
the Sunday Times).
Vanunu must notify the authorities of his address in the Dan region and
advise the police 24 hours in advance if he wants to sleep at another
address. He must not be within 500 meters of border crossings, or partake
in Internet chats unless permitted.
Officials from the Shin Bet security service and the Defense Ministry's
internal security department on Monday gave Vanunu official papers
outlining the restrictions he faces.
Legal sources said the restrictions were intended to test Vanunu's
conduct. If he violates them, they said, the defense establishment will
retaliate with severe sanctions.
*****************************************************************
11 AFP: I'm not a traitor, says Israeli nuclear whistleblower on eve of release
+ [http://www.spacewar.com/]
JERUSALEM (AFP) Apr 19, 2004
Mordechai Vanunu, who is to be freed Wednesday after 18 years in
prison for blowing the whistle on Israel's nuclear programme,
remains unrepentant and does not regard himself as a traitor,
according to new footage.
"I am neither a traitor nor a spy. I only wanted the world to
know what was happening" at the Dimona nuclear plant in southern
Israel, Vanunu said during an interrogation by security service
agents which was broadcast on Israeli television Monday night.
Vanunu said that he had been motivated by a desire "to destroy
the reactor", saying that he had acted "for the (good of the)
world".
"Why did the world perceive me as a hero or appreciate what I did
-- except for Israel?" he asked during the broadcast
interrogation which was the first opportunity ordinary Israelis
had had to see him throughout his long capitivity.
"Just like they destroyed the Iraqi reactor, I want them to
destroy the Israeli reactor," he said in reference to Iraq's
Osirak nuclear plant which was the target of a 1981 Israeli air
raid.
Vanunu, a former technician at Dimona, was sentenced in 1986
after leaking details of Israel's secret nuclear arsenal to
Britain's Sunday Times newspaper. He spent 11 years of his
incarceration in solitary confinement.
Israeli agents lured Vanunu from London to Italy where he was
kidnapped and brought to Israel. He was tried in secret and found
guilty of espionage.
He will be subjected to a series of unprecedented restrictions
after his release, including a ban on leaving the country.
Interior Minister Avraham Poraz ruled the travel ban was
essential to prevent him from "damaging state security", his
ministry said in a statement.
But proposals to bar Vanunu from speaking to foreigners,
including his American-born adoptive parents, or approaching any
foreign embassy were dropped by Poraz, public television
reported.
Vanunu's lawyers had appealed to the Israeli government to
abandon the restrictions in their entirety.
The senior attorney for the Association for Human Rights in
Israel (ACRI), Oded Feller, "submitted its reservations yesterday
regarding the severe restrictions that state agencies are seeking
to impose on Vanunu after his release", ACRI said in a statement.
Feller said in the appeal to the interior minister and the head
of the Home Front Command, Major General Yaior Naveh, "that the
prohibitions and restrictions ... are unreasonable, and
constitute a severe and unjustified infringement of the freedom
of the released prisoner."
Amnesty International also urged the Israeli government Monday
not to impose any restrictions or conditions on Vanunu.
"His release is long overdue and Israel must not continue to
violate his fundamental human rights once he is released from
prison," it said.
Vanunu himself denied that he remained any threat to national
security and said he had no more nuclear secrets to reveal.
"First of all, I've been on the inside for 20 years -- everything
has changed already," he told his interrogators.
"Second, what I went through is a process the entire world knows
about ... it's clear that everything has been published. Science
has progressed.
"Technology has taken giant steps forward, so what I saw appears
to me to be very old. I don't think the Americans are interested,
or the Europeans."
Israel has firmly adhered to a policy of "nuclear ambiguity",
never confirming or denying it possesses nuclear weapons. But
foreign experts believe the Jewish state holds at least 200
atomic warheads.
Vanunu's brother Meir said it was "scandalous" that the security
services had allowed the tape of the interrogation to be
broadcast.
"This reminds one of the methods of a totalitarian country," he
told AFP.
Despite the ban on talking to foreigners, many international
supporters of Vanunu are expected to attend his release on
Wednesday from Shikma prison in the southern port city of
Ashkelon.
WAR.WIRE
*****************************************************************
12 Reuters: Nuke Whistleblower Wants Israel's Reactor Destroyed
Mon Apr 19, 2004 06:35 AM ET
By Allyn Fisher-Ilan
JERUSALEM (Reuters) - Mordechai Vanunu, about to complete an
18-year jail term for spilling Israeli nuclear secrets, has
called for the destruction of Israel's secretive Dimona reactor,
newspapers reported on Monday.
"Just like the Iraqi reactor was destroyed, I want the Israeli
reactor destroyed," Vanunu, referring to Israel's 1981 bombing
near Baghdad, was quoted as saying in a videotaped meeting
recently with security officers.
"I am defending the Arab world," he said in the interview,
according to a transcript carried by newspapers. The tape was to
be broadcast later in the day.
Vanunu, a former technician at the Dimona reactor, was jailed in
1986 as a traitor after disclosing information to Britain's
Sunday Times newspaper which led analysts to conclude Israel had
produced as many as 200 nuclear bombs at the facility.
Israel maintains a strategic ambiguity over its nuclear program
in an attempt to ward off its foes while avoiding a regional
arms race. It has kept the Dimona facility, in southern Israel,
closed to international inspection. Vanunu, 49, is expected to
be placed under restrictions as soon as he is released on
Wednesday, the government having decided to bar him from leaving
the country, tap his phone and bar his access to the press for a
probationary period.
Release of the videotape appeared aimed at bolstering the
government's case in a court challenge Israel's civil liberties
union is mounting on Vanunu's behalf against the edicts.
Challenging Israel's right to exist, he declared: "There is no
need for a Jewish state. There should be a Palestinian state.
Whoever wants to be Jewish can live anywhere."
Vanunu said he hoped to fight the restrictions and move
overseas. He denied having anything sensitive left to divulge
and threatened to defy some restrictions using the Internet.
"I've been inside for 20 years, everything has changed. Science
has advanced...so what I saw seems very outdated to me," Vanunu
said.
Vanunu also maintained he was neither a spy nor a traitor.
"I wanted to inform the world about what happened. It's not
treason," and outside Israel "five or six billion people (see
me)...as a positive figure."
Asked why he had chosen to convert to Christianity back in the
1980s, Vanunu replied: "I think Islam and Judaism are both the
same backward religion...Christianity is progressive."
*****************************************************************
13 Haaretz: Limits on Vanunu eased slightly ahead of release
[http://www.haaretz.com]
Last Update: 20/04/2004 04:17
By Yossi Melman [ymelman@haaretz.co.il] and Relly Sa'ar
[rellys@haaretz.co.il] , Haaretz Correspondents
The defense establishment on Monday decided to ease some of the
restrictions on nuclear whistleblower Mordechai Vanunu, who goes
free on Wednesday after serving an 18-year sentence.
The move came after defense officials realized that some of the
restrictions were legally untenable. Thus, the ban on discussing
his abduction was lifted. The ban on going near embassies was
also altered; Vanunu was told that he could go near them, but not
enter them.
Interior Minister Avraham Poraz signed an injunction on Monday
prohibiting Vanunu from leaving Israel for one year. Other
restrictions imposed on him by the defense establishment will
remain in effect for six months. Defense sources said the main
reason for preventing Vanunu from leaving the country and not
issuing him a passport was that he still knows state secrets that
may jeopardize state security.
The Association for Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI), which
represents Vanunu, intends to petition the High Court of Justice
against the restrictions, after Vanunu's request to revoke them
were rejected.
Vanunu, who was convicted for revealing details of Israel's
previously covert nuclearfacility in Dimona to Britain's Sunday
Times newspaper in October 1986, will take up residence in
Jaffa's luxurious Andromeda Hill apartment complex, security
sources said Monday.
While some restrictions were eased, Vanunu was warned not to give
interviews to the media about his work and to report to the
police if anyone approaches him for this purpose.
Vanunu may not give anyone any classified information obtained
while he was working in the Dimona nuclear facility or discuss
issues related to his former workplace, even if he has released
that information before (to the Sunday Times).
Vanunu must notify the authorities of his address in the Dan
region and advise the police 24 hours in advance if he wants to
sleep at another address. He must not be within 500 meters of
border crossings, or partake in Internet chats unless permitted.
Officials from the Shin Bet security service and the Defense
Ministry's internal security department on Monday gave Vanunu
official papers outlining the restrictions he faces.
Legal sources said the restrictions were intended to test
Vanunu's conduct. If he violates them, they said, the defense
establishment will retaliate with severe sanctions.
Mordechai Vanunu is set to be released on Wednesday, after 18
years in jail. (Archives)
Home [http://www.haaretz.com] | News
© Copyright Haaretz. All rights reserved
*****************************************************************
14 Haaretz: Ignore Vanunu; don't restrict him
[http://www.haaretz.com]
By [rpedatzur@haaretz.co.il]
Who is so afraid of Mordechai Vanunu? For 20 years he has had no
connection with new information regarding Israel's nuclear
program and the Dimona reactor, where he worked as a junior
technician and from where he was fired in 1985. He has already
passed on all the information he had to the Sunday Times, which
published it in October 1986. Why, then, have so many of the
powers that be from the defense establishment banded together
with such decisiveness to restrict his freedom upon his release
tomorrow, after 18 years of incarceration?
Why does Yehiel Horev, chief or internal security (malmab) at the
Defense Ministry, want to keep him under administrative detention
and define him as a serious security risk? The answer appears to
have nothing to do with the supposedly dangerous nuclear secrets
Vanunu still has stored in his brain. Apparently, the defense
establishment, and particularly the Shin Bet security service and
the Defense Ministry's internal security department, simply wants
to avoid embarrassment and criticism if Vanunu tells how he made
a laughing stock of the system that was in charge of protecting
secrets at the Dimona reactor.
To this day, there has been no serious probe into the failures of
the Shin Bet and the internal security department, which share
the responsibility for securing the reactor in Dimona. The joint
internal examination committee of both bodies, which was
established after the disclosure of the Vanunu affair, included
Horev, the current chief of security and the individual appointed
by the defense establishment to oversee security at the reactor
during part of the period when Vanunu worked there. The
committee's work was a whitewash. No one was found directly
responsible for the failure and no one was held accountable for
the fact that the information on Vanunu's political activities at
Be'er Sheva University - his relationships with Arab students and
his remarks against Israel's nuclear policy - never set off a
warning bell among those responsible for the security of the most
secret facility in Israel.
Since all this concerns nuclear matters, the discussion of which
is taboo, there was also no demand for and accounting from those
responsible for the serious failure. Everything could change if
Vanunu talks. This may also be the reason for the fact that he
was kept in solitary confinement for more than 11 years. Beyond
the desire to take revenge on someone who embarrassed the system,
there was apparently also the hope that he would lose his mind,
and would therefore be unable to tell how he managed to deceive
the security system.
The series of restrictions to be imposed on the "nuclear
prisoner" would not put even Stalin's Soviet Union to shame.
Vanunu will not be issued a passport and he will be forbidden to
leave Israel. He will have to live in a certain city, of his own
choosing, but will not be allowed to leave that city's
jurisdiction without prior coordination with the local police
station. He will not be allowed to approach any Israeli border
crossing, including Ben-Gurion International Airport, the sea
ports, crossings into the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank
and Gaza, the crossings between the PA and Jordan and Egypt, the
direct crossings between Israel and Jordan or Egypt, nor any
marina at which there is a police checkpoint. And will also not
be allowed any contact - face-to-face, by telephone, fax or
e-mail - with foreign residents, even those living in Israel.
Immediately after his exit from prison, Vanunu will also have to
learn the addresses of all the foreign embassies in Israel -
because he is not allowed to go near them either; and if he
doesn't not know their exact locations, he might accidentally
walk down an adjacent street and come close enough to one of them
to land himself back in jail.
The defense establishment continues to err in the Vanunu affair,
just as it did in the 1980s. Instead of allowing him to wander
around the world, speak about anything he wished to speak about
and simply ignoring him, attention is being focused directly on a
man who can cause absolutely minimal damage. What could happen
anyway? Vanunu will claim that Israel has to be disarmed of her
nuclear weapons. He would be invited to conferences and be
honored by those who hate Israel. He would become a hero for a
moment for those who want to pressure Israel on the nuclear
issue. Well, so what? Will that harm national security? Of course
not.
A similar mistake was made, by the way, in 1986, when the Sunday
Times hesitated to publish Vanunu's revelations, fearing that
they were a fabrication (this was a short time after the paper
had fallen victim to fraud and published "Hitler's Diaries,"
which turned out to be forgeries). Only after the editor of the
Times realized that then prime minister Shimon Peres had convened
the editors' committee and had asked its members not to give the
affair broad coverage, did the British newspaper become convinced
that Vanunu was telling the truth and published his account and
the photographs he had taken.
Vanunu is not a conscientious objector. He does not belong to the
group of scientists and academicians working to rid the world of
its nuclear weapons. He is a strange man with strange ideas who
committed a very serious crime for which he was tried and
imprisoned for a lengthy period. The restrictions imposed on him
and the declarations of the terrible damage he could cause are
unnecessary exaggeration. Leave Vanunu alone. Simply ignore him.
Don't turn him into a cultural hero.
[http://www.haaretz.com] |
© Copyright Haaretz. All rights reserved
*****************************************************************
15 SFC: Vanunu's release refocuses attention on Israel's `bomb in the basement'
SF Chronicle [http://sfgate.com]
KARIN LAUB, Associated Press Writer
Monday, April 19, 2004
(04-19) 13:05 PDT JERUSALEM (AP) --
Eighteen years after he was kidnapped by Mossad agents for
exposing Israel's secret nuclear program, Mordechai Vanunu will
go free this week -- a moment Israel fears will refocus unwelcome
attention on its "bomb in the basement."
In remarks broadcast Monday, the 50-year-old Vanunu said he has
no more secrets to reveal, but he'd like to see Israel's nuclear
reactor destroyed.
The audiotape of a recent conversation in prison between Vanunu
and Shin Bet agents marked the first time Israelis heard him
explain his actions. Vanunu's brother, Meir, said Monday the
prisoner didn't know his remarks would be published.
Anti-nuclear crusaders, including actors, legislators and a Nobel
Peace Prize laureate, were flying in from Europe and the United
States for Wednesday's release, but they won't be able to embrace
their hero.
Trying to quash any celebrations, the security services have
barred Vanunu from speaking to foreigners, traveling abroad or
even approaching foreign embassies for fear he might seek
political asylum.
Vanunu's campaign began in 1986, when he gave The Sunday Times of
London a description and photographs of Israel's Dimona reactor,
where he had worked for nine years. Based on his account, experts
said at the time that Israel had the world's sixth-largest
stockpile of nuclear weapons.
The revelations undercut Israel's policy of "nuclear ambiguity."
That policy was forged in the 1960s when Israel promised the
United States it would not declare its nuclear status, test
nuclear weapons or use them for political gain, wrote Israeli
historian Avner Cohen. In exchange, Washington did not pressure
Israel to disarm, he said.
Israel has kept the pledge, neither confirming nor denying it has
nuclear capability. Some say that by drawing attention to its
nuclear capability, Vanunu actually boosted Israel's deterrence.
Anti-nuclear campaigners were flying to Israel to greet Vanunu
outside Shikma Prison in the coastal town of Ashkelon. Among them
were Mairead Corrigan Maguire, a 1976 Nobel Peace Prize laureate
from Northern Ireland, and British actress Susannah York. Others
sent messages, including British playwright Harold Pinter who
wrote: "You are a remarkable man, a man of principle and
integrity."
Vanunu received thousands of letters over the years, and was
adopted by an American couple, Nick and Mary Eoloff of St. Paul,
Minn.
The prisoner proudly told Shin Bet interrogators the world
considers him a hero, according to the audiotape.
However, there is little sympathy for him in Israel, a country
where just about everything is debated openly -- except nuclear
weapons. The phrase "bomb in the basement" has been frequently
used to describe Israel's secret nuclear program. It was also the
title of a 2001 Israeli documentary, "A Bomb in the Basement --
Israel's Nuclear Option."
Israelis believe the weapons are their last line of defense, "the
ultimate guarantee that another Holocaust will not happen," said
legal commentator Moshe Negbi. The consensus is that too much
talk will only harm security.
Still, critics say, Vanunu's punishment was excessive.
Yossi Melman, a journalist who writes about espionage, said the
security services were trying to deter others and distract
attention from their own blunders. The Shin Bet ignored warning
signs that Vanunu had been drawn into left-wing circles while
working at the reactor, Melman said.
Vanunu said Israel shouldn't have trusted him with classified
material. "You gave information to the wrong man," he told the
Shin Bet.
Vanunu was snatched from Rome by the Mossad in 1986 after being
lured into a rendezvous by a female agent. He was smuggled to
Israel by yacht, tried behind closed doors and sentenced to 18
years for treason.
He spent 12 of those years in solitary confinement, earning him a
mention in the 1998 edition of Guinness World Records.
In the first 21/2 years, Vanunu was under 24-hour video
surveillance, with fluorescent lights on at all times in his
windowless cell, said his brother Meir. He was allowed a one-hour
daily walk in a yard shrouded in canvas to prevent him from
signaling other prisoners. His only human contact was a guard and
a family visit every two weeks.
The crushing isolation harmed Vanunu's mental health, according
to his brother, an opinion backed by former Israeli legislator
Yossi Katz, who met him in 1998. Vanunu improved after getting
out of solitary.
Israeli newspapers ran rare photographs of the white-haired,
balding Vanunu on Monday, showing him in jeans, a brown prison
uniform shirt and a blue ski jacket. Vanunu, a convert to
Christianity, wore a gold cross around his neck.
The prisoner, one of 11 children of working-class Jewish
immigrants from Morocco, seems to have been an accidental spy.
He was a loner who rebelled against his ultra-Orthodox Jewish
upbringing. He studied at Ben Gurion University in the Negev
desert while working at the reactor and earned an undergraduate
degree in philosophy.
In 1985, after getting fired from his job in Dimona, Vanunu flew
to Thailand, where he stayed at a Buddhist monastery and
considered conversion, then moved to Australia. He joined an
Anglican congregation in Sydney, changed his name to John
Crossman and met a freelance journalist who suggested Vanunu talk
to the media about Dimona.
With Vanunu's impending release, Israel's nuclear program has hit
the headlines again, reviving demands that Israel disarm. Egypt
says Israel's arsenal is spurring Arab and Muslim countries to
develop their own bombs.
In an attempt at damage control, Israel is imposing restrictions
on Vanunu, with the implicit threat of re-arrest.
"We just want to stop him from spreading state secrets," said
Likud Party legislator Yuval Steinitz, chairman of parliament's
Defense and Foreign Affairs Committee. "We think Vanunu still has
information he hasn't revealed."
[Buy The San Francisco Chronicle]
©2004 Associated Press
*****************************************************************
16 Reuters: What Nuke Whistleblower Doesn't Know Scares Israel
Mon Apr 19, 2004 08:43 AM ET
By Dan Williams
TEL AVIV (Reuters) - With one newspaper interview, Mordechai
Vanunu blew away Israel's cherished nuclear secrecy.
Now Israeli policy makers fear the 49-year-old whistle-blower
could emerge from prison with new claims about his work at the
Dimona reactor and that fantasy may be as harmful as fact.
"Who will guarantee that he will only speak the truth? What is
to stop him imagining things?" Shabtai Shavit, a former chief of
Israel's Mossad intelligence agency, told Reuters.
"The main consideration should be his intent to go on causing
damage to Israel," said Shavit, who took part in secret
deliberations on keeping Vanunu under surveillance when he ends
an 18-year jail term Wednesday, April 21.
In statements made through relatives, Vanunu has said he has
nothing to add to his 1986 disclosures to Britain's Sunday Times
newspaper -- which led analysts to conclude Dimona had produced
as many as 200 nuclear bombs and made Israel a military
superpower.
A mid-level Dimona technician, Vanunu was fired in 1985 and
converted to Christianity. After the Sunday Times interview, he
was abducted by Mossad and tried as a traitor.
By all accounts, Vanunu is angry and distraught at his treatment
and vowed to continue campaigning to expose Israel's
nonconventional weapons capabilities.
Israeli security veterans are worried by this mix of ideology
and ire.
Some question the government's decision to keep Vanunu in the
country, tap his phone and bar his access to the press for a
probationary period after his release.
"I think it is a mistake to gag him," said David Kimche, a
retired Mossad operative and Foreign Ministry chief of staff.
"It only bolsters Vanunu's supposed credibility and, in turn,
pretty much anything he may choose to concoct about Israel."
*****************************************************************
17 Arutz Sheva: Ministers Instructed to Remain Silent on Vanunu Affair
IsraelNN.com
21:54 Apr 19, '04 / 28 Nisan 5764
(IsraelNN.com) On Wednesday nuclear spy Mordehai Vanunu is
scheduled to leave prison after completing his 18-year sentence.
The Prime Minister’s Office today instructed cabinet ministers to
refrain from granting interviews on the scheduled release, with
the exception of Justice Minister Tommy Lapid.
Cabinet Secretary Yisrael Maimon explained it is of the utmost
importance that the cabinet voice be one, without hearing varying
opinions from the different ministers due to the sensitivity of
the case. Maimon added that Lapid is well informed regarding the
imminent release and the restrictions being imposed on Vanunu
following his release and therefore, the most qualified to deal
with the media.
All rights reserved IsraelNationalNews ©
Arutz Sheva Israel Broadcasting Network
webmaster@israelnationalnews.com
[http://www.binamica.co.il/]
*****************************************************************
18 BostonHerald: Vanunu: Israel's nuclear reactor should be destroyed
Israeli nuclear whistle-blower Mordechai Vanunu has called for
the destruction of Israel's secretive Dimona reactor, newspapers
reported. (AP)
By Associated Press
Monday, April 19, 2004JERUSALEM - Nuclear whistleblower Mordechai
Vanunu said he has no more secrets to reveal, but he believes
Israel's nuclear reactor near the desert town of Dimona should be
destroyed, according to remarks published Monday.
Vanunu is to be released Wednesday, after serving 18 years
for treason.
In 1986, the former Dimona technician provided photographs
and descriptions of the reactor to The Sunday Times of London.
Based on his information, experts at the time said Israel has the
world's sixth-largest stockpile of nuclear weapons.
Mossad agents kidnapped Vanunu from Italy in 1986, and he
has largely been kept out of sight since then, except for
occasional court appearances.
On Monday, Israeli newspapers ran rare photographs of
Vanunu, provided by Israel's Prisons Authority. The white-haired,
balding Vanunu was shown in a prison courtyard, wearing jeans, a
brown prison uniform shirt and a blue ski jacket. The convert to
Christianity wore a cross on a gold chain around his neck.
The Yediot Ahronot and Maariv newspapers published
excerpts from what they said was Vanunu's interrogation by Shin
Bet security agents two weeks ago. Vanunu appeared to be
rambling at times, sometimes referring to himself in the third
person and other times as ``we.''
Vanunu spent 12 years of his term in solitary confinement,
and his mental health suffered during that time, his brother
Meir and his attorney have said. Vanunu has improved since
getting out of solitary, they said.
Israel is concerned that Vanunu's release will refocus
attention on its nuclear program. As part of its policy of
nuclear ambiguity, Israel neither confirms nor denies it has
nuclear weapons.
After his release, Vanunu will be prevented from traveling
abroad for a year, from contacting foreigners and from
discussing his work at the nuclear reactor and the circumstances
of his capture. Vanunu plans to appeal to the Supreme Court if
the restrictions are not rescinded.
In his conversation with the Shin Bet agents, Vanunu said
the United States and Europe already know everything they need
to know about Israel's nuclear program.
``As for myself, I just want to repeat the things I
already said and that were published,'' Vanunu was quoted as
saying. He suggested it would be difficult for the Shin Bet to
monitor him, noting that he'll have access to a computer.
Vanunu said he hoped the debate over Israel's nuclear
program would be revived, and he expressed disappointment that
Israel hasn't come under greater pressure to dismantle Dimona.
``I want them to take the reactor, more than that, I want
them to destroy the reactor, as they destroyed the reactor in
Iraq,'' Vanunu said. Israel bombed the Iraqi reactor in 1981, to
prevent Baghdad from obtaining nuclear weapons.
Vanunu, who began working at Dimona in 1977, said Israel
should not have trusted him with sensitive information. While
working at Dimona, Vanunu studied philosophy at Ben Gurion
University and joined left-wing groups on campus.
Vanunu said ``bigshot psychologists'' from the Shin Bet
and the Mossad should have spotted him as a potential security
risk. ``You gave information to the wrong man,'' Maariv quoted
him as saying. However, he insisted he was not a spy.
Vanunu said he believes he is considered a hero by much of
the world.
Asked about his political beliefs, Vanunu said there is no
need for a Jewish state, and that he would prefer for his family
- he is one of 11 children of Jewish immigrants from Morocco -
to live in Morocco or in a Palestinian state.
( © Copyright 2004 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This
No portion of BostonHerald.com
*****************************************************************
19 Straits Times: Beijing pulls no punches with Cheney -
APRIL 20, 2004 TUE
He is told the US should not expect Chinese help on North Korea
unless it helps to curb Taiwanese separatism
By Ching Cheong
HONG KONG - While in China last week, American Vice-President
Dick Cheney was told, in no uncertain terms, what Beijing
expected of Washington in containing separatism in Taiwan.
He received broad hints from his hosts that the United States
should not expect Chinese help over the North Korean nuclear
issue unless Washington was prepared to reciprocate by helping
Beijing check Taiwan's independence movement.
All four top leaders he met - President Hu Jintao, Vice-President
Zeng Qinghong, Premier Wen Jiabao and military supremo Jiang
Zemin - demanded that the US stop selling arms to Taiwan as a
first step in regaining Beijing's cooperation in the Korean
peninsula.
Reflecting the mood of the discussions, a Chinese Foreign
Ministry spokesman urged Washington to scrap the Taiwan Relations
Act (TRA), which empowers American arms sales to Taiwan,
altogether.
Last Saturday, just before Mr Cheney's arrival in Beijing, the US
marked the 25th anniversary of the Act.
A State Department statement said that the TRA had made 'a vital
contribution to ensuring peace and stability in the Taiwan
Strait, and provides a strong framework to help ensure Taiwan's
security'.
The legislation effectively nullified the third Sino-US
communique, which commits the US to reduce arms sales to the
island gradually to nought.
However, for the past 25 years, arms sales have increased both
qualitatively and quantitatively.
Previously, such arms were mainly defensive. But since 2000, they
included offensive ones as well.
Beijing has tried to tolerate the breach, hoping that good
Sino-US relations would curb Taiwanese separatism.
But the result of the March 20 presidential election in Taiwan
dashed such hopes.
From Beijing's point of view, the election showed clearly the
American hand behind the re-election of pro-independence
President Chen Shui-bian.
In mid-last year, when his popularity was at an all-time low, the
US helped bolster it by having Secretary of State Colin Powell
shake hands with him twice - an unprecedented move since the US
switched diplomatic recognition to Beijing in 1979.
Late last year, when Mr Chen announced his plan to hold a
referendum alongside the presidential election, the US, despite
great Chinese pressure to intervene, was willing only to force
him to drop the provocative tone but not the referendum itself.
In February this year, when Chinese Vice-Foreign Minister Dai
Bingguo visited the US, he was given an assurance that the US
would not congratulate Mr Chen should he win re-election.
Washington broke its promise.
And then early this month, the US announced the sale of
long-range radar to Taiwan to boost its early warning capability.
To the Chinese, all these can only suggest that the US is happy
to see Mr Chen re-elected.
Many Chinese scholars have pointed out that Chinese and American
interests over Taiwan do not converge and so it would be futile
for Beijing to rely on Washington to curb separatist sentiments
in Taiwan.
Professor Zhu Liqun, of the Institute of Foreign Affairs Studies,
said that such a policy would lead to nowhere and should be
replaced by one that bolsters China's national defence
capability.
His view is that as far as the US is concerned, the best scenario
would be peaceful independence for Taiwan while the worst would
be peaceful unification with China.
And if peaceful independence is not possible, then the
second-best scenario is preservation of the status quo, achieved
by arming Taiwan to withstand Chinese pressure for unification.
In maintaining the status quo, the US would prefer Mr Chen's
pro-separation Democratic Progress Party (DPP) rather than the
pro-unification opposition coalition to run the island because
only the DPP could prevent the worst-case scenario from
happening.
To the US, managing a rising China remains one of its core
concerns for the next 50 years.
A rising China unified with Taiwan means that the combined
economic might of the two entities could well displace US
influence in the region, not to mention the military implications
of China entering the Pacific Ocean via Taiwan.
Thus, while it is China's core interest to bring Taiwan into its
fold, it is America's interest to see the two separated.
The US would step in if and only if Taiwan's provocation was
likely to lead to war between China and the US.
According to Prof Zhu, this decade-long policy of relying on the
US to restrain Taiwan only had the effect of allowing it to drift
further away.
If China is serious about unification, then it should scrap the
policy and build up its national defence, he said.
to The Straits Times
asia1.com.sg
*****************************************************************
20 NRC: NRC Renews License for H.B. Robinson Steam Electric Plant, Unit 2, for an Additional 20 Years
News Release - 2004-04
U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
Office of Public Affairs Telephone: 301/415-8200
Washington, DC 20555-0001 E-mail: opa@nrc.gov
No. 04-043 April 19, 2004
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission has renewed the operating
license of Unit 2 of the nuclear power facility at the H.B.
Robinson Steam Electric Plant, located in Darlington County,
S.C., for an additional 20 years. The plant is operated by
Carolina Power & Light Company (CP&L).
CP&L submitted its license renewal application to the NRC on
June 14, 2002. The renewal extends the license for H.B. Robinson
Unit 2 from July 31, 2010, to July 31, 2030.
The NRCs environmental review is described in a site-specific
supplement to the NRCs Generic Environmental Impact Statement
for License Renewal of Nuclear Power Plants," (NUREG-1437,
Supplement 13). In the Final Supplemental Environmental Impact
Statement, issued in December 2003, the staff concluded that
there were no impacts that would preclude renewal of the license
for environmental reasons. Two public meetings to discuss the
environmental review were held near the plant on September 25,
2002, and June 25, 2003.
In its Safety Evaluation Report Related to the License Renewal
of H.B. Robinson Steam Electric Plant, Unit 2, issued in
January 2004, the NRC staff concluded that there were no safety
concerns that would preclude license renewal, because the
licensee had demonstrated the capability to manage the effects
of plant aging. In addition, the NRC conducted inspections of
the plants to verify information submitted by the licensee. The
Safety Evaluation Report is available on the NRC Web site at
this address:
http://www.nrc.gov/reactors/operating/licensing/renewal/applicati
ons/robinson.html.
On March 18, 2004, the Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards
-- an independent body of technical experts which advises the
Commission -- issued its recommendation that the operating
license for H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, be renewed. That
recommendation is contained in "Report on the Safety Aspects of
the License Renewal Application for the H.B. Robinson Steam
Electric Plant, Unit 2." A copy of this document is available on
the NRC Web site at this address:
http://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/doc-collections/acrs/letters/2004/5
102069.pdf [PDF Icon] .
The H.B. Robinson license renewal brings the total number of
renewals to 24 units. A complete listing of completed renewal
applications, as well as those currently under review, can be
found on the NRCs Web site at this address:
http://www.nrc.gov/reactors/operating/licensing/renewal/applicati
ons.html.
Last revised Monday, April 19, 2004
*****************************************************************
21 NRC: Report on the Independent Verification of the Mitigating Systems
FR Doc 04-8749
[Federal Register: April 19, 2004 (Volume 69, Number 75)]
[Notices] [Page 20953-20954] From the Federal Register Online via
GPO Access [wais.access.gpo.gov] [DOCID:fr19ap04-98]
Performance Index (MSPI) Results for the Pilot Plants AGENCY:
Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
ACTION: Request for comment.
SUMMARY: The Nuclear Regulatory Commission is announcing the
availability of the draft document entitled: ``Report on the
Independent Verification of the Mitigating Systems Performance
Index (MSPI) Results for the Pilot Plants,'' dated February 2004
for review and comment by external stakeholders. Interested
individuals may obtain a copy of this document from ADAMS
Accession ML040550036 via the public web site, or from the person
identified under the caption: FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT.
DATES: Submit comments by June 15, 2004. Comments received after
this date will be considered if it is practical to do so, but the
Commission is able to ensure consideration only for comments
received on or before this date.
ADDRESSES: Submit comments to: Chief, Rules and Directives
Branch, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC
20555-0001.
Deliver comments to: 11545 Rockville Pike, Rockville, Maryland,
between 7:30 a.m. and 4:15 p.m. Federal workdays. The draft
document and certain other documents related to this action,
including comments received, may be examined in the NRC Public
Document Room, 11555 Rockville Pike, Rockville, Maryland.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Donald A. Dube, Division of Risk
Analysis and Applications, Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research,
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC 20555-0001.
Telephone: 301-415-5472, e-mail: dad3@nrc.gov [dad3@nrc.gov] .
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The Reactor Oversight Process (ROP)
was created four years ago to improve the NRC's regulatory
oversight of licensee operation of commercial nuclear power
plants. It is intended to better risk-inform agency actions and
bring more objectivity to the regulatory process. The ROP is
consistent with the goals of the Commission's Probabilistic Risk
Assessment (PRA) Policy Statement and the NRC's Strategic Plan
(NUREG-1614), which include increased use of the PRA technology
in ``* * * regulatory matters to the extent supported by the
state-of-the-art in PRA methods and data and in a manner that
complements the NRC's deterministic approach and supports the
NRC's traditional defense-in-depth philosophy.'' The ROP is
reflective of the NRC's efforts to better risk-inform its core
processes.
SECY-99-007 and 99-007A, ``Recommendations for Reactor Oversight
Process Improvements,'' described the ROP. The ROP was
implemented in April 2000 following a six-month pilot program
conducted in 1999. The results of this pilot program were
described in SECY-00-0049, ``Results of the Revised Reactor
Oversight Process Pilot Program.'' A fundamental aspect of the
ROP is the use of both performance indicators and inspection
findings to determine whether the objectives of the ROP's
cornerstones of safety are being met on a plant-specific basis.
In light of the movement toward more risk-informed and
performance- based oversight, draft Risk-Based Performance
Indicators (RBPI) were developed to (1) address specific areas in
the current ROP that were identified in SECY-00-0049 as possible
enhancements and (2) potentially support any future development
of performance indicators using improved risk analysis tools.
NUREG-1753, ``Risk-Based Performance Indicators: Results of Phase
1 Development,'' discussed the technical feasibility of using
available risk models and data to enhance the NRC's ability to
monitor plant-specific safety performance of reactors in a risk-
informed and performance-based manner. This development activity
was designed to fit into the ROP concept for indicators,
thresholds, and performance monitoring while continuing to move
the NRC's programs forward in accordance with the PRA Policy
Statement and the goals of the Strategic Plan.
The Mitigating Systems Performance Index (MSPI) builds upon the
insights and findings developed in the RBPI Program as discussed
in NUREG-1753. The MSPI is described in ``NRC Regulatory Issue
Summary 2002-14, Supplement 1 Proposed Changes to the Safety
System Unavailability Performance Indicators,'' Attachments 1 and
2, draft NEI 99-02, Rev. 0, ``Regulatory Assessment Performance
[[Page 20954]] Indicator Guideline,'' Section 2.2 ``Mitigating
Systems Performance Index'' and Appendix F ``Methodologies for
Computing the Unavailability Index, the Unreliability Index, and
Determining Performance Index Validity''.
The MSPI was developed as a potential replacement for the Safety
System Unavailability (SSU) performance indicator. The purpose of
the MSPI is to ``monitor the performance of selected systems
based on their ability to perform risk-significant functions * *
*'' The NRC's Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research developed the
MSPI to address several specific problems with the currently used
performance indicators including: the use of fault exposure hours
in the SSU, the omission of unreliability elements in the
indicator, the use of mostly one-size- fits-all performance
thresholds irrespective of risk-significance of the system, and
the cascading of support system failures onto mitigating system
unavailability. A twelve-month pilot program on the MSPI
consisting of twenty nuclear power plant units was initiated in
September of 2002. For the first six months, licensees submitted
system and component performance data, and exercised the MSPI
algorithm. Over the second six months of the pilot, the NRC staff
worked to fully assess the results as well as to identify
technical issues and to provide recommendations for their
resolution. Numerous meetings involving both internal and
external stakeholders have been held to discuss developmental
details of the MSPI. The MSPI was extensively tested, evaluated,
and reviewed during the pilot plant trial and evaluation period.
Although the NRC staff recently announced that use of the MSPI in
the ROP, as piloted, would not be pursued further, the subject
draft report is being made available to document the results of
the NRC evaluation of technical issues and detailed proposed
changes to the MSPI methodology. The report can be found as ADAMS
Accession ML040550036 via the NRC public Web site at
http://www.nrc.gov
[http://frwebgate.access.gpo.gov/cgi-bin/leaving.cgi?from=leaving
FR.html&log=linklog&to=http://www.nrc.gov] . A briefing on the
results of the MSPI pilot before the Advisory Committee on
Reactor Safeguards Subcommittee on Reliability and PRA, and Plant
Operations, is currently scheduled for April 14, 2004 from 8 a.m.
to 11 a.m. at NRC Headquarters in T2B3 of Two White Flint,
Rockville, MD. Separately, the Office of Nuclear Reactor
Regulation intends to document the concerns with the piloted MSPI
and conduct a public meeting to solicit further stakeholder input
regarding the MSPI. Information regarding this public meeting
will be provided at a later date.
At this time, we are interested in comments regarding all aspects
of the subject report, particularly the following areas:
Fundamental mathematical formulation of the MSPI.
Recommended improvements to the originally formulated MSPI
methodology per draft revision to NEI 99-02.
Overall technical findings and results of the MSPI pilot,
including validity of MSPI outcomes.
Dated at Rockville, Maryland, this 7th day of April, 2004.
For the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
Charles E. Ader, Director, Division of Risk Analysis and
Applications, Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research.
[FR Doc. 04-8749 Filed 4-16-04; 8:45 am] BILLING CODE 7590-01-P
*****************************************************************
22 Herald: Call to expand nuclear power use attacked by greens
Web Issue 1986 April 19 2004
Herald [http://www.sundayherald.com/]
STEPHEN STEWART April 19 2004
CALLS for the government to make greater use of nuclear power
instead of windfarms were denounced by environmental groups
yesterday.
The Sunday Herald, The Herald's sister paper, reported that the
David Hume Institute, the Edinburgh-based economic think tank,
intends to publish a report urging ministers to reconsider
nuclear power and abandon renewable resources such as wind power.
Professor David Simpson, founding director of the Fraser of
Allander Institute and former professor of economics at
Strathclyde University, commissioned the report, which was
leaked to the newspaper. He is due to deliver the report at the
Royal Society of Edinburgh this week.
He claimed that the cost of generating electricity from wind
power was twice as high as from nuclear power and gas. Extra
costs generated by renewable energy were adding about 2% to
domestic electricity bills, he added.
However, Friends of the Earth Scotland said calls for new
nuclear power plants in Scotland were "environmental and
economic madness".
Dr Dan Barlow, Friends of the Earth Scotland's head of
research, said: "Claims that nuclear power would be better than
renewables, such as wind, simply don't add up.
"For an organisation which puts so much faith in the ability of
the market to deliver, this report conveniently forgets that
when it comes to nuclear power the market has already spoken.
Despite decades of support and billions of pounds in public
subsidy nuclear power remains an uneconomic, unsafe and unwanted
energy technology.
"A return to nuclear power would be environmental and economic
madness."
theherald.co.uk
Copyright © Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights
*****************************************************************
23 Pravda.RU: Vietnam modernizes its nuclear reactor
[PRAVDA.RU] Last update:04/20/2004 05:30 MSK
15:29 2004-04-19
Vietnam, with the help of the International Atomic Energy Agency
(IAEA), began work to modernize its nuclear reactor. Yesterday,
the Vietnamese Ministry of Science and Technology authorized the
modernization project.
According to the Vietnamese Atomic Energy Institute, a full
evaluation of the technical condition of the reactor, especially
its control systems, is envisaged within the framework of the
project. Special consideration will be given to the technical
variants of the modernization of the system and the possible
replacement of old equipment, including protective devices.
To realize the project, the IAEA will allocate over $240,000 to
the Vietnamese Institute of Nuclear Research and the Institute of
Atomic Energy.
The project is scheduled to be completed in 2005.
The reactor is in Da Lat, a city in central Vietnam. In 1963, the
Saigon regime put the 240 kilowatt reactor into operation.
After the regime was overthrown in 1975 and the Americans
dismantled the main components, the reactor stopped operating.
Soviet experts doubled its capacity (500 kilowatts) and put the
reactor back into operation in 1984.
In 20 years, the reactor has not had any technological or
ecological failures.
© RIAN
Copyright ©1999 by " [http://www.pravda.ru/] ". When
*****************************************************************
24 AP Wire: NRC approves license renewal for Pee Dee nuclear plant
| 04/19/2004 |
Associated Press
COLUMBIA, S.C. - A nuclear power plant has received regulatory
approval to continue operating until 2030, the Nuclear Regulator
Commission said Monday.
The H.B. Robinson nuclear facility's original license was set to
expire in 2010. The NRC said there were no safety or
environmental factors that should prevent the license renewal.
"This is a significant achievement that positions the Robinson
plant to continue to provide safe, reliable, efficient power to
Progress Energy customers for many years to come," said John
Moyer, the plant's vice president.
Plant operator Carolina Power & Light Co. submitted an
application to renew the license.
The plant received its original license in 1970.
*****************************************************************
25 PRN: Robinson Nuclear Plant's License Renewed by NRC Through July 2030
[PR Newswire]
Press Release Source: Progress Energy, Inc.
Monday April 19, 1:19 pm ET
HARTSVILLE, S.C., April 19 /PRNewswire-FirstCall/ -- The H.B.
Robinson Nuclear Plant near Hartsville, S.C., is operating today
with a renewed commitment to meeting the future energy needs of
Progress Energy's customers. + (Logo:
http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20020923/CHM008LOGO-c
[http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20020923/CHM008LOGO-c] )
The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) has approved the
renewal of the operating license for the Robinson Nuclear Plant
through July 2030.
"This is a significant achievement that positions the Robinson
Plant to continue to provide safe, reliable, efficient power to
Progress Energy customers for many years to come," said John
Moyer, vice president of the Robinson Nuclear Plant. "This
accomplishment is a testament to the dedication of our plant
employees who have established the excellent safety and
environmental record that led to license renewal. We are
committed to continuing our focus on safety and environmental
stewardship each and every day, throughout the operation of the
plant."
The Robinson Plant has consistently been ranked among the top
nuclear plants in the nation in terms of safety, production and
cost. The renewed operating license will allow the Robinson
Nuclear Plant to continue to meet the energy needs of customers
and provide economic benefits to both Progress Energy and the
local community for decades to come.
"I am pleased to hear that the license has been extended, so that
the Robinson Plant will continue its powerful partnership with
Darlington County through 2030," said Anne Warr, chairwoman of
the Darlington County Council. "Progress Energy is the largest
taxpayer in Darlington County, annually paying more than $8
million in property taxes in our county, with the majority going
towards enhancing the county's education system, safety services
and other public uses. The more than 400 employees at the
Robinson Plant have an excellent record for keeping the plant
running safely and reliably. They also are good citizens in our
community, taking active roles in our schools and in our civic
and community organizations. I'm pleased that we will continue
this valuable partnership for many years to come."
The Robinson Nuclear Plant generates 710 megawatts of electricity
for Progress Energy customers. The Robinson Plant received its
operating license from the NRC in 1970. The plant's original
license term of 40 years was set to expire July 31, 2010. The
NRC's action renews the plant's operating license for an
additional 20 years, through July 2030.
For license renewal, Progress Energy spent 21/2 years performing
an extensive safety review of the Robinson Nuclear Plant's
systems, structures and components. During that 21/2-year period,
the company also performed a thorough review of the environmental
impacts of license renewal.
Once Progress Energy filed for a renewal of the operating license
in June 2002, the NRC began conducting its own review including
onsite inspections. In addition, the NRC performed its own review
of the environmental impacts of renewing the license for an
additional 20 years.
Progress Energy (NYSE: PGN [http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=pgn&d=t]
- News [http://finance.yahoo.com/q/h?s=pgn] ), headquartered in
Raleigh, N.C., is a Fortune 250 diversified energy company with
more than 24,000 megawatts of generation capacity and $9 billion
in annual revenues. The company's holdings include two electric
utilities serving more than 2.8 million customers in North
Carolina, South Carolina and Florida. Progress Energy also
includes nonregulated operations covering generation, energy
marketing, natural gas production, fuel extraction, rail services
and broadband capacity. For more information about Progress
Energy, visit the company's Web site at www.progress-energy.com
[http://www.progress-energy.com] .
Source: Progress Energy, Inc.
Copyright © 2004 PR Newswire. All rights reserved. Republication
*****************************************************************
26 NRC: NRC to Hold Predecisional Enforcement Conference to Discuss Apparent
Violation at Browns Ferry
News Release - Region II - 2004-03
U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
Office of Public Affairs, Region II
No. II-04-034 April 19, 2004
CONTACT: Ken Clark (404) 562-4416
Roger D. Hannah (404) 562-4417 E-mail: [opa2@nrc.gov]
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission staff will hold a
predecisional enforcement conference with Tennessee Valley
Authority officials on Wednesday, April 28, in Atlanta to
discuss an apparent violation of NRC safety requirements at the
Browns Ferry nuclear plant near Athens, Alabama.
The enforcement conference will begin at 1:30 p.m. in the NRC
Region II office on the 24th floor of the Sam Nunn Atlanta
Federal Center at 61 Forsyth Street, SW. The meeting will be
open to observation by interested members of the public, and NRC
officials will be available before its conclusion to answer
questions from those who attend.
NRC inspectors found deficiencies in the Unit 1 Recovery Quality
Assurance Program, specifically related to weld repairs in the
torus. The torus is a large hollow doughnut-shaped pressure
suppression pool which would be used to remove the heat released
from the reactor in the event of an accident.
NRC inspectors found numerous examples of weld repairs that were
omitted due to failure to follow instructions and independently
verify. TVA initiated a 100% review of torus weld repairs, and
the NRC staff says that review and subsequent corrective actions
appear comprehensive enough to resolve the problem.
The conference is an opportunity for company officials to
provide their perspective on the apparent violation and to
clarify or correct any information they feel may be inaccurate
or incomplete in the NRC inspection report. No decision on the
apparent violation or any enforcement action will be made at the
conference. Those decisions will be made later by NRC officials.
Last revised Monday, April 19, 2004
*****************************************************************
27 NRC: NRC to Meet with Duke Energy Officials to Discuss Safety Performance at Catawba
Nuclear Power Plant
News Release - Region II - 2004-03
U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
Office of Public Affairs, Region II
No. II-04-035 April 19, 2004
CONTACT: Ken Clark (404) 562-4416
Roger D. Hannah (404) 562-4417 E-mail: [opa2@nrc.gov]
The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission staff will meet with Duke
Energy officials on Wednesday, May 12, to discuss the results of
NRC's annual assessment of safety performance at the Catawba
nuclear power plant near York, South Carolina.
The meeting will be held at 1:00 p.m. in the City Council
Chambers at the Rock Hill City Hall. The public is invited to
observe the meeting, and NRC officials will be available before
the conclusion of the meeting to answer any questions.
The NRC said both Catawba reactors were operated safely and met
all objectives during the evaluation period which covered the
calendar year 2003. As a result, the NRC plans to conduct only
routine inspections at the Catawba plant in 2004. A letter from
the NRC to Duke Energy outlining the results of the most recent
evaluation is available from Region II Public Affairs and on the
NRC web site at
www.nrc.gov/NRR/OVERSIGHT/ASSESS/LETTERS/cat_2003q4.pdf [PDF
Icon] .
The NRC staff will also conduct inspections this year at Catawba
(not specifically related to the plants performance) related to
operator licensing examinations, inspections of the planned
spent nuclear fuel storage installation, and safety issues
concerning reactor pressure vessel lower head penetration
nozzles and the reactor containment sump.
The agency will also continue to monitor plant actions in
response to NRC security orders and any newly developed portions
of the plant security program.
Current performance indicators for the two units at the Catawba
plant are available at
www.nrc.gov/NRR/OVERSIGHT/ASSESS/CAT1/cat1_chart.html and
www.nrc.gov/NRR/OVERSIGHT/ASSESS/CAT2/cat2_chart.html.
Last revised Monday, April 19, 2004
*****************************************************************
28 [DU-WATCH] connecting dots in Iraq
Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2004 01:16:19 -0500 (CDT)
Can you connect the dots numbered below?
1. Coalition Provisional Authority (CPA) Order #37, Sec 3.2: CPA
& all their retinue of contractors & subcontractors are exempted
from paying Iraq taxes.
CPA Order #40 outlines Central Bank domination of Iraq. CPA Order
#39: no limit on foreign ownership of Iraqi businesses or
profit-removal from Iraq.
http://www.alternet.org/print.html?StoryID=17364
http://cpa-iraq.org/regulations/index.html#Orders
http://www.ahkmena.com/New_Editorial/Details.asp?News=753
http://www.brengzethuis.nl
2. ~70% current Iraqi unemployment.
3. No social safety net in Iraq now of food stamps, etc., & no
supply of tax money to allocate in that direction; none coming in
from abroad, no known plans from abroad to do so.
4. +50% of US corporations didn't pay any US taxes in 1996-2000,
according to recent news report on California radio.
5. US military in Iraq has rules of engagement permitting wide
civilian casulties, whereas British military in Iraq does not have
such rules of engagement, according to senior British officers in
Iraq, 4-11-04.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2004/04/11/wtact11.xml
Can someone connect the dots below?
1. "During the years 1993 to 1999 - while Securacom was doing
contract work for the WTC, United Airlines and the Metropolitan
Washington Airport Authority, and while Bush, Walker and al-Sabah
were sitting on the board - a large and sometimes controlling
interest in the company was held by KuwAm.
And what is KuwAm, you ask? It is a Washington, D.C.-based,
Kuwaiti/American investment group whose board of directors has
included - you guessed it - Marvin Bush, Wirt Walker, and Mishal
Yousef Saud al-Sabah.
Let's briefly recap the coincidences, shall we? The Bush family
coincidentally has close business ties to the family that supplied
the mastermind of the terrorist attacks. The Bush family also
coincidentally had ties to the company that provided security for
the principal target of the attacks, the World Trade Center (this
company would, of course, have been afforded unprecedented and
unquestioned access to the buildings). And the Bush family
coincidentally had similar ties to United Airlines, which supplied
two of the hijacked flights, and Dulles International Airport, which
supplied a third.
The prime suspect, the weapons, the primary target ... I guess the
question that comes to my mind is then: is there any aspect of the
September 11 story that is not coincidentally covered with the
fingerprints of some member of the Bush family?"
http://www.ratical.org/ratville/JFK/JohnJudge/linkscopy/Stratesec.html
2. 7-6-03, Promis security software provided for Saddam by Bush
Sr.
http://www.conspiracyplanet.com/channel.cfm?channelid=2&contentid=1104&page=2
7-6-03, 7-8-03, similar http://www.vdare.com/malkin/inslaw.htm
http://www.terpsboy.com/archives/001358.html
--------------------------------- Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Tax Center - File online by April 15th
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
[Brought to you by HTTP://WWW.STOPNATO.ORG.UK] Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/du-watch/
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
du-watch-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
*****************************************************************
29 [DU-WATCH] Thom Hartmann Radio Interview with Leuren Moret on
Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2004 01:18:39 -0500 (CDT)
Interview with Leuren Moret on depleted uranium on the
Thom Hartmann radio program by local station, internet
radio or satellite radio. Go to this website to find
out how to listen.
http://www.thomhartmann.com/showlisten.shtml
======================================================
RECENT ARTICLE:
http://www.awakenedwoman.com/moret_nuclear.htm
Awakened Woman e-Magazine
War on Iraq is a Nuclear War
And the fallout is coming this way, says independent
scientist Leuren Moret
by Stephanie Hiller
April 10, 2004
In May, 2003, the United States dumped 2,200 tons of
depleted uranium on Iraq, according to reliable
sources, and it's logical to assume that more depleted
uranium is being employed in the current attacks on
Faluja that began April 8 to put down Iraqi resistance
to the American presence there.
According to independent geoscientist Leuren Moret,
the war on Iraq - like the war on Afghanistan - is a
nuclear war. "Depleted uranium is a nuclear weapon and
it is a weapon of mass destruction under the U. S.
government's definition of weapons of mass
destruction," Moret says.
The Pentagon has repeatedly denied that DU is harmful,
despite the symptoms of half the returning veterans
from the first Persian Gulf Wars who are now disabled.
But researchers have shown that the Pentagon has been
fully aware of the consequences of what is called "low
level radiation" since 1943, when depleted uranium was
first suggested for development as a military weapon
under the Manhattan Project.
On Sunday, April 6, the New York Daily News reported
that nine soldiers who returned from Iraq last summer
had symptoms typical of DU poisoning. The News
arranged for them to be tested by Asaf Duracovic, a
former Colonel in the Army Reserves who served in the
1991 Persian Gulf War, and one of the world's foremost
experts on the medical effects of radioactive
weaponry. Depleted uranium was found in the urine of
four of the men - Sgt. Hector Vega, Sgt. Ray Ramos,
Sgt. Agustin Matos and Cpl. Anthony Yonnone - the
first confirmed cases of inhaled depleted uranium
exposure from the current Iraq conflict
Recently completed laboratory analyses show two
members of Uranium Medical Research Centre's (UMRC)
field investigation team are contaminated with
Depleted Uranium (DU). The two field staff, one from
Canada and the other, Beirut, toured Iraq for thirteen
days in October 2003; five months after the cessation
of Operation Iraqi Freedom's aerial bombing and ground
force campaign. Using mass spectrometry, UMRC's
partner laboratory in Germany measured DU in both team
members' urine samples.
(Please see
http://www.umrc.net/UMRC_bulletin_07_Feb_2004.asp)
If short-term visitors and soldiers have been so
affected, what of the people, living near bomb sites,
breathing the air every day, drinking the water? What
of the children who play in these sites and collect
pieces of exploded material to sell so their families
can eat?
Using figures developed by Japanese physicist,
Professor Yagasaki from the University of the Ryukyus,
Okinawa, and explained in his presentation at the
World Conference on Depleted Uranium Weapons held in
Hamburg last October, the radioactivity of 2,200 tons
(or 440,000 pounds) of depleted uranium together with
some 1,000 tons used in Afghanistan, is the atomicity
equivalent of 400,00 Nagasaki bombs.
Depleted uranium is cheap and plentiful. When uranium
is processed for fission bombs or fuel rods for use in
power plants, only U-235, about half a percent of the
total, is used. Most of what's left over is U-238,
so-called "depleted" uranium. The US has over a
million tons of the stuff, and storage is becoming a
serious problem.
Though less radioactive than U-235, DU is still highly
radioactive internally, and chemically toxic as well.
"There is no allowable level of risk," says Moret.
Nearly twice as dense as lead, DU is used in tanks and
airplanes, as well as bullets, handguns, cannons, all
the way up to large bombs weighing more than 5,000
pounds.
It's not dangerous until it blows up.
Depleted uranium is pyrophoric. Relatively innocuous
as a metal alloy used in planes, tanks, missiles,
bullets and rounds, when depleted uranium burns, it
releases a radioactive gas. Larger particles may
settle to the ground, but winds blowing across the
desert may carry the fine particles to locations in a
1000-mile radius from the explosion. As a result,
areas as far west as Egypt and as far east as India
are likely to be contaminated. "The U.S. has staged a
nuclear war in the Middle East, from Iraq and Central
Asia, to the northern half of India. Half of Egypt,
Israel, the Saudi Arabian peninsula, Turkey, Iran, the
Russian oil-rich states, the Caspian oil region, and
northern are now, or will be, all contaminated."
Depleted uranium - U-238 - has a half-life of 4.5
billion years. It's effects will be with us forever.
It is in the soil, in the groundwater, in food, but
the worst of all, it is in the air. When inhaled, it
enters directly into the bloodstream. One uranium
particle behaves in the body like a tiny nuclear bomb,
sending out alpha and beta particles and gamma rays to
adjacent cells. These are permanently damaging to the
cells and chromosomes and lead to a host of deadly
diseases, including cancer and leukemia. They also
cause mutations of the genetic material that will show
up in subsequent generations as terrible birth
deformities, weakened health, and infertility.
Moret says the fallout from these foreign wars is
headed our way. Spread by powerful desert winds, the
fallout will be carried certainly as far as Britain
(where dust storms from the Middle East commonly leave
residual dust) and then across the Atlantic Ocean. It
will also travel across Asia and the Pacific Ocean and
be slowly and silently deposited across the North
American continent.
American citizens have already been exposed to
radiation from a variety of sources including
malfunctioning nuclear power plants, the disasters at
Chernobyl and Three Mile Island, above-ground bomb
tests conducted from 1957 to 1963, and the enormous
existing pile of depleted uranium, about 1 million
tons, poorly stored in the United States. Radiation
has caused the geometric rise of cancers in the US - 1
in 3 Americans compared to 1 in 20 before the second
World War. It is also responsible for the rise in
autism, learning disabilities, chronic immune
deficiency disorders (chronic fatigue syndrome,
Epstein-Barr and so forth), higher rates of infant
mortality and the general weakening of the public's
health.
Leuren Moret was formerly employed at the Lawrence
Berkeley Radiation Laboratory in Berkeley, and the
Lawrence Livermore nuclear weapons lab. Since walking
out on her job to become a whistleblower at Livermore
in 1991, she has devoted her time to the study of the
effects of nuclear radiation. She has worked with
scientists like Dr. Ernest Sternglass, Marian Fulk,
Dr. Asaf Durakovic of the Uranium Medical Research
Center, Dr. Doug Rokke of Traprock Peace Center and
many others. Her testimony at the International
Criminal Tribunal for Afghanistan held December 13-14,
2003, in Tokyo was largely responsible for the
unanimous verdict on depleted uranium, and that the
President Bush and the United States is guilty of war
crimes against that country.
Leuren Moret will be interviewed by Janie Rezner on
her show, Women's Voices, this Monday, April 12, at 7
pm Pacific Daylight Savings time. You can listen to
the interview via the internet. Visit www.kzyx.org
MORE INFORMATION
http://www.mindfully.org
http://www.traprockpeace.org
http://www.umrc.net
http://www.uraniumweaponsconference.de/speakers.htm
The European Committee on Radiation Risk, within the
European Parliament, has just published an excellent
report on low-level radiation at
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Tax Center - File online by April 15th
http://taxes.yahoo.com/filing.html
------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor ---------------------~-->
Buy Ink Cartridges or Refill Kits for your HP, Epson, Canon or Lexmark
Printer at MyInks.com. Free s/h on orders $50 or more to the US & Canada.
http://www.c1tracking.com/l.asp?cid=5511
http://us.click.yahoo.com/mOAaAA/3exGAA/qnsNAA/Sj.0lB/TM
---------------------------------------------------------------------~->
[Brought to you by HTTP://WWW.STOPNATO.ORG.UK]
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/du-watch/
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
du-watch-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
*****************************************************************
30 [DU-WATCH] why we didn't check before - chelation therapy (or
Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2004 01:29:06 -0500 (CDT)
News Flash! ......This article is a "call to the
healthcare industry"......
Chelation Therapy for Heavy Metals Poisoning is NOT
illegal in the State of Kentucky. It is the
individual doctor's choice to treat patients with
Chelation Therapy, or not. (Says the Pharmacy
Department of the Drug Enforcement Branch of the
Kentucky Health Services Dept. in Frankfort KY)
Chelation Therapy is a cleansing treatment by which
certain medicines, when injected, attract the
molecules and isotopes of harmful elements trapped in
the human body, force them back into the bloodstream
and out of the body through normal excrement's.
Many victims of Multiple Heavy Metals Poisoning, in
the State of Kentucky and across America, have been
told by different doctors, other health care persons
and even politicians (Lois Wineburg) that in Kentucky,
Chelation Therapy is illegal.
How many lives could have been saved if the truth was
made public and our doctors that are not familiar with
Chelation Therapy would take a few moments to learn
the truth about the limited risks (almost nil) related
to Chelation Therapy.
This independent investigative advocate for victims of
Depleted Uranium Poisoning and other Multiple Heavy
Metals Poisoning, has found through three years of
research that the only risk that Chelation Therapy
presents is with the use of Sulfur Drugs that enhance
the Chelation process. All a doctor must do is either
"ask" the patient if he, or she is sensitive to Sulfur
drugs, or conduct a simple test to find out if the
patient is allergic to Sulfur.
In my discussion with dozens of victims across America
and three other nations, victims who in turn are
familiar with hundreds of other victims of Heavy
Metals Poisoning, not one person has reported negative
results from being treated with Chelation Therapy.
Most victims report a drastic improvement in their
health. Victims already suffering from Cancers, MS,
MD and other debilitating diseases have not had as
great success, but did show signs of increased
strength and quality of life. To put it plainly, they
"felt" much better having these poisons out of their
bodies. (One victim traveled to Costa Rica for four
weeks of treatments and reports being apparently
cured.)
So, why are our doctors not practicing Chelation
Therapy? The only answer I have been able to find in
interviewing seven or eight, is that they were taught
in school that Chelation Therapy is "Alternative
Medicine", not "Traditional" and therefore, not to be
practiced by "Accepted" medical practitioners. In
other words, if a doctor treats patients with
Chelation Therapy, he,or she runs the risk of being
branded a "Renegade", or labeled with another childish
name and thus have his, or her reputation ruined.
Petty, at the least.
One doctor was kind enough to admit that his view was
that if he continued to avoid the use of Chelation
Therapy, he could continue to treat hundreds of
patients. If he "bucked the system", his fellow
physicians would shun him, hospitals would curtail his
privileges and he would be reduced to treating a
handful of patients. This is "petty politics in
medicine".
One doctor in Tennessee that treated me with Chelation
Therapy and saved my life, and the lives of dozens
others, was forced to stop treating patients by a
Department of the United States Government threatening
his employer. (Names withheld as a courtesy)
Local Paducah area health food store employees have
told me that over the past twenty years the Food and
Drug Administration has targeted doctors and small
clinics that have tried to treat with Chelation
Therapy. While the FDA could not stop these clinics
from using Chelation Therapy, because it was legal,
they spent days going through the clinic records until
they found some trivial questionable record and used
it to shut down the clinic.
This article is a "call to the healthcare industry", a
plea for life giving Chelation Therapy Treatments. I
would be dead today, if I did not receive my three day
Chelation Therapy Treatment, three years ago. I know
several other people in Western Kentucky that are
alive today ONLY because a caring doctor "bucked the
system" as long as he could, until he was forced to
stop, saving the lives of doomed victims of Heavy
Metals Poisoning.
Kentucky Doctors and Hospitals, PLEASE bring Chelation
Therapy to Kentucky. PLEASE give us this life-saving
service.
Every person that I have talked too, EVERY ONE has
said that if their doctor would treat them with
Chelation Therapy, they would not consider malpractice
suits. They would be so grateful for the treatments,
they would tell everyone to go to their doctor and be
treated. This fallacy that Chelation Therapy is
dangerous is not true. The real danger is trying to
survive without it.
This article is humbly submitted for copy, reprint and
publication in any news media anywhere in the world.
I give my permission to reproduce in any manner, but
not to be altered in any way.
Blessings,
Charles M. Driver
10455 Old Lovelaceville Rd.
Paducah KY 42001
270-488-3999
gizmo@brtc.net
____________________________________________________________
Yahoo! Messenger - Communicate instantly..."Ping"
your friends today! Download Messenger Now
http://uk.messenger.yahoo.com/download/index.html
------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor ---------------------~-->
Buy Ink Cartridges or Refill Kits for your HP, Epson, Canon or Lexmark
Printer at MyInks.com. Free s/h on orders $50 or more to the US & Canada.
http://www.c1tracking.com/l.asp?cid=5511
http://us.click.yahoo.com/mOAaAA/3exGAA/qnsNAA/Sj.0lB/TM
---------------------------------------------------------------------~->
[Brought to you by HTTP://WWW.STOPNATO.ORG.UK]
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/du-watch/
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
du-watch-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
*****************************************************************
31 Records on DU Exposures Never Saw the Light of Day
Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2004 01:16:43 -0500 (CDT)
From: Kirt Love
UMRC Information Bulletin
http://www.umrc.net/UMRC_bulletin_07_Feb_2004.asp
February 6, 2004
Warning of uranium contamination risks to
NGO staff, Coalition forces, foreign contract
personnel and civilians in Iraq
February 6, 2004 Recently completed laboratory analyses show
two members of Uranium Medical Research Centre's (UMRC) field
investigation team are contaminated with Depleted Uranium (DU). The
two field staff, one from Canada and the other, Beirut, toured Iraq
for thirteen days in October 2003; five months after the cessation of
Operation Iraqi Freedom's aerial bombing and ground force campaign.
Using mass spectrometry, UMRC's partner laboratory in Germany measured
DU in both team members' urine samples.
The UMRC team surveyed US and British controlled combat areas
and bomb-sites in southern Iraq, including Baghdad, An Nasiriyah, As
Suweiriah and Al Basra (details can be found at UMRC.net, Abu Khasib
to Al Ah'qaf: Field Investigation Report). The conditions responsible
for the team's DU contamination are considered to be inhalation of
resuspended ultra-fine soil and dust particles saturated with uranium
and airborne uranium oxides and metallic particulate. Uranium was used
in anti-tank penetrators, suppression ordnance and bunker-defeat
warheads deployed during the 26 days of Operation Iraqi Freedom by
both US and UK forces. The contamination of UMRC's team members
occurring over a two-week period, many months after the main conflict,
represents a risk to civilians, non-governmental organisations' staff,
Coalition armed forces and foreign contractors and diplomatic staff.
In 1997, UMRC was the first study group to detect DU in the
urine of Canadian, British and US troops who served in Gulf War I. The
urinary excretion of battlefield uranium was identified six years
following exposure. In January 2004, the US Department of Veterans
Affairs admitted it had detected DU in the urine of US forces who are
not retaining DU shrapnel, in 2000, eight years after Desert Storm. In
2001 and again in 2002, UMRC measured high concentrations of
artificial uranium containing the synthetic isotope, 236U, in Afghan
civilians exposed to the detonation plumes of bombs deployed during
Operation Enduring Freedom.
In November 2003, the British Ministry of Defence (MOD) released
a formal statement to the Guardian disclaiming UMRC's Operation Telic
findings of high levels of radioactivity in British-led battlefields.
The MOD stated unequivocally that battlefield uranium residues remain
stable inside defeated Iraqi tanks and cannot be made biologically
available to humans. Since then, the MOD has found unusually high
concentrations of uranium excreted in the urine of its 1st Armoured
Division troops who served in Basra (September 2003, UK DU Oversight
Board Meeting minutes, Gulf Veterans Illnesses Unit, UK Ministry of
Defence). The MOD's recent findings in its troops now deployed back to
Germany, coupled with the contamination of UMRC's staff demonstrate
the need to initiate immediate solutions to protect exposed civilians
and foreign personnel in Iraq.
Preliminary results of UMRC's laboratory analysis of field
samples of civilian urine, soils and water samples indicate uranium
contamination in several Iraqi cities and battlefields. Details of
UMRC's findings from US and British controlled battlefields and
bombsites will be released later this month (February 2004). UMRC has
offered its assistance to the United Nation's Environment Program
(UNEP) to guide UNEP's post-conflict study team to radiologically
contaminated bombsites and battlefields in Iraq and Afghanistan. UMRC
urges UNEP to undertake immediate studies and lead the implementation
of a radiation protection program for Iraqi and Afghan civilians as
well as a supervised environmental clean-up program, as early as
possible.
For information:
T Weyman
Iraq Field Team Lead
Info@UMRC.net
*****************************************************************
32 [RADFOOD] good news and action item
Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2004 01:41:11 -0500 (CDT)
*GOOD NEWS: NEW YORK STATE UNITED TEACHERS UNION REJECTS IRRADIATED
MEAT*
On April 7, 2004 the New York State United Teachers union passed a
resolution calling for:
1) a moratorium on the use of irradiated meat in school food programs
until the long-term effects on children have been studied and
documented
2) distribution of factual, accurate and current information on food
irradiation to parents and guardians
3) notification to parents and guardians in those schools where
irradiated meat is or is intended to be used
This resolution is not binding, but is a strong recommendation to the
state Department of Education not to purchase irradiated meat.
click on the following link to read the text of the resolution
http://www.citizen.org/documents/nysutresolution.pdf
*TAKE ACTION! FAX PUBLIX!*
One of the most prominent food irradiation companies, SureBeam,
recently went bankrupt. While SureBeam supplied many of the national
supermarket chains with irradiated meat, there are still other companies
in the business. Publix is still stocking irradiated meat, and needs to
hear from their shoppers that this is a bad choice.
The company that Publix gets it's irradiated meat from - Food
Technology Service - uses Cobalt 60 (a nuclear material) to irradiate.
There are a host of problems with Cobalt 60 food irradiation facilities,
especially for surrounding communities. In addition to a long list of
accidents impacting workers and surrounding communities, the presence of
cobalt 60 raises serious security questions for neighbors of such
facilities. The Federation of American Scientists modeled the
detonation of a foot-long rod of Cobalt obtained from a food irradiation
plant, and found that it would result in the contamination of 1000
square kilometers, with a 10% risk of death from cancer for residents
living inside a 300-city block area for 40 years following the
detonation.
We need to pressure Publix to keep irradiated meat off their shelves.
Tell Publix that it is irresponsible to support a technology that has
negative impacts on your health and the safety of communities burdened
with irradiation facilities! Publix stores are located in Florida,
Alabama, Georgia, South Carolina, and Tennessee.
SEND A FREE FAX TO PUBLIX FROM OUR WEBSITE:
http://www.citizen.org/fax/background.cfm?ID=319&source=12
********************
If you would like to be removed from the radfood list, send an email to listserv@listserver.citizen.org with the words "unsubscribe radfood" in the message.
If you would like to be added to the radfood list, send an email to listserv@listserver.citizen.org with the words "subscribe radfood" in the message.
To learn more about food irradiation, visit our website at http://www.citizen.org/cmep/
Questions about the radfood list can be directed to RADFOOD-request@LISTSERVER.CITIZEN.ORG
-Public Citizen's Critical Mass Energy and Environment Program
*****************************************************************
33 DU contaminated vets return from Iraq
Date: Mon, 19 Apr 2004 01:46:40 -0500 (CDT)
Will DU be the "Agent Orange" of Iraq?
===
http://www.nydailynews.com/front/v-pfriendly/story/180333p-156685c.html
New York Daily NewsPoisoned?
By JUAN GONZALEZ
DAILY NEWS STAFF WRITER
Saturday, April 3rd, 2004
Four soldiers from a New York Army National Guard company serving in Iraq
are contaminated with radiation likely caused by dust from depleted
uranium shells fired by U.S. troops, a Daily News investigation has
found.
They are among several members of the same company, the 442nd Military
Police, who say they have been battling persistent physical ailments that
began last summer in the Iraqi town of Samawah.
"I got sick instantly in June," said Staff Sgt. Ray Ramos, a Brooklyn
housing cop. "My health kept going downhill with daily headaches,
constant numbness in my hands and rashes on my stomach."
A nuclear medicine expert who examined and tested nine soldiers from the
company says that four "almost certainly" inhaled radioactive dust from
exploded American shells manufactured with depleted uranium.
Laboratory tests conducted at the request of The News revealed traces of
two manmade forms of uranium in urine samples from four of the soldiers.
If so, the men - Sgt. Hector Vega, Sgt. Ray Ramos, Sgt. Agustin Matos and
Cpl. Anthony Yonnone - are the first confirmed cases of inhaled depleted
uranium exposure from the current Iraq conflict.
The 442nd, made up for the most part of New York cops, firefighters and
correction officers, is based in Orangeburg, Rockland County. Dispatched
to Iraq last Easter, the unit's members have been providing guard duty
for convoys, running jails and training Iraqi police. The entire company
is due to return home later this month.
"These are amazing results, especially since these soldiers were military
police not exposed to the heat of battle," said Dr. Asaf Duracovic, who
examined the G.I.s and performed the testing that was funded by The News.
"Other American soldiers who were in combat must have more depleted
uranium exposure," said Duracovic, a colonel in the Army Reserves who
served in the 1991 Persian Gulf War.
While working at a military hospital in Delaware, he was one of the first
doctors to discover unusual radiation levels in Gulf War veterans. He has
since become a leading critic of the use of depleted uranium in warfare.
Depleted uranium, a waste product of the uranium enrichment process, has
been used by the U.S. and British military for more than 15 years in some
artillery shells and as armor plating for tanks. It is twice as heavy as
lead.
Because of its density, "It is the superior heavy metal for armor to
protect tanks and to penetrate armor," Pentagon spokesman Michael
Kilpatrick said.
The Army and Air Force fired at least 127 tons of depleted uranium shells
in Iraq last year, Kilpatrick said. No figures have yet been released for
how much the Marines fired.
Kilpatrick said about 1,000 G.I.s back from the war have been tested by
the Pentagon for depleted uranium and only three have come up positive -
all as a result of shrapnel from DU shells.
But the test results for the New York guardsmen - four of nine positives
for DU - suggest the potential for more extensive radiation exposure
among coalition troops and Iraqi civilians.
Several Army studies in recent years have concluded that the low-level
radiation emitted when shells containing DU explode poses no significant
dangers. But some independent scientists and a few of the -Army's own
reports indicate otherwise.
As a result, depleted uranium weapons have sparked increasing controversy
around the world. In January 2003, the -European Parliament called for a
moratorium on their use after reports of an unusual number of leukemia
deaths among Italian soldiers who served in Kosovo, where DU weapons were
used.
I keep getting weaker. What is happening to me?
The Army says that only soldiers wounded by depleted uranium shrapnel or
who are inside tanks during an explosion face measurable radiation
exposure.
But as far back as 1979, Leonard Dietz, a physicist at the Knolls Atomic
Power Laboratory upstate, discovered that DU-contaminated dust could
travel for long distances.
Dietz, who pioneered the technology to isolate uranium isotopes,
accidentally discovered that air filters with which he was experimenting
had collected radioactive dust from a National Lead Industries Plant that
was producing DU 26 miles away. His discovery led to a shutdown of the
plant.
"The contamination was so heavy that they had to remove the topsoil from
52 properties around the plant," Dietz said.
All humans have at least tiny amounts of natural uranium in their bodies
because it is found in water and in the food supply, Dietz said. But
natural uranium is quickly and harmlessly excreted by the body.
Uranium oxide dust, which lodges in the lungs once inhaled and is not
very soluble, can emit radiation to the body for years.
"Anybody, civilian or soldier, who breathes these particles has a
permanent dose, and it's not going to decrease very much over time," said
Dietz, who retired in 1983 after 33 years as nuclear physicist. "In the
long run ... veterans exposed to ceramic uranium oxide have a major
problem."
Critics of DU have noted that the Army's view of its dangers has changed
over time.
Before the 1991 Persian Gulf War, a 1990 Army report noted that depleted
uranium is "linked to cancer when exposures are internal, [and] chemical
toxicity causing kidney damage."
It was during the Gulf War that U.S. A-10 Warthog "tank buster" planes
and Abrams tanks first used DU artillery on a mass scale. The Pentagon
says it fired about 320 tons of DU in that war and that smaller amounts
were also used in the Serbian province of Kosovo.
In the Gulf War, Army brass did not warn soldiers about any risks from
exploding DU shells. An unknown number of G.I.s were exposed by shrapnel,
inhalation or handling battlefield debris.
Some veterans groups blame DU contamination as a factor in Gulf War
syndrome, the term for a host of ailments that afflicted thousands of
vets from that war.
Under pressure from veterans groups, the Pentagon commissioned several
new studies. One of those, published in 2000, concluded that DU, as a
heavy metal, "could pose a chemical hazard" but that Gulf War veterans
"did not experience intakes high enough to affect their health."
Pentagon spokesman Michael Kilpatrick said Army followup studies of 70
DU-contaminated Gulf War veterans have not shown serious health effects.
"For any heavy metal, there is no such thing as safe," Kilpatrick said.
"There is an issue of chemical toxicity, and for DU it is raised as
radiological toxicity as well."
But he said "the overwhelming conclusion" from studies of those who work
with uranium "show it has not produced any increase in cancers."
Several European studies, however, have linked DU to chromosome damage
and birth defects in mice. Many scientists say we still don't know enough
about the long-range effects of low-level radiation on the body to say
any amount is safe.
Britain's national science academy, the Royal Society, has called for
identifying where DU was used and is urging a cleanup of all contaminated
areas.
"A large number of American soldiers [in Iraq] may have had significant
exposure to uranium oxide dust," said Dr. Thomas Fasey, a pathologist at
Mount Sinai Medical Center and an expert on depleted uranium. "And the
health impact is worrisome for the future."
As for the soldiers of the 442nd, they're sick, frustrated and confused.
They say when they arrived in Iraq no one warned them about depleted
uranium and no one gave them dust masks.
Experts behind News probe
As part of the investigation by the Daily News, Dr. Asaf Duracovic, a
nuclear medicine expert who has conducted extensive research on depleted
uranium, examined the nine soldiers from the 442nd Military Police in
late December and collected urine specimens from each.
Another member of his team, Prof. Axel Gerdes, a geologist at Goethe
University in Frankfurt who specializes in analyzing uranium isotopes,
performed repeated tests on the samples over a week-long -period. He used
a state-of-the art procedure called multiple collector inductively
coupled plasma-mass spectrometry.
Only about 100 laboratories worldwide have the same capability to
identify and measure various uranium isotopes in minute quantities,
Gerdes said.
Gerdes concluded that four of the men had depleted uranium in their
bodies. Depleted uranium, which does not occur in nature, is created as a
waste product of uranium enrichment when some of the highly radioactive
isotopes in natural uranium, U-235 and U-234, are extracted.
Several of the men, according to Duracovic, also had minute traces of
another uranium isotope, U-236, that is produced only in a nuclear
reaction process.
"These men were almost certainly exposed to radioactive weapons on the
battlefield," Duracovic said.
He and Gerdes plan to issue a scientific paper on their study of the
soldiers at the annual meeting of the European Association of Nuclear
Medicine in Finland this year.
When DU shells explode, they permanently contaminate their target and the
area immediately around it with low-level radioactivity.
*****************************************************************
34 Gallup Independent: Ex-workers have health problems
April 17, 2004
Still paying for the good ol'days
Part Two of Two
By Kathy Helms Diné Bureau
THOREAU John W. Hardy and his wife Sarah of Chinle have been
trying to get John's compensation for uranium-related illness for
the last 14 years, ever since the 1990 Radiation Exposure
Compensation Act came into being. Medically, he qualifies.
But when you add up the total amount of time he worked for
Arizona Mining Co. and El Paso Natural Gas, it amounts to only
seven Working Level Months (WLM) not enough to qualify.
Hardy, 78, said he worked over near the Grand Canyon "one whole
summer and through the winter back to the summer. I know we spent
a year there," he says. The last 14 years the couple have spent
searching for records to document Hardy's case.
But Melton Martinez, whose Eastern Navajo Uranium Workers office
has been trying to help, said, "He has a year in El Paso Natural
Gas but they're saying that El Paso Natural Gas did not go mining
until 1954. He worked for them from 1953 all the way into 1956,
and they're not counting that."
Translating for Hardy, Martinez said, "He's got a real bad lung
problem. He hasn't been able to really perform the duties he used
to do, like walking. He's got problems with just even walking, he
says. His breathing problem is pretty strong. They gave him an
oxygen bottle but now he's back to inhalers. He said he qualifies
from the medical, but he doesn't have enough time. And he's
really suffering from what he has done. They're telling us that
he has scarring in the lung, pulmonary fibrosis."
Sarah, her mom, dad and family lived at the mining site. She said
the company built a hut for the miners and their families, "one
long hut with separate rooms that's what they built for them over
at the mining site. They lived right there by the mining site for
over a year. He says they used to blast right nearby,"a
driveway's distance away, Martinez said. "That's how close they
were living and they were blasting and all of the dust used to
come over them." Nobody seemed to mind the dust. After all, it
was a job.
On the road The red rocks dance ahead as the truck rolls down the
rutted dirt road. Martinez is riding shotgun, pointing out
landmarks along the circuitous route that leads from Haystack to
Bluewater and back again ."This is Haystack Road we're on.
There's about 600 people living in this area," he said. "There
were a lot of sheep that were grazing in those areas where mining
had happened."
Haystack, the mountain, lay just ahead. It was named by
Martinez's grandfather, Paddy Martinez, who found the first
uranium there in April 1950. Directly across from Haystack
Mountain is another blip on the landscape a black-tipped mountain
with roads winding back and forth across its great expanse.
"It used to be a volcano. That tip right there at the top, it
used to be a big bowl-like, but now all of those people that
wanted gravel or whatever, they went up in there with heavy
equipment and big trucks and they started destroying it," hauling
it away by the truckload.
When the uranium mining was going on, Martinez said, "they will
blast and the dust will go up like maybe somewhere around 100-200
feet up in the air. And all of that dust will travel right into
where we're living, and we've been living there ever since our
grandfather," Martinez said. Whether gravel hauled from the
volcano was contaminated with radioactive dust is anybody's
guess.
Farther down the road is Martinez's house, situated on 160 acres
of allotted land with the sacred Mount Taylor in the distance. It
was his dad's land, and Grandfather Paddy's before that.
Martinez points to various landmarks along the way. "All of this
is Indian allotments. That's my sister's sheep. My brother's got
a whole bunch of goats. From this corner here is my aunt's land
but she passed away too. All of this is nothing but the kids
living and all of the elders gone."
Though he has been trying to get the Navajo Nation to test water
in the area, because it's allotted land, he said, "the Navajo
EPA, it seems like they're being blocked by that boundary line
the Navajo Reservation line. So they can't really step out of
there. I've been trying to get EPA out here. Finally they got to
Church Rock and they did some testing there. They did 12 wells
and only two of them passed, I heard. Then the other 10 are like
'for livestock only' like we don't eat the livestock ..." he said
sarcastically. "Somebody's going to eat it, no matter what. We
sell it from here, it goes down to market."
Soft, sweet water Just down the road is Martinez's Uncle Harold's
homesite. "My uncle was probably the first person that started
working for Anderson Development. Anderson started coming out
here and they started contracting out all of these mining
companies. They bought trucks. I think they had something like 80
trucks hauling ore. A whole bunch of Navajos worked there."
Martinez worked there too, as a laborer repairing tires, welding,
operating heavy equipment. "At that time I was just learning how
to use them big equipments. And then we'd go on a roadtrip after
those trucks. Wherever they'd break down, we tried to fix their
tires there and get them back on the road the transporters."
On the right-hand side of the road loomed a windmill and water
tank. "This water tastes real good. There's no water like it in
this world. So soft, sweet. It's real good water," Martinez said.
To the best of his knowledge, it's never been tested.
The truck rumbles through a farm gate. "This is private land that
my uncle leases. I think Kerr-McGee or somebody owns this
property, but we're grazing on it. They're leasing it," he said.
Goat Mountain is home to several doghole mines camouflaged amid
the weathered sandstone cliff. "You really can't see yellowcake
because it's mixed with sand," he said. "They used to call this
place Junior Mine, because the guy that owned it, his name is
Junior. He's a Navajo."
Doghole mines came long before those with contemporary square
openings. "Way back in the 50s they weren't really using lumber
and stuff like that to brace the hole that they were digging, so
they made it kind of like round-shaped so the ground would hold
itself. You don't have to put no lumber inside. As they came
closer to modern mining they started making it square and they
started putting posts in there, lumber, mesh wire, stuff like
that. That's how they started making all kinds of tunnels.
"We used to walk into the mines far back," Martinez said as he
climbed toward Junior Mine. "But now it's starting to change. The
mines are starting to fill up with sand." At one time, it was
possible to stand upright and walk into the dogholes. Not
anymore. Junior Mine also has a distinct odor, he said. "I don't
know if you can smell it or not, but it smells like rusted
metal."
Next stop, Wasteland About four to five miles from Goat Mountain
is the haul road leading past a former Kerr-McGee mine site and
Anderson Development to Ambrosia Lake "Ambrosia Lake had a town
here. It was probably somewhere around 200-300 people. They had a
trailer park. They even had a cafe. It's just a ghost town now.
"The thing too that happened, this whole place is dead. Look at
it the whole area became a wasteland. The grass used to grow
thick in here, but now there's nothing. It rains but I don't know
what happened to the grass. All of this area is probably
contaminated off of the mill tailings manmade mountains,"
Martinez said.
He pointed to an area adjacent to the highway intersection across
from the mill site. "All this was where they used to stockpile
the uranium ore higher than those telephone posts mountains of
ore just waiting for shipment. Usually what a company did is if
they hit low-grade uranium, they would just stockpile it until
they hit a real rich bed, and what they would do is mix it to get
more tonnage. There used to be a restaurant right there."
Near one of the mine sites is a power substation. "I'm not sure
what they're going to do with all of this electricity they put
up. They're probably going to leave it here and wait for Bush to
decide when to start mining again," Martinez said. Weekend April
17, 2004 Selected Stories: Couple hit by train, man dies Tribal
council to consider just who is Navajo Still paying for the good
ol' days Man burned to death after fiery wreck on rez School,
tribe try for more native culture
Giant employee still critical, but doing better First Navajo
Nation voting deadline
the Gallup Independent feedback on this website and the paper in
[gallpind@cia-g.com]
*****************************************************************
35 New York Daily News: G.I.s press Army for uranium test
Juan Gonzalez Exclusive:
Email: jgonzalez@ edit.nydailynews.com
[jgonzalez@edit.nydailynews.com]
How The News broke the story.
Hundreds of soldiers back from Iraq have asked the Army to test
them for radiation exposure after the Daily News revealed four
members of a New York Army National Guard unit are contaminated
with depleted uranium.
Up to 800 G.I.s already have handed in their 24-hour urine
samples, and hundreds more are waiting for appointments,
according to a source at Walter Reed Army Medical Center.
But several independent uranium experts who reviewed one of the
first official lab results that Walter Reed doctors provided to a
soldier last week are questioning whether the Army's testing
methods are adequate.
"They are using an instrument that apparently isn't very
accurate," said Glen Lawrence, a professor of biochemistry at
Long Island University.
"The instruments they used are just not sophisticated enough to
give accurate readings," agreed Leonard Dietz, a retired
scientist from the Knolls Atomic Laboratories who invented one of
the instruments for measuring uranium isotopes.
The demand for tests was sparked by a News investigation that
found four soldiers from the 442nd Military Police Company are
contaminated with radiation likely caused by dust from depleted
uranium shells fired by U.S. troops.
One of the soldiers, Staff Sgt. Ray Ramos, was told at Walter
Reed last week that the Army's testing of his urine had come back
negative.
Ramos, who has suffered for months from unexplained ailments,
demanded copies of reports from the two Army labs that analyzed
his urine.
One lab reported that different uranium isotopes in the sample
were "not detectable."
The other lab listed an error ratio so large in its analysis that
it was impossible to tell for certain whether the uranium in
Ramos' urine was natural, depleted or enriched.
"We know the way this data is reported can be confusing," said
Lt. Col. Mark Melanson, the program manger for health physics at
the second lab.
The main issue, Melanson said, is how much total uranium was
found in Ramos - and his total was 6.3 nanograms (parts per
billion) per liter.
That "is within the dietary ranges reported by the Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention and is safe," Melanson said.
The Army, according to Melanson, does not even bother to analyze
a sample for depleted uranium unless the total natural uranium
concentration is more than 268 nanograms per liter.
"That's an extraordinarily high cutoff," said Dr. Tom Fasy, a
pathologist at Mount Sinai Medical Center.
When told of the criticisms of the Army's methods, Melanson
said, "As an additional check, we are sending samples to the CDC
for independent analysis."
This is not the first time the Army's depleted uranium screening
operation has come under scrutiny. Last December, two congressmen
demanded an investigation of the program by the General
Accounting Office.
Reps. Ciro Rodriguez (D-Tex.) and Robert Filner (D-Calif.)
charged the Defense Department has previously misled
investigators about soldiers' depleted uranium exposure during
the 1991 Persian Gulf War.
Originally published on April 19, 2004
All contents © 2004 Daily News, L.P.
*****************************************************************
36 BBC: Nuclear sub surfaces in Arctic
Last Updated: Monday, 19 April, 2004
[HMS Tireless]
HMS Tireless has been a focus for protests
A Royal Navy nuclear submarine has surfaced at the North Pole
after weeks beneath the ice.
The Plymouth-based HMS Tireless returned to the Arctic Ocean for
the first time in eight years for operational exercises with the
US navy.
A civilian scientist is with the crew on board to monitor global
warming effects on the polar cap.
The submarine has caused controversy and drawn protest in the
past and was investigated after a collision at sea.
Scientist Nick Hughes from the Scottish Association for Marine
Science (SAMS) is on board the Tireless to take measurements of
the thickness of the ice underwater.
The permanent ice pack at the North Pole has retreated 100 miles
north in recent years and can thin in the summer to as little as
6ft.
Arctic walkabout
Ice on the Arctic has diminished by 40% in the past 20 years,
according to research.
For the past 30 years scientists from SAMS have travelled to the
Arctic when a Naval vessel goes so they can monitor the effects
of global warming.
The Royal Navy said the vessel's 130 crew will be able to stretch
their legs and take in the extraordinary beauty of the Arctic
wilderness during the surfacing.
The last time the craft surfaced was at the French port of Brest
in February.
A Royal Navy spokesman said: "They've been crammed on board the
sub under the ice for weeks so they'll be dying to go for a
walkabout.
Bear danger
"Let's hope there's not too many polar bears about."
A previous US submarine mission crew had to watch in amazement as
one inquisitive bear chewed the fin and external casing of their
vessel.
The Tireless has caused controversy in the past.
In May 2003 it was taken to Scotland for repairs and prompted a
Ministry of Defence inquiry after it collided with an object at
sea.
The craft has also been a target for anti-nuclear protesters in
Plymouth who attempted to break into a naval base in 2003.
In 2001, its presence in Gibraltar put a strain on relations with
Spain and caused outrage among environmentalists.
*****************************************************************
37 ITAR-TASS: Security at Moscow’s nuclear facilities raises concerns
[ITAR-TASS News Agency of Russia]
19.04.2004, 20.20
MOSCOW, April 19 (Itar-Tass) -- The Federal Service of Atomic
Supervision has expressed concern about security at nuclear
facilities in Moscow.
The service’s spokesman, Valery Rozhnov, told Itar-Tass on
Monday, “There are 11 research reactors in Moscow, the combined
capacity of which is 20 megawatt … and part of them are
operating at higher educational institutions where it is hard to
cerate conditions for effective control over the production of
radioactive materials.”
He stressed, “Such nuclear facilities as the Moscow Institute of
Engineering and Physics, which works with radioactive materials
on a daily basis, have a critical bench of two megawatt. The
productions generated by this bench may pose a threat if they
fall into the hands of potential terrorists.”
In his words, “This requires constant control over the
activities of the institute by our service and its compliance
with our recommendations.”
The Federal Atomic Energy Agency told Itar-Tass, “There is a
number of operating commercial reactors in Moscow that make
radioactive isotopes for various purposes, including medical
ones, which may be used in a ‘dirty nuclear bomb’.”
Federal Atomic Energy Agency spokesman Nikolai Shingarev said,
“It is necessary to introduce strict control over isotope
products made in Moscow and experiments that involve radioactive
materials”.
In his view, physical protection of these facilities and the
transportation of radioactive materials “are not properly
financed.”
© ITAR-TASS. All rights reserved. You undertake not to copy,
*****************************************************************
38 Salt Lake Tribune: No more nuclear waste
April 19, 2004
I read "Hanford nuclear site workers' concerns prompt
investigation of facility, protocol" (Tribune, April 10) with
Rocky Flats and a number of other facilities that were used to
manufacture uranium and plutonium for the nation's nuclear
weapons are now contaminated with highly radioactive waste that
no one wants. Turns out, a lot of this waste has been dumped in
Utah.
An issue that is frequently glossed over in discussions of
resuming nuclear testing is waste generation. As the article
discusses, the cleanup at Hanford is expected to cost upward of
$50 billion in taxes and will not be finished until 2035 at
best. The administration is seeking nearly $30 million for the
construction of a new Hanford, known as the Modern Pit Facility.
What deadly waste and contamination will be generated there? How
much will the cleanup and decontamination of that site cost?
Could any of that waste be slated for Utah?
In upcoming months, Sens. Bennett and Hatch will have the
opportunity to vote on whether to appropriate funding for this
new nuclear bomb factory. If our senators are serious about
representing Utahns' interests, they will vote against funding
the Modern Pit Facility and against all government activities
that pave the way toward resuming nuclear weapons testing.
Vanessa Pierce
Salt Lake City
">
Copyright Salt Lake City Tribune
*****************************************************************
39 Zwire: EPA to revise Foote Mineral cleanup plan
[http://www.zwire.com
Monday 19 April, 2004
See all stories on this topic:
NATION watching Diablo nuclear plant lawsuit
Kansas City Star (subscription) - Kansas City,MO,USA
By DAVID SNEED. San Luis Obispo County has quickly become a national test
case for public involvement in nuclear power plant safety. ...
KIM Jong-il may face nuclear quiz
The Age - Melbourne,Victoria,Australia
... yesterday for talks with Chinese leaders, who may raise recent reported
disclosures by a Pakistani scientist exposing his regime's nuclear weapons
activity. ...
See all stories on this topic:
SECURITY at Moscow ’ s nuclear facilities raises concerns
ITAR-TASS - Moscow,Russia
MOSCOW, April 19 (Itar-Tass) -- The Federal Service of Atomic Supervision
has expressed concern about security at nuclear facilities in Moscow.
...
See all stories on this topic:
DROP wind farm plans for nuclear says report
The Scotsman - Edinburgh,Scotland,UK
ENVIRONMENTALISTS today attacked a report suggesting nuclear power as a
more viable option than wind farms to provide Scotland with power. ...
See all stories on this topic:
FOUR ARRESTED IN ANTI-NUCLEAR PROTEST IN OAK RIDGE
WBIR-TV - Knoxville,TN,USA
... Complex in Oak Ridge. Three of those arrested yesterday were protesting
nuclear weapons research at the plant. The fourth person ...
See all stories on this topic:
NO more nuclear waste
Salt Lake Tribune - Salt Lake City,UT,USA
I read "Hanford nuclear site workers' concerns prompt investigation of
facility, protocol" (Tribune, April 10) with great interest. ...
See all stories on this topic:
S.KOREA eyes China's booming nuclear power market
Forbes - USA
SEOUL, April 19 (Reuters) - South Korea's state-run nuclear power firm
said on Monday it had formed a consortium with local companies to bid
for nuclear power ...
See all stories on this topic:
FAZL blames Ahmedis for plotting against nuclear programme
Pakistani Newspaper - Pakistan
... of Muttahida Majlis-e-Amal (MMA), Maulana Fazlur Rehman has alleged
that Qadianis (Ahmedis) are conspiring with US to eliminate the nuclear
programme of the ...
NRC renews Progress' SC Robinson nuclear plant
Forbes - USA
NEW YORK, April 19 (Reuters) - Progress Energy Inc. (nyse: PGN - news -
people) said Monday the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission approved a new
20-year ...
This daily-once News Alert is brought to you by Google News (BETA)...
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Remove this News Alert:
http://www.google.com/newsalerts/remove?s=92d1672a1b037a07&hl=en
Create another News Alert:
http://www.google.com/newsalerts?hl=en
Try Google News:
http://news.google.com/
*****************************************************************
46 Scotsman.com: Wind power 'will cost taxpayer millions'
[http://www.scotsman.com/]
Mon 19 Apr 2004
Scotland’s largest wind farm, near Peebles, may not have the
economic and ecological benefits that have been promised, says a
new report. Picture: David Cheskin/PA
JAMES REYNOLDS ENVIRONMENT CORRESPONDENT
THE publication this week of a new report into renewable energy
is set to raise serious questions over the economic and
ecological benefits of wind power.
According to the leading economist Professor David Simpson, the
government’s strategy to promote wind power as a means of
reducing carbon emissions is fundamentally flawed.
His report Tilting at Windmills, a copy of which has been
obtained by The Scotsman, goes on to suggest that nuclear power
could be a better option for the future, as long as there was an
"acceptable waste management strategy".
Conducted on behalf of the influential Edinburgh-based think tank
the David Hume Institute (DHI), the paper also claims using
so-called "green power" would cost the taxpayer millions of
pounds more than conventional power sources.
In February last year, Tony Blair, the Prime Minister, announced
a strategy to promote greener forms of energy in a bid to reduce
carbon dioxide emissions by more than 60 per cent in the next 50
years.
Pledges to put a five-year block on planning new nuclear power
stations and increase renewable energy sources such as wind and
wave power were broadly welcomed by environmental pressure groups
at the time.
However, others dismissed the white paper as a "policy-free zone"
and insisted "intermittent and unproven" renewable resources were
no answer to Britain’s need for reliable, continuous
electricity.
The new paper, a severe criticism of the government’s
commitment to produce 20 per cent of electricity from renewable
resources by 2020, predicts the consequences of investing in
renewables will have costs over and above those of conventional
fuelled energy.
Prof Simpson writes: "Achieving a target of 20 per cent of
electricity generated by wind power would cost consumers at least
an extra £1.2 billion each year, and over £2 billion annually
on less favourable assumptions."
He adds that because of the cost of providing additional stand-by
generating capacity - when the wind doesn’t blow - it is
unlikely wind power will ever account for more than 20 per cent
of electricity generation.
However, Scottish Renewables, a trade association representing
the renewable energy industry, last night dismissed the report as
"a one-sided diatribe masquerading as an authoritative academic
study".
Jason Ormiston, a spokesman for the organistion, said: "The
simple truth is that wind energy is clean, economic and has an
important role, alongside other renewables and energy efficiency,
in helping the UK in meeting climate change targets."
For and against: Prof Simpson's arguments, and the answers from
Scottish Renewables
HERE are Professor David Simpson’s arguments with responses
from the industry representative body, Scottish Renewables. He
claims that:
The cost of generating electricity from wind power is twice that
of the cheapest conventional alternative source. By 2010 the cost
of subsidising renewable forms of energy will be about £1
billion a year.
Response: This figure is correct, but the price support for
renewables is paid for through the markets by suppliers and
reflects the premium paid for green energy. Prof Simpson fails to
quantify the high cost to society/environment of pollution from
conventional generation.
The government promotes wind energy through the Renewable
Obligations scheme, the cost of which is some 2 per cent and
falls on electricity companies who pass it on to consumers in
higher bills.
Response: The RO is designed to support electricity generation
that has little or no environmental cost, whereas conventional
generation is cheaper because it does not pay for other social
and environmental costs.
It is generally accepted that wind power will become competitive,
but projections show that by 2020 a generation portfolio
containing 20 per cent wind power will still cost more than a
conventionally fuelled alternative.
Response: The cost of wind power is falling and will continue to
fall.
Achieving a target of 20 per cent of electricity generated by
wind power would cost consumers at least an extra £1.2 billion
each year, and more than £2 billion on less favourable
assumptions.
Response: A recent EU study found that wind power had the least
additional cost to society.
It is most unlikely that realising the official targets for the
output of renewables, of which wind power is the principle
component, is the lowest cost way of achieving reductions in CO2
emissions.
Response: Renewable energy is one of several ways of tackling CO2
emissions. The government has set CO2 reduction targets for 2020,
and expects 50 per cent of the cut to come from energy
efficiency. Renewables will be 20 per cent of this cut.
Between now and 2010 overall CO2 emissions are expected to resume
an upward path reflecting increasing emissions from the transport
and household sectors and from power generation because of run
down of nuclear power.
Response: This sounds like an argument for more renewable energy.
Denmark has increased GNP by 28 per cent since 1990 whilst CO2
emissions have fallen by 11 per cent in the same period.
A serious attempt to address the issue of a reduction in CO2
emissions has yet to begin. When it does, it may raise wholesale
electricity prices by up to 60 per cent in five years.
Response: Unsubstantiated claim. Renewables will lead to a modest
increase in prices of 2 per cent. If price shocks do occur they
will come from price hikes in conventional generation.
Because of the cost of providing additional stand-by generating
capacity, it is unlikely wind power will ever account for more
than 20 per cent of electricity generation through the National
Grid, and will make no substantial contribution to a reduction in
carbon emissions.
Response: Combined with other renewables like hydro and biomass a
significant cut in emissions can be expected.
No matter how large the wind power capacity, the variable nature
of its output means it can make no significant contribution to
security of energy supply.
Response: The key to security of supply is to have a mixture of
different renewables working alongside conventional generation.
All forms of generation have strengths and weaknesses.
A 20 per cent share for wind and other renewables in power
generation will require a major re-engineering of the electricity
transmission and distribution networks, costing an extra £2.5 to
£4.5 billion.
Response: Much of Scotland’s electricity grid was planned and
built over 50 years ago. There has been chronic under investment
so, yes, investment is needed, but why have a 21st century
electricity system using old worn-out grid lines?
The government should take advantage of the renewables review
coming up in 2005-6 to reconsider the nuclear option.
Response: Nuclear fuel is not a renewable source of power so
should not form part of the review.
Nuclear power avoids extra costs, emits no greenhouse gasses, and
contributes to security of supply.
Response: Nuclear power has many problems of its own. After 50
years the public do not support nuclear energy.
Wind power may have a valuable role in locations where grid
connections are too expensive, notably in remote and
sparsely-populated areas.
Response: Small wind energy schemes can help isolated communities
toward energy self-sufficiency whilst on a larger scale help cut
emissions significantly, meet future demand and create thousands
of jobs.
[http://webfeeds.scotsman.com
*****************************************************************
NOTE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107 this
material is distributed without profit or payment to those who
have expressed a prior interest in receiving this information for
non-profit research and educational purposes only. For more
information go to:
*****************************************************************